5 of the top-rated equity fund managers in the US share their blueprints for consistently crushing the market - and the best ways to replicate their success

Advertisement
5 of the top-rated equity fund managers in the US share their blueprints for consistently crushing the market - and the best ways to replicate their success

charts trader screen

Lucas Jackson/Reuters

  • Business Insider spoke to five of the top-rated US equity fund managers to learn about their strategies, strongest convictions in the market, and advice for other investors looking to replicate their success.
  • The funds featured below received perfect scores in Lipper's assessment of total return, consistent return, capital preservation, expense, and tax efficiency.
  • Visit Business Insider's homepage for more stories.

With $17.7 trillion in assets still managed by US mutual funds, reports of the industry's death are premature.

Sure, it's shrinking as money gushes into exchange-traded funds. But a select group of fund managers have established track records that demonstrate why many investors still rely on the professionals to grow their money.

Advertisement

Business Insider interviewed five of the top-rated fund managers as screened by Lipper, which rates funds across five categories that capture the most important attributes investors want in a money manager: total return, consistent return, capital preservation, expense, and tax efficiency.

The funds featured below received a 5/5 score in all of these criteria.

We learned about each manager's strategies, the stand-out stocks boosting their performance versus peers, and the best advice they have for investors who want to replicate their success.

Advertisement

{{}}

Andrea Frazzini, portfolio manager, AQR US Defensive Equity Fund

Andrea Frazzini, portfolio manager, AQR US Defensive Equity Fund

Frazinni manages $3.2 billion at AQR, one of the world's largest hedge funds. He also co-leads the global stock selection team that generates forecasting models.

His overarching goal is to hold a diverse slate of American companies that can survive in any market environment.

His investing style mirrors AQR's well-known adoption of quant strategies. Beyond the firmwide approach, he is influenced by his other job as an adjunct professor of finance at New York University's Stern School of Business.

"A lot of what we do comes straight out of academia," Frazinni told Business Insider. "We develop theories and testable hypotheses, then use our findings and economic theory as guidance to build our portfolios."

Here's what that looks like: Frazinni lets his model make the decisions about which individual stocks to overweight or underweight. It forecasts stock-level risk — such as how connected a single stock's moves are to the broader market — and business risk, like cash flow or margins.

The model then assigns a score to every stock. From there, the scores are ranked from most to least risky such that the portfolio overweights safer securities and underweights the riskiest ones.

1-year return: 11.9%

Biggest company holdings (as of 3/31): PepsiCo, Starbucks, Coca-Cola, Procter & Gamble, and Johnson & Johnson.

Investing advice:

Frazzini says his investing is rooted in data instead of personal judgement and feelings.

"Whenever I think of a particular idea or concept we'd like to develop, I like to collect as much evidence as I can to essentially prove it wrong," he said.

Clare Hart, JPMorgan Equity Income Fund

Clare Hart, JPMorgan Equity Income Fund

Hart's investing strategy has been virtually unchanged in her 15 years managing the $21.9 billion JPMorgan Equity Income Fund.

She has always screened prospects for three main attributes: quality companies with a reasonable valuation that pay at least a 2% dividend yield.

Her refusal to waver on these three requirements has been met with pushback over the years — and she has stood by each of them even when the market demanded otherwise.

The defense for quality is almost a no-brainer: If a company is on track to go bankrupt, that's not a stock she wants to own.

On valuation, she looks for cheap stocks, but not the cheapest.

"I was investing during the tech bubble, the telecom bubble after, and the financial crisis," Hart told Business Insider. "I have seen cheap get cheaper, and cheap can get to zero if things go away."

She has also resisted pressure to increase the 2% yield requirement because doing so would raise the risk of buying overvalued stocks. Even when Apple prepared to announce its highly anticipated dividend in 2012, she did not buy the stock until she could confirm the yield met her requirement. While waiting, investors sold Apple shares to fund Facebook's initial public offering. It turned out to be a double win: a cheaper price and a satisfactory dividend yield.

