I compared Dunkin's new Beyond Meat breakfast sandwich with the real deal and was surprised to find the plant-based 'meat' was better - here's why

Advertisement
I compared Dunkin's new Beyond Meat breakfast sandwich with the real deal and was surprised to find the plant-based 'meat' was better - here's why

Dunkin bag

Irene Jiang / Business Insider

Dunkin' is now serving a plant-based "meat" breakfast sandwich.

Advertisement

On Wednesday, Dunkin' became the first chain to serve Beyond sausage for breakfast.

Dunkin's new Beyond sausage breakfast sandwich is now available at the chain's locations in Manhattan, New York, and will eventually be served nationwide, according to an announcement from the chain.

Beyond Meat CEO Ethan Brown told Business Insider's Kate Taylor that the company's partnership with Dunkin' is part of an effort to democratize the plant-based "meat" trend and make Beyond Meat products available to a wider range of consumers.

I, a consumer, was skeptical when I heard of this odd couple. When I think of Dunkin', I think of donuts.

Advertisement

Read more: I ate the bacon, egg, and cheese biscuits from 4 major fast-food chains, and the winner surprised me

But as Business Insider's resident chow chomper, I had a solemn duty to give Dunkin's new Beyond sausage breakfast sandwich a fair chance.

I made my way to a nearby Dunkin' restaurant, and after a brief ordering snafu, I lugged my haul of two sandwiches back to the office. On the table: Dunkin's new Beyond sausage breakfast sandwich and its standard sausage breakfast sandwich.

Here's how they compared:

{{}}

Two peas in a pod are nothing alike. While the accoutrements are the same, the sausages look very different.

Two peas in a pod are nothing alike. While the accoutrements are the same, the sausages look very different.

Dunkin's sausage breakfast sandwich is hot, greasy, and heavy.

Dunkin's sausage breakfast sandwich is hot, greasy, and heavy.
Advertisement

The buttered and toasted English muffin is soft, the fried egg characteristically overcooked, and the cheese as lopsided as the top bun was before I adjusted it to look nicer.

The buttered and toasted English muffin is soft, the fried egg characteristically overcooked, and the cheese as lopsided as the top bun was before I adjusted it to look nicer.

The real meat sausage is thinner and wider than its Beyond counterpart.

The real meat sausage is thinner and wider than its Beyond counterpart.
Advertisement

The cheese and sausage carry most of the flavor load while the egg and muffin function more as sidekicks.

The cheese and sausage carry most of the flavor load while the egg and muffin function more as sidekicks.

That means the sausage has to be full of flavor — and it is. It's juicy, fatty, spiced, and really, really salty. Almost too salty.

That means the sausage has to be full of flavor — and it is. It's juicy, fatty, spiced, and really, really salty. Almost too salty.
Advertisement

Overall, the real meat sausage breakfast sandwich delivers the umami kick you crave from a sandwich of its kind. However, it did leave me feeling the tickle of nascent heartburn.

Overall, the real meat sausage breakfast sandwich delivers the umami kick you crave from a sandwich of its kind. However, it did leave me feeling the tickle of nascent heartburn.

Read more: I ate the same meal at both Texas Roadhouse and Outback Steakhouse, and one was the clear winner

The Beyond patty is thicker but smaller in circumference, and it's a lighter shade of brown.

The Beyond patty is thicker but smaller in circumference, and it's a lighter shade of brown.
Advertisement

The patty looks noticeably different from Dunkin's meat sausage, but it also looks like some meat sausages I've eaten in the past.

The patty looks noticeably different from Dunkin's meat sausage, but it also looks like some meat sausages I've eaten in the past.

Upon first bite, the Beyond sausage tastes like meat. But chewing it reveals that it's not.

Upon first bite, the Beyond sausage tastes like meat. But chewing it reveals that it's not.
Advertisement

Although Beyond has done an excellent job of creating a meat-like texture to its sausage, there's a noticeable pea-like aftertaste. It also isn't bursting with salt and fat like the real sausage is.

Although Beyond has done an excellent job of creating a meat-like texture to its sausage, there's a noticeable pea-like aftertaste. It also isn't bursting with salt and fat like the real sausage is.

The Beyond sausage has a clear plant-based taste and a milder flavor than the real sausage, but it feels better in digestion. If it were saltier and fattier, it'd more closely mimic the flavor of the meat sausage, but I'm not sure I'd want it to.

The Beyond sausage has a clear plant-based taste and a milder flavor than the real sausage, but it feels better in digestion. If it were saltier and fattier, it'd more closely mimic the flavor of the meat sausage, but I'm not sure I'd want it to.
Advertisement

I'd say that the real meat sausage sandwich still tastes better. After all, the breakfast sandwich recipe was crafted around it. But Beyond's sausage isn't really much worse. It just tastes more like the suggestion of sausage than like a real sausage.

I'd say that the real meat sausage sandwich still tastes better. After all, the breakfast sandwich recipe was crafted around it. But Beyond's sausage isn't really much worse. It just tastes more like the suggestion of sausage than like a real sausage.

If I hadn't had the meat sausage as reference, I might have been fooled by the Beyond sausage. And when it comes down to it, the Beyond sandwich gave me everything I wanted out of a sausage breakfast sandwich without the carbon footprint of beef. It's the one I'll order next time.

If I hadn't had the meat sausage as reference, I might have been fooled by the Beyond sausage. And when it comes down to it, the Beyond sandwich gave me everything I wanted out of a sausage breakfast sandwich without the carbon footprint of beef. It's the one I'll order next time.
Advertisement
Next StoryWe went grocery shopping at Walmart and Whole Foods and saw how Amazon's $13.7 billion bet is failing to beat the superstore in price and selection