I flew on one of the 'worst airlines in America'. Here's why I'd do it again.

Advertisement
I flew on one of the 'worst airlines in America'. Here's why I'd do it again.

Frontier Airlines Airbus A320

Frontier Airlines

A Frontier Airlines Airbus A320. Not the exact plane I flew on.

Advertisement
Advertisement
  • Frontier Airlines is one of many ultra-low-cost airlines in the US offering passengers cheaper fares than what major carriers charge.
  • But there's a catch to flying one such airline, especially one that has often been ranked as one of the worst in the country.
  • I recently flew from San Francisco, California, to Austin, Texas, aboard a Frontier flight.
  • Here's why it was a painfully mediocre experience - and why I would still most likely do it again, under certain conditions.
{{}}

As this was my first year living out of my home state, I needed to get home to Texas for Christmas, and I knew from the start that I’d be looking at an expensive flight home.

As this was my first year living out of my home state, I needed to get home to Texas for Christmas, and I knew from the start that I’d be looking at an expensive flight home.

I wasn't thrilled, since the holidays are typically one of the most expensive times to fly in the US.

I wasn't thrilled, since the holidays are typically one of the most expensive times to fly in the US.

Source: Kayak

Advertisement

Since I was on a budget, I looked into some budget airlines. These airlines allow thrifty passengers like yours truly to book a flight for less than what other big airlines offer.

Since I was on a budget, I looked into some budget airlines. These airlines allow thrifty passengers like yours truly to book a flight for less than what other big airlines offer.

One of these airlines was Frontier, an ultra-low-cost airline.

One of these airlines was Frontier, an ultra-low-cost airline.

Source: Business Insider

Advertisement

Flying on an ultra-low-cost airline entails not paying much for the flights themselves ...

Flying on an ultra-low-cost airline entails not paying much for the flights themselves ...

Source: Frontier

... but you payy for literally everything else, like carry-on bags, seat selections, and in-flight Coca Colas.

... but you payy for literally everything else, like carry-on bags, seat selections, and in-flight Coca Colas.

Source: Frontier

Advertisement

Frontier has also been ranked on several occasions as one of the country's worst airlines.

Frontier has also been ranked on several occasions as one of the country's worst airlines.

Source: Forbes, Business Insider, Business Insider, MarketWatch, MSN, Wall Street Journal

Reports of poor customer service and on-time performance are just some of the factors plaguing the airline, though improvements have been made recently.

Reports of poor customer service and on-time performance are just some of the factors plaguing the airline, though improvements have been made recently.

Source: TripAdvisor

Advertisement

Airline site The Points Guy ranked Frontier the fifth best US airline out of ten in 2018, up from the second worst in 2017.

Airline site The Points Guy ranked Frontier the fifth best US airline out of ten in 2018, up from the second worst in 2017.

Source: The Points Guy and The Points Guy

But, all of that aside, it's still a budget airline and is a viable option for those looking to fly in a specific price range.

But, all of that aside, it's still a budget airline and is a viable option for those looking to fly in a specific price range.
Advertisement

We're talking $20 one-way ticket specials throughout the year, though I wasn't lucky enough to snag one of those.

We're talking $20 one-way ticket specials throughout the year, though I wasn't lucky enough to snag one of those.

Source: Travel + Leisure

But I still managed to snag a well-priced ticket when I decided to fly Frontier home to Texas for Christmas 2018.

But I still managed to snag a well-priced ticket when I decided to fly Frontier home to Texas for Christmas 2018.
Advertisement

I started in the Frontier app and punched in my destination details to look for flights.

I started in the Frontier app and punched in my destination details to look for flights.

These were my search results. I opted for the flight that cost $178.80, one way.

These were my search results. I opted for the flight that cost $178.80, one way.
Advertisement

The itinerary required a 4-hour layover in Denver, which I wasn't thrilled about.

The itinerary required a 4-hour layover in Denver, which I wasn't thrilled about.

The ticket was cheap for the busy and expensive holiday season.

The ticket was cheap for the busy and expensive holiday season.

Source: Insider and Kayak

Advertisement

But Frontier is a "no frills" airline with a big focus on an "a la carte" payment system. Meaning you pay extra if you want to select a seat, check a bag, and bring a carry-on.