Financial services companies make up the largest chunk of her portfolio, and they include a smorgasbord of asset managers, insurers, and regional banks.

1-year return: 5.47%

Biggest company holdings (as of 3/31): Merck, Chevron, Bank of America, Microsoft, and CME Group.

Investing advice: "Find the smart people, work with the smart people," Hart said.

She continued: "Don't be afraid of the people who tell you things you don't want to hear about your stocks. You want to talk to those people.

"For women, I think this industry is a good fit because if someone wants to be biased against you, it's harder if you really have a track record, you have numbers, you have performance, and you can show you know what you're doing," Hart said.

Advertisement

Mick Dillon & Bertie Thomson, Brown Advisory Global Leaders Fund

Mick Dillon & Bertie Thomson, Brown Advisory Global Leaders Fund

Dillon and Thomson co-manage a $211.4 million portfolio of companies across the world.

To them, the customer is the most important part of every company's value chain. That's why they put a premium on companies that solve customer problems in unique ways.

This criteria, and their go-anywhere capability, led them to invest in Bank Rakyat Indonesia, a microfinance lender that most US investors probably have never heard of.

"That company really solves customers' problems because otherwise they have no access to credit," Dillon told Business Insider. "These people are non-credit-worthy or outside the formal banking system. The average loan size is $1,000-$2,000."

Dillon and Thomson are also invested in companies more popular with US investors like Mastercard and Microsoft. Once they enter a position, they strive to maintain it for as long as possible to reap the benefits of compounding.

"To some extent, we are in the rejection game," Thomson said. "It's about saying no to a number of investments that come across our path."

Every company that does make the cut must pass four key tests: customer satisfaction, a strong return on invested capital, quality management, and a reasonable valuation.

1-year return: 4.97%

Biggest company holdings (as of 3/31): Microsoft, Visa, Alphabet, Unilever, and Mastercard.

Investing advice:

"One of the ways we make better investment decisions is by having a third-party coach who analyzes every decision we make," Dillon said.

He continued: "You rarely find elite athletes who don't have a coach. Airline pilots have coaches. If all these people who are at the top of their fields have coaches, then why don't investors?"

"A passion for companies and learning will stand you in very good stead in the industry," Thomson said. "If you don't have that passion and that excitement about learning, especially learning about different companies, it's probably not the career for you despite the attraction s that some people feel the industry has."

Eric Fischman, MFS Growth Fund

Eric Fischman, MFS Growth Fund

One of the first things Fischman examines in a candidate for his $22 billion fund is whether or not the company can raise prices in a recession.

After all, the growth fund he manages has a mandate to invest in companies that aren't tied to market cycles. That's why he says he'll probably never own commodities. And within the technology sector, the semiconductor industry isn't a prized corner because it's fortunes are linked to cyclical growth.

This approach means he's not easily motivated to sell out of companies — even when market conditions go south — so he keeps the turnover of the portfolio low.

"It enables us focus on the long term and not get whipped around by day-to-day market swings, tweets that might be coming out, or earnings misses or beats," he told Business Insider in an exclusive interview.

One stock that he has stuck with since 2002 — and one that serves as a poster child of his investing strategy — is American Tower. The company signs long-term contracts with cellphone providers to lease the tower space they need to beam network signals. Not only do the contracts guarantee recurring revenue, they come with built-in price escalators.

1-year return: 10.69%

Biggest company holdings (as of 3/31): Microsoft, Amazon, Visa, Adobe, and Alphabet.

Investing advice: "Make sure that you're investing in businesses that you understand. Understand how a business make money, understand how they're going to continue to make money in five years, and focus on that longer term," Fischman said.

He continued: "Don't get whipped around by the day-to-day or quarter-to-quarter events that are unfolding. If there's a company that you like the long-term outlook of and they miss a quarter, it doesn't necessarily mean anything. Something could have been going on that was unique to the business or a customer."

Advertisement