There's a war on the way women talk - and it needs to end

Advertisement

amy schumer

Kevin Winter/Getty Images

Sorry, not sorry, for saying 'sorry.'

The debate over how women talk is coming to a head.

Advertisement

In May, Amy Schumer parodied women's tendency to over-apologize in a widely-lauded "Inside Amy Schumer" sketch titled, "I'm sorry." A few months later, in one of its most popular posts this year, the Washington Post satirized how a woman might hedge what she says in the boardroom with phrases like "I'm sorry, I just had this idea." This was following Jennifer Lawrence's viral essay where she questioned how the way she speaks influences how she's perceived.

But linguists and workplace experts are worried, at best, about a discussion sourounding this supposed speech epidemic, while others are plain pissed off.

Complimentary Tech Event
Transform talent with learning that works
Capability development is critical for businesses who want to push the envelope of innovation.Discover how business leaders are strategizing around building talent capabilities and empowering employee transformation.Know More

Articles abound instructing women to stop using supposedly destructive speech patterns, from prefacing requests with "sorry" to saying "just" too much.

The problem isn't that women use this kind of language more than men - in fact, Robin Lakoff, widely regarded as the founder of language and gender studies, tells Business Insider there's no empirical proof that this is even the case. She says the issue is we listen much more closely to what women say and are consequently far more critical, which has devastating effects.

Advertisement

"People are busy policing women's language and nobody is policing older or younger men's language," said Penny Eckert, a professor of linguistics at Stanford University and the coauthor "Language and Gender," in an interview with NPR.

Eckert declined Business Insider's request for an interview because she was "so sick of the media's fascination with women's ways of speaking," not to mention that Business Insider republished an article by Ellen Petry Leanse, a former Apple and Google employee, which essentially advised women to stop saying the word "just" so often, because it supposedly hurts their credibility in the workplace.

Several experts dislike this line of talk, and for good reason.