An analyst who thinks Tesla is worth $0 sees even more bad news in August's delivery numbers


Kim Kyung Hoon/Reuters

Inside a Tesla store

  • One of Tesla's most bearish analysts is doubling down on his $0 valuation in the wake of InsideEV's latest delivery estimate for the company.
  • "That story is clearly over," Ed McCabe of Highbridge Capital Management said of those who say Tesla is a growth company to justify losses and slowing growth.
  • Shares of Tesla have fallen 38% since their most recent high in December 2018. Follow the stock here.
  • Visit Business Insider's homepage for more stories.

Tesla's estimated deliveries for the month of August have the company's most bearish of Wall Street analysts on the edge of their seat as the end of the quarter approaches.

For Ed McCabe, head of equity trading at Highbridge Capital Management, InsideEV's estimates for August's numbers - showing another decline in Model 3 sales - proved that "organic demand is extremely weak," he said in a report Thursday.
"While there is no reasonable justification for a structurally unprofitable and horribly managed company to enjoy a $40 billion market cap, proponents of the stock tout its growth," he said. "That story is clearly over."

Tesla total monthly deliveries

Ed McCabe

Tesla's monthly deliveries for 2018 and 2019.

On its most recent quarterly update, Tesla reaffirmed guidance of between 360,000 and 400,000 deliveries worldwide for the full year of 2019. Halfway through the year, total sales were at roughly 158,000, or about half of the low end of that range.

However, McCabe says that even if Tesla hits these goals - it likely won't help the balance sheet.

Tesla stock price Markets Insider

Markets Insider

Shares of Tesla have fallen 38% since their most recent high in December 2018.

"To reach the low-end of guidance Tesla needs to average 103K deliveries in the remaining two quarters of the year," he said. "To reach the high-end it needs to average 123K. Both would exceed Tesla's second quarter record. Neither will happen. It's also irrelevant. The company is structurally unprofitable. The more cars Tesla sells the more money it loses."Now that there's more competition coming - like Porsche's new electric Taycan Turbo - things could get even worse, McCabe says.

"Remember that the staggering losses and cash burn have occurred while Tesla has had the electric vehicle market essentially to itself and Musk has promised imminent and sustainable profits and cash flow generation multiple times," he said.

"Back-to-back quarters of negative revenue growth, increasing losses, and cash burn will make plain to even the most ardent believers that Tesla is not a viable business."

Get the latest Tesla stock price here.