But Frontier is a "no frills" airline with a big focus on an "a la carte" payment system. Meaning you pay extra if you want to select a seat, check a bag, and bring a carry-on.

Source: Frontier

Paying for baggage online well before your flight is cheaper.

Paying for baggage online well before your flight is cheaper.
Advertisement

You'll pay $38 for a checked bag or a carry-on bag if you purchase the baggage during the period between booking and 24 hours before check-in.

You'll pay $38 for a checked bag or a carry-on bag if you purchase the baggage during the period between booking and 24 hours before check-in.

If you wait until you get to the airport ticket counter, you're looking at a $50 charge for either. Also, "elite" frequent flyers get a free checked and a free carry-on bag per flight.

If you wait until you get to the airport ticket counter, you're looking at a $50 charge for either. Also, "elite" frequent flyers get a free checked and a free carry-on bag per flight.
Advertisement

Since it was the same price for both, and I was going to be home for two weeks, I chose to purchase a checked bag for $38, sending my total flight costs to $216.80.

Since it was the same price for both, and I was going to be home for two weeks, I chose to purchase a checked bag for $38, sending my total flight costs to $216.80.

This was my baggage situation — a large suitcase that I would check and a small (and free!) "personal item" holding my laptop and other things.

This was my baggage situation — a large suitcase that I would check and a small (and free!) "personal item" holding my laptop and other things.
Advertisement

I checked into my flight 24 hours before departure, and my mobile boarding passes appeared in my Frontier app.

I checked into my flight 24 hours before departure, and my mobile boarding passes appeared in my Frontier app.

The airline also highly stresses the need to get to the airport at least two hours before departure. Reminders pop up in the emails for your flight reservations and are displayed on the airline's website and on signs at the airport.

The airline also highly stresses the need to get to the airport at least two hours before departure. Reminders pop up in the emails for your flight reservations and are displayed on the airline's website and on signs at the airport.

Source: Frontier

Advertisement

So I showed up to San Francisco International Airport at 10 a.m., about three hours before my scheduled departure.

So I showed up to San Francisco International Airport at 10 a.m., about three hours before my scheduled departure.

I found a row of Frontier self-service kiosks when I walked in.

I found a row of Frontier self-service kiosks when I walked in.
Advertisement

I had my mobile boarding pass ...

I had my mobile boarding pass ...

... but I was curious if Frontier charged passengers for printed ones at the airport like its fellow budget airline Spirit reportedly did at one point.

... but I was curious if Frontier charged passengers for printed ones at the airport like its fellow budget airline Spirit reportedly did at one point.

Source: Inc and TripAdvisor

Advertisement

But the kiosk spat my boarding passes out at me without asking for payment.

But the kiosk spat my boarding passes out at me without asking for payment.

I collected my boarding passes and headed to the ticket counter to check my suitcase.

I collected my boarding passes and headed to the ticket counter to check my suitcase.
Advertisement

To my right I could see the ticket counter for Southwest Airlines ...

To my right I could see the ticket counter for Southwest Airlines ...

... and to my left was Delta's. Even from afar I could see the counter decked out in Christmas decorations.

... and to my left was Delta's. Even from afar I could see the counter decked out in Christmas decorations.
Advertisement

My airline's counter was a tad less festive. It was about 10:30 a.m. at this point, and the counter was completely unstaffed.

My airline's counter was a tad less festive. It was about 10:30 a.m. at this point, and the counter was completely unstaffed.

But I figured that since I was told to show up two hours ahead of departure that someone would arrive by 11 a.m., so I waited patiently.

But I figured that since I was told to show up two hours ahead of departure that someone would arrive by 11 a.m., so I waited patiently.
Advertisement

Others weren't so patient. Some began angrily calling Frontier customer service phone lines, and one woman went to an information center in the airport to find some answers.

Others weren't so patient. Some began angrily calling Frontier customer service phone lines, and one woman went to an information center in the airport to find some answers.

Another woman claimed that she had even missed her flight because the Frontier ticket counter had been unstaffed for so long.

Another woman claimed that she had even missed her flight because the Frontier ticket counter had been unstaffed for so long.
Advertisement

Eventually a Frontier representative showed up when I was expecting: around 11 a.m.

