I know I am part of Apple's iPhone problem but even after doing all my research, I still don't feel the need to upgrade

Advertisement
I know I am part of Apple's iPhone problem but even after doing all my research, I still don't feel the need to upgrade

iPhone 7-Plus

Nick Bastone / Business Insider

Advertisement
  • At the beginning of January, Apple announced that its holiday quarter revenue would be 7% lower than expected due to weakening iPhone sales.
  • Not having upgraded my 7 Plus for over two years, I know I am part of Apple's iPhone problem.
  • So, I made a trip to my local Apple Store and did some research to see if I should finally upgrade to an iPhone XR or XS. Here's what I decided.

I am part of Apple's iPhone problem.

You see, I own a perfectly fine iPhone 7 plus that I've had for over two years, and I feel no pressure to upgrade.

Complimentary Tech Event
Transform talent with learning that works
Capability development is critical for businesses who want to push the envelope of innovation.Discover how business leaders are strategizing around building talent capabilities and empowering employee transformation.Know More

My screen isn't cracked. All the apps I need are running smoothly (despite the occasional crash). And I like to think that my photos still stand up to my friends' who shoot with their new, notch-laden iPhone XR and XS.

Bah humbug! I'm sticking with my 7!

Advertisement

I was curious, though, how much it would cost to upgrade and would that cost be justified?

The Face ID feature to open a locked screen seems nice (my thumbprint only works 50% of the time when it's sunny out and 0% when it's raining). And maybe having Portrait Mode on the front facing camera would help make me look less awkward in selfies. Maybe not.

Anyways, I headed to my local Apple store in San Francisco's Union Square to figure out if I should finally upgrade or not.

Here's what I found:

{{}}

If I were to buy the cheapest of Apple's new phones — the 64 GB iPhone XR — my monthly fee would be $37.41 through its financing program.

If I were to buy the cheapest of Apple's new phones — the 64 GB iPhone XR — my monthly fee would be $37.41 through its financing program.

That $37.41 is exactly what I was paying per month for my 7 Plus.

But since I haven't upgraded my phone for over two years, my monthly payments are no longer. Starting last September, I owned my phone outright and have been paying $0 to Apple since.

So, if I were to upgrade, I'd have to get used to a monthly payment again.

If I traded in my 7 Plus (which is in good condition), I would receive a $300 credit through Apple's GiveBack program.

If I traded in my 7 Plus (which is in good condition), I would receive a $300 credit through Apple's GiveBack program.

That credit could be used for future monthly payments and paying taxes on my next phone.

Shoot! I always forget about the taxes. Let's figure that out real quick.

The 64 GB XR retails for $749, and the sales tax in San Francisco is 8.5%. So to walk out the door with my new XR, I would have to pay $63.67 in taxes.

Advertisement

After taxes, I would have $236.33 left from my trade-in credits, which would be enough to cover my first six months of fees on my new XR. That's not bad!

After taxes, I would have $236.33 left from my trade-in credits, which would be enough to cover my first six months of fees on my new XR. That's not bad!

But, do I really want an XR?

But, do I really want an XR?

I wasn't impressed with the look or feel of that phone.

According to the specs, my 7 Plus is thinner and lighter than the XR and actually has a higher resolution display.

Advertisement

If I were to upgrade, I'd go with the 256 GB XS Max which comes out to $60.33 per month through Apple's financing program.

If I were to upgrade, I'd go with the 256 GB XS Max which comes out to $60.33 per month through Apple's financing program.

That's quite a bit more expensive per month than the XR and after taxes on the $1249 XS Max, I would only have three free months from my trade-in credit.

Going from $0 to $60.33 per month is a hefty difference. And for what reason?

My 7 Plus is still looking good!

My 7 Plus is still looking good!

I'm proud that even without a case (those get in the way of how a phone is supposed to feel), I only have minor scratches.

Also, my battery life is still holding strong. And as the Apple employee kindly reminded me, if my battery does deteriorate, I can replace it with a new one for just $49.

Further, even with improvements to the newer cameras in the XR and XS, I still stick by the quality of shots I'm able to capture with my 2.5-year-old "clunker."

I'm not sure what it'll take for me to finally upgrade from my 7 Plus — maybe if those intermittent app crashes become more consistent or god forbid, my AirPods can't connect.

But for now, I'll happily continue to be in upgrade limo and a poster boy for Apple's current iPhone problem.

Advertisement