A small trinket or treat, gift box included
Create a gift box at Greetabl
Greetabl is a cool service that lets you choose an eye-catching box design and a gift (options range from $4 confetti to a $28 bracelet) to go inside it. Then, pick a few photos from your time together as a couple, write a personal message, and you have a small gift that may not be extravagant but is infinitely thoughtful.
A leather travel organizer
Medium Travel Organizer, $85 + $10 monogram, available at Leatherology
Leatherology's full-grain leather travel bag will become their favorite thing to pack in their carry-on. It includes a zipped mesh storage pocket, elastic loops for their cords and bottles, and a water-resistant lining for maximum durability. Brown and black are classic, beautiful colors, but don't be afraid to go out of the box with a bright Turmeric or Cobalt (shown above).
A trip to anywhere in the world, done their way
Plan a personalized trip, from $25 per day, available at Journy
Maybe you both prefer experiences to a physical gift. In that case, a Journy custom travel itinerary — complete with sightseeing spots, restaurant recommendations, and hotel reservations, all based on your budget and what you like to do on your dream vacation — fits the bill. You'll work one-on-one with an experienced planner to create a trip to remember.
next slide will load in 15 secondsSkip AdSkip AdA physical representation of your favorite shared memories
Their own virtual personal stylist
Gift Card, from $20, available at Stitch Fix
Everyone's personal style is different, which is why no two Stitch Fix boxes are the same. The average price for men's and women's items is $55, but they can set their own budget to receive clothes they're comfortable with, and you can give a gift card in amounts up to $1,000.
A diffuser that only emits their favorite scents
A custom candy bento box
Design a 4-Piece Bento Box, $34, available at Sugarfina
Pre-made candy gift boxes inevitably contain at least one piece or flavor your recipient doesn't like. With Sugarfina's customizable bento boxes, not a single gummy or chocolate will go to waste because you pick the candy types yourself. Choose from 100 creative candies like Tequila Grapefruit Sours and Red Velvet Caramels to satisfy the tastes of your sugar fiend.
A suit cut to their exact proportions
next slide will load in 15 secondsSkip AdSkip AdA fluffy, embroidered towel
Bath Towel, $58 + $15 embroidery, available at Weezie
Gift the first towel you see off a shelf, and you probably won't have a next Valentine's Day to look forward to. Gift the fluffy, personalized, luxury towels from Weezie, and they won't be able to stop talking about them for Valentine's Days to come.
A print that displays the intersection of your names
The best way for vinyl lovers to discover new music
Three-Month Gift Membership Subscription, $99.97 (originally $120), available at VNYL
VNYL's team of curators studies your music profile — assembled via a quiz and connected Spotify, Soundcloud, Instagram, etc. — to hand-pick new albums that they think you'll love. Then, they send you a vinyl record of their tailored pick to your door. If your giftee is a music-lover and has a record player, this is a cool subscription that will help them discover even more music to love.
An engraved shaving set
Winston Set, $25 + $15 engraving, available at Harry's
The once-ordinary ritual of shaving every morning turns into a luxurious experience with this Harry's Set (containing a weighty chrome finish razor handle, sharp but gentle blades, foaming shave gel, and travel cover) on hand. A three-character engraving on the handle confirms its ownership — and trust us, he'll be possessive.
next slide will load in 15 secondsSkip AdSkip AdA personalized curation of wine
Gift Card, from $60, available at Winc
The California-based company both creates its own wine and curates bottles from top vineyards, and it subscription program sends three full bottles of wine based on your recipient's "Palate Profile." Its community rating system also points them to new names to try.
An engravable bar necklace
A pillow to help them sleep well at night
A cute twist on a classic game
Personalized Hearts Four-Across Game, $75, available at UncommonGoods
The game of Connect Four never gets old, but this personalized version brings a refreshing and loving twist, replacing the spaces with hearts, names, and dates. You can also pick the chip color. Though playing it on Valentine's Day is a must, you can, of course, bring it out anytime for some fun competition.
A custom mug and the coffee to go with it
next slide will load in 15 secondsSkip AdSkip AdA monogrammed marble and wood serving board
A soft and silky cashmere robe
New beauty and grooming samples to try every month
A map poster of somewhere special to them
Customized Poster, $49, available at Grafomap
Grafomap is a website that lets you design posters with maps of any place in the world. You can make one of their hometown, their favorite travel destination, or the place where you met, and hone in on particular spots. If you're looking for a map gift but don't love Grafomap, there are seemingly endless options on both Etsy here and Uncommon Goods here.
Vitamins suited to their body and needs
3-Month Subscription, $90, available at Care/of
Vitamins were never so giftable before Care/of. Its business centers around personalization, down to the name and message printed on the vitamin pack. Your purchase also provides mothers in need with prenatal vitamins.