Eventually a Frontier representative showed up when I was expecting: around 11 a.m.

But I wasn't sure if it was because airport staff had been notified of the counter's lack of attendance or because that's when the attendant had planned to arrive at the desk.

But I wasn't sure if it was because airport staff had been notified of the counter's lack of attendance or because that's when the attendant had planned to arrive at the desk.
Advertisement

The attendant was also snide and rude, dismissing passengers that complained to her about the lack of attendance.

The attendant was also snide and rude, dismissing passengers that complained to her about the lack of attendance.

The attendant explained that the Frontier employees who work the ticket counter also double as gate agents.

The attendant explained that the Frontier employees who work the ticket counter also double as gate agents.
Advertisement

Frontier's website advises passengers that check-in for each flight closes 45 minutes prior to departure. So if the woman who claimed she missed her flight showed up to check her bag past that time, it would make sense as to why she had missed her flight.

Frontier's website advises passengers that check-in for each flight closes 45 minutes prior to departure. So if the woman who claimed she missed her flight showed up to check her bag past that time, it would make sense as to why she had missed her flight.

Source: Frontier.

The attendants that were staffing the ticket counter would have had to move to the gate counters to assist passengers there.

The attendants that were staffing the ticket counter would have had to move to the gate counters to assist passengers there.
Advertisement

A Frontier Airlines representative later told me in an email that staff rotation in an airport, from the ticket counter to departure gate, is "industry standard."

A Frontier Airlines representative later told me in an email that staff rotation in an airport, from the ticket counter to departure gate, is "industry standard."

Since I had been at the counter at least two hours before my scheduled departure, I was fine. I made it through security and to my gate with plenty of time to spare.

Since I had been at the counter at least two hours before my scheduled departure, I was fine. I made it through security and to my gate with plenty of time to spare.
Advertisement

But the whole incident left me frazzled. Did this happen often with Frontier passengers? I charged my phone and read a book until boarding started.

But the whole incident left me frazzled. Did this happen often with Frontier passengers? I charged my phone and read a book until boarding started.

I had the lowly "Zone 3" stamped on my boarding pass, so I waited my turn to queue up at the gate.

I had the lowly "Zone 3" stamped on my boarding pass, so I waited my turn to queue up at the gate.
Advertisement

This was only the beginning of the wait time I'd endure throughout the day.

This was only the beginning of the wait time I'd endure throughout the day.

Onward into the cabin!

Onward into the cabin!
Advertisement

For the flight from San Francisco to Denver, I'd be flying on an Airbus A320, one of Frontier's 84 aircraft in its all-Airbus fleet.

For the flight from San Francisco to Denver, I'd be flying on an Airbus A320, one of Frontier's 84 aircraft in its all-Airbus fleet.

The airline's average fleet age is about 4 years old.

Source: Air Fleets

I made my way toward my seat, which reminded me more of a lawn chair than an airplane seat.

I made my way toward my seat, which reminded me more of a lawn chair than an airplane seat.
Advertisement

Here's a side view of seats on a separate Frontier flight. They were thin, with hardly any backing, and unlike the more cushioned seats I've encountered on other flights, these seats were tough.

Here's a side view of seats on a separate Frontier flight. They were thin, with hardly any backing, and unlike the more cushioned seats I've encountered on other flights, these seats were tough.

These "lawn chairs" are actually slimline seats airlines around the world have been using in recent years to save weight and create space for additional rows of seating on an aircraft.

These "lawn chairs" are actually slimline seats airlines around the world have been using in recent years to save weight and create space for additional rows of seating on an aircraft.
Advertisement

I didn't pay to select my seat, so I was assigned 27B, a middle seat. But I got lucky — a passenger sat to my left but no one sat to my right in the aisle seat. I scooted over to claim it before we took off.

I didn't pay to select my seat, so I was assigned 27B, a middle seat. But I got lucky — a passenger sat to my left but no one sat to my right in the aisle seat. I scooted over to claim it before we took off.

As usual for flights of this length, there were no pillows or blankets waiting for me at my seat. However, the tray tables were not what I usually find on other airlines I've flown with.

As usual for flights of this length, there were no pillows or blankets waiting for me at my seat. However, the tray tables were not what I usually find on other airlines I've flown with.
Advertisement

They were dirty, small, and didn't slide out toward you so you could eat over your plate if you were to buy food.

