The Acura NSX is Business Insider's 2016 Car of the Year

Hollis Johnson/Skye Gould

The wait is over! Business Insider's 2016 Car of the Year is the Acura NSX.

The new NSX beat out the fiercest competition in the three-year history of our award. It is a worthy, exciting winner and a triumph for Honda, Acura's parent company. But the NSX also revived one the greatest stories in the history of the automobile. And by the way, this mid-engine supercar from a Japanese brand is actually an all-American machine, designed in California and proudly built in Ohio.

Here's the backstory. In the 1990s, Honda was on top of the world. Its Accord and Civic sedans were selling like hotcakes. While the brand, as a whole, had established a reputation for building technologically advanced cars with rock-solid reliability. On the performance front, Honda-powered Formula One race cars had reeled off six straight constructors' world championships.

It was time for a halo product - a crown jewel in the Honda's lineup.

In 1990, that's exactly what happened with introduction of the New Sportscar eXperimental or NSX. The first generation Honda NSX - sold under the Acura luxury brand name in the US - was a true game changer. It proved that the Honda could build a state-of-the-art supercar capable of taking on the best Europe had to offer, but with Japanese reliability. Many industry observers point to the original NSX as one of the driving forces behind the quality and performance of modern day Ferraris, Porsches, and Lamborghinis. In fact, the NSX even served as the benchmark for McLaren's groundbreaking, 240-MPH F1 hypercar.

End of the road?

In 2005, Honda ended the original NSX's 15-year tour of duty and the wait for a successor commenced. First, Honda planned to replace the NSX with a front-engined V10 supercar, but the financial crisis put an end to that. Then, the successor was reincarnated as a mid-engined V6 show car. However, when the decision was made to add turbochargers and a hybrid system for more power, the car was once again redesigned because the orientation of the engine had to change for cooling purposes.

After a decade of waiting, a new NSX finally arrived, and we got our hands on one of Honda/Acura's pre-production prototypes.

The process

At Business Insider, we don't have extensively scientific criteria for selecting what we feel were the best cars of 2016 - we currently lack the testing facilities for anything like that. But we do consider each finalist in terms of three important questions: Was the vehicle compelling to drive? Did it stand apart from the competition? And did it involve a strong business case for the automaker that created it?

At first we were skeptical. After all, movies requiring this many re-shoots rarely take home Oscars. In addition, we were concerned that the new car has abandoned the original NSX's lightweight simplicity in favor of a complex hybrid drive system.

Furthermore, the automotive landscape has changed considerably since 2015. In 1990, 300 horsepower and the ability to hit 60 mph from a standstill in 5 seconds meant you had enough chips to play with the big boys. But these days, we live in an era of 700-horsepower family-hauling muscle sedans and 6,000 pound SUVs capable of ripping off 0-6o runs in 4 seconds.

Over the years, Honda and Acura have changed as well. The company, still an industry leader, has had a few more misses than hits of late. The company's bread-and-butter Accord and Civic sedans are no-longer sure bets while its once-niche CR-V crossover has become to company's new breadwinner.

Acura has endured its share of troubles. The brand has struggled to keep up with rivals from Japan and Germany in terms of sales, performance, and prestige.

At the end of the day, none of those concerns materialized because the NSX proved to be stunningly good to look at, joyful to drive, and easy to live with. We also sampled the NSX in three distinct settings: on the road, on the race track with Transportation Reporter and longtime NSX enthusiast Benjamin Zhang behind the wheel, and on another track with a pro driver at the controls, while Senior Correspondent Matt DeBord hung on for dear life in the passenger seat.

Simply glorious

Set eyes on the NSX's sheet metal once and you can't help but look again. The design isn't classically beautifully, like a vintage Pininfarina-designed Ferrari, but its striking aesthetic is attractive in its own right. In a year where we've had Ferraris, Porsches, Rolls-Royces, and Teslas roll through our suburban New Jersey auto test center, no car generated as much attention from the general public as the NSX.

Behind the wheel, Acura's decision to go with hybrid tech was a stroke of genius. Generating 573 horsepower, the twin-turbocharged V6 offered on-demand power with little complaint. With traction going to all-four wheels, the NSX proved to highly forgiving - offering endless grip around corners.

In addition, the NSX's advanced hybrid drive unit represents the first time we've seen such a system in a supercar with a price tag south of $1 million.

Once again, Honda and Acura will have a halo product - a stunning, eye-catching supercar to get buyers in the showroom and to stroke the egos of the brand's owners. It's a car that will set the pace and the tone for Honda and Acura in the coming years.

A great car - from a great year

It's been a great year for the auto industry. Audi's new MLB Evo platform hit its stride with the world-class A4 sedan and Q7 SUV, while Ferrari's turbocharging revolution arrived with the new 488 GTB. Meanwhile, Cadillac is revitalized with a new high-tech flagship sedan and crossover in the form of the CT6 and XT5. Jaguar and Maserati rolled out the first SUVs in their companies' histories, while McLaren's new Sports Series is expected to double the company's sales total in a few short years.

But when it was all said and done, Honda/Acura's NSX supercar stood victorious. We are proud to announce the 2017 Honda/Acura NSX as Business Insider's 2016 Car of the Year. Congratulations!

Below, we present Matt's original review of the NSX. What a car!

Photos by Hollis Johnson.

Graphic by Skye Gould.