It Is Perfectly Moral To Torture A Robot
Kyle Russell/Business Insider
Knight arrives at the conclusion that humans and robots need each other to be at their most productive - robots are efficient workers that never get bored, and humans have the proper sense to give the robots well-defined instructions on what to do, or else they wouldn't do anything at all.
Early in the paper, Knight addresses the question of how humans "ought" to treat machines. She argues that "the more we regard a robot as a social presence, the more we seem to extend our concepts of right and wrong to our [behavior] toward them."
In other words, understand that robots relate to the world entirely differently from people, but treat them the way you'd like to be treated yourself. It's the golden rule, after all, and Knight suggests it (rather importantly) applies to robots as well. Not out of any sense of decency to the robots, but because of what such behavior would suggest about us as people:
As Carnegie Mellon ethicist John Hooker once told our Robots Ethics class, while in theory there is not a moral negative to hurting a robot, if we regard that robot as a social entity, causing it damage reflects poorly on us. This is not dissimilar from discouraging young children from hurting ants, as we do not want such play behaviors to develop into biting other children at school.
So there's no direct harm in torturing a machine, but it's pretty unpleasant to manifest torture in the real world. It's unattractive, no?
- CEO says he tried to hire an AI researcher from Meta, and was told to 'come back to me when you have 10,000 H100 GPUs'
- We bought a house in Japan for $30,000. We'll have more land than we could afford in the US, and our kids will be more independent.
- Rumors Prince William is having an affair with Rose Hanbury are flooding social media again after Stephen Colbert waded into 'Katespiracy'
- Electrifying auto market: Planning to buy an EV, compare their price with petrol, diesel and CNG variants
- Bank of Japan ends decades-long negative interest policy
- Realme Narzo 70 Pro with Dimensity 7050, 5,000mAh battery launched in India
- Popular Vehicles shares make weak market debut; decline nearly 2% in opening trade
- TCS shares tank over 3% after Tata Sons divests 0.65% stake