They were dirty, small, and didn't slide out toward you so you could eat over your plate if you were to buy food.

I did have plenty of legroom, though my legs are short. The seat pitch — the amount of room between two rows of seats — for the standard economy section was 28 to 29 inches.

I did have plenty of legroom, though my legs are short. The seat pitch — the amount of room between two rows of seats — for the standard economy section was 28 to 29 inches.

Source: Frontier

Advertisement

That's less than what you'd find on most major carriers, where seat pitch is usually north of 30 inches. There weren't any first-class or business-class seats, only "stretch" seats where passengers can pay to get up to 38 inches of pitch.

That's less than what you'd find on most major carriers, where seat pitch is usually north of 30 inches. There weren't any first-class or business-class seats, only "stretch" seats where passengers can pay to get up to 38 inches of pitch.

Source: Business Insider

My personal item fit under the seat in front of me. I was worried about having to shell out an extra $38 to upgrade it to a carry-on if a flight attendant deemed it too big, but no one even checked to see if it was within proper dimensions.

My personal item fit under the seat in front of me. I was worried about having to shell out an extra $38 to upgrade it to a carry-on if a flight attendant deemed it too big, but no one even checked to see if it was within proper dimensions.
Advertisement

I looked up to find familiar airplane features — no smoking signs and other indicators.

I looked up to find familiar airplane features — no smoking signs and other indicators.

There also weren't any back-of-seat TV screens, since the airline had done away with them back in 2015 to free up weight on the aircrafts. I usually keep busy on flights by watching movies, so I was a bit peeved that I couldn't do that.

There also weren't any back-of-seat TV screens, since the airline had done away with them back in 2015 to free up weight on the aircrafts. I usually keep busy on flights by watching movies, so I was a bit peeved that I couldn't do that.

Source: Business Insider

Advertisement

Luckily I had the menus to entertainment myself.

Luckily I had the menus to entertainment myself.

Here's another aspect of Frontier's "no frills" experience.

Here's another aspect of Frontier's "no frills" experience.
Advertisement

Nothing is complimentary, except water. Snacks and non-alcoholic drinks go for $2.99 a pop. Cocktails and spirits run for $7.99 each. I defied the system and vowed to wait until we landed to find food.

Nothing is complimentary, except water. Snacks and non-alcoholic drinks go for $2.99 a pop. Cocktails and spirits run for $7.99 each. I defied the system and vowed to wait until we landed to find food.

The approximately two-hour flight was uneventful and boring. We landed on time at Denver International Airport, where Frontier Airlines is based.

The approximately two-hour flight was uneventful and boring. We landed on time at Denver International Airport, where Frontier Airlines is based.

Source: Frontier

Advertisement

I got a better look at the lawn chair-looking seats on the way off the plane.

I got a better look at the lawn chair-looking seats on the way off the plane.

I couldn't get over how strange and outdated they looked. They also were far from comfortable. They didn't recline, my backside grew numb midway during the flight, and even if I were tired, sleep would have been out of the question.

I couldn't get over how strange and outdated they looked. They also were far from comfortable. They didn't recline, my backside grew numb midway during the flight, and even if I were tired, sleep would have been out of the question.
Advertisement

I disembarked from the first leg of my journey at around 4:30 p.m. MT.

I disembarked from the first leg of my journey at around 4:30 p.m. MT.

The assigned gate, A40, for the next leg was serving passengers for other flights.

The assigned gate, A40, for the next leg was serving passengers for other flights.
Advertisement

I scoped out the area of the airport where I'd be spending the next four hours, give or take.

I scoped out the area of the airport where I'd be spending the next four hours, give or take.

I've never had such a lengthy layover while flying.

I've never had such a lengthy layover while flying.
Advertisement

My total travel time from baggage drop-off in San Francisco to baggage claim in Austin, Texas, was about 10 hours.

My total travel time from baggage drop-off in San Francisco to baggage claim in Austin, Texas, was about 10 hours.

Four of those hours were spent wandering around the Denver airport keeping myself busy.

Four of those hours were spent wandering around the Denver airport keeping myself busy.
Advertisement

It's not the worst airport to be stuck in though.

