Harry's Texturizing Putty, $12
If you're looking for some flexibility, the Texturizing Putty from Harry's is a good choice. Once applied, it provides a good hold, but unlike a paste or pomade, you can reshape your hairstyle a bit later. For example, you may want a more professional look in the morning as you head into the office, but a more messy style for happy hour after work — this putty lets you do that.
At least, that's what I experienced during a full week of using it while on vacation. I didn't need a very strong hold, but I still wanted some style. The Texturizing Putty maintained my all-day messy look, yet kept my short, straight hair in place (instead of sticking up haphazardly), despite the hot, sweaty weather. My look in the evening definitely changed from what I started the day with, so it may not work for people who want a consistent look from day-to-night.
The pliable putty is very thick and you really need to dig into it, but a little is all you need. However, the putty works best on towel-dried hair. Don't worry if it clumps up — just massage it into the hair and shape (no combing here). It leaves a matte finish, and your hair won't ever look like it's been gelled to death. The scent isn't unpleasant, but it isn't my favorite of the new Harry's products; still, it's subtle when it's on your hands and you won't smell it throughout the day. Unlike L'Oréal's Studio Line Overworked Hair Putty, Harry's feels lighter.
I used to use a pomade from Baxter of California and Sumotech from Bumble & Bumble, and the reason why I stopped is because of how expensive they are. The Texturizing Putty costs less, comes with a lot more in the jar, and works just as well, if not better. I love that it's easy to apply and maintain. Plus, the jar size meets TSA regulations, so it's the perfect hair product for travel. — Les Shu, Insider Picks Guides Editor