It's not the worst airport to be stuck in though.

The Wall Street Journal named the Denver International Airport the best in the country in 2018.

The Wall Street Journal named the Denver International Airport the best in the country in 2018.

Source: Denver Post

Advertisement

I grabbed a glass of wine at Denver ChopHouse & Brewery ...

I grabbed a glass of wine at Denver ChopHouse & Brewery ...

... had way too much fun on those moving walking path things ...

... had way too much fun on those moving walking path things ...
Advertisement

... and meandered to an upper level where the airline lounges were located.

... and meandered to an upper level where the airline lounges were located.

I looked up to see passengers lounging comfortably in the exclusive airline clubs. Lucky ducks.

I looked up to see passengers lounging comfortably in the exclusive airline clubs. Lucky ducks.
Advertisement

I chose a row of cold, hard-lined seats instead ...

I chose a row of cold, hard-lined seats instead ...

... and settled in for a long winter's nap.

... and settled in for a long winter's nap.
Advertisement

Though it was difficult to snooze with bright florescent lights shining down on me and people walking by so often.

Though it was difficult to snooze with bright florescent lights shining down on me and people walking by so often.

So I took to Netflix to pass the time. I highly recommend Ellen Degeneres's most recent standup comedy special.

So I took to Netflix to pass the time. I highly recommend Ellen Degeneres's most recent standup comedy special.
Advertisement

I grabbed some snacks from an airport shop before finally making it to my gate.

I grabbed some snacks from an airport shop before finally making it to my gate.

This time my destination of Austin was displayed below the gate number. I was weary and tired at this point.

This time my destination of Austin was displayed below the gate number. I was weary and tired at this point.
Advertisement

I was again one of the last to board, since I was Zone 3.

I was again one of the last to board, since I was Zone 3.

This plane was a 14-year-old Airbus A319. My seat this time was the window seat in row 23.

This plane was a 14-year-old Airbus A319. My seat this time was the window seat in row 23.

Source: Air Fleets

Advertisement

I was looking at a seat pitch of 28 to 29 inches again, and seats were arranged in a 3-3 layout like before.

I was looking at a seat pitch of 28 to 29 inches again, and seats were arranged in a 3-3 layout like before.

Source: Frontier

The lawn chairs were back ...

The lawn chairs were back ...
Advertisement

... as were the microscopic tray tables.

... as were the microscopic tray tables.

The legroom was the same ...

The legroom was the same ...
Advertisement

... and like last time, my personal item fit snugly under the seat in front of me without incident.

... and like last time, my personal item fit snugly under the seat in front of me without incident.

Finally, at 11:02 p.m. CT, about 10 hours after I'd checked my suitcase in San Francisco, we landed in Austin, Texas. Home at last!

Finally, at 11:02 p.m. CT, about 10 hours after I'd checked my suitcase in San Francisco, we landed in Austin, Texas. Home at last!
Advertisement

Frontier had recently switched operations to the South Terminal of the Austin-Bergstrom International Airport. I walked across the tarmac toward baggage claim, passing other Frontier aircraft.

Frontier had recently switched operations to the South Terminal of the Austin-Bergstrom International Airport. I walked across the tarmac toward baggage claim, passing other Frontier aircraft.

Source: KXAN

I didn't have to wait long for my giant green suitcase to appear on the conveyer belt.

I didn't have to wait long for my giant green suitcase to appear on the conveyer belt.
Advertisement

And so my first experience flying Frontier came to an end.

And so my first experience flying Frontier came to an end.

In short, it was ... mediocre. Painfully mediocre.

In short, it was ... mediocre. Painfully mediocre.
Advertisement

Simply put, I got what I paid for.

Simply put, I got what I paid for.

Flying with a budget airline like Frontier seems to be the best option when you don't have any bags to check or carry on, ...

Flying with a budget airline like Frontier seems to be the best option when you don't have any bags to check or carry on, ...
Advertisement

... if you don't value being served complimentary food and drinks while in-flight ...

... if you don't value being served complimentary food and drinks while in-flight ...

... and if you don't mind long layovers.

... and if you don't mind long layovers.
Advertisement
Next StoryThe deadline to file your taxes is April 15 in every state except Maine and Massachusetts