An environmental-advocacy group graded 16 cruise lines on how well they limit pollution. Every Carnival cruise line they graded got an 'F.'

Advertisement
An environmental-advocacy group graded 16 cruise lines on how well they limit pollution. Every Carnival cruise line they graded got an 'F.'

Carnival Ecstasy cruise ship

Joe Skipper/Reuters

Carnival's Carnival Ecstasy ship.

Advertisement
  • The environmental-advocacy group Friends of the Earth graded 16 cruise lines on how well they limit pollution from their ships.
  • The cruise lines were evaluated on how they treat their sewage, the steps they've taken to limit air pollution at ports, whether they follow water-pollution rules in Alaska, and the quality of information they provided about their environmental practices to Friends of the Earth.
  • Disney Cruise Line was the only cruise line to receive an overall grade above C-.
  • Visit Business Insider's homepage for more stories.

Most cruise lines do a poor job of limiting the damage they do to the environment, according to a new study from the environmental-advocacy group Friends of the Earth.

The group graded 16 cruise lines based on how they treat their sewage, the steps they've taken to limit air pollution at ports, whether they follow water-pollution rules in Alaska, and the quality of information they provided about their environmental practices to Friends of the Earth.

Read more: Carnival, Royal Caribbean, and Norwegian Cruise Line are in a fierce battle for domination in the cruise industry - here's how they stack up

Disney Cruise Line was the only cruise line to receive an overall grade above C-. All cruise lines owned by Carnival Corp automatically received failing grades due to their violation of a settlement related to a 2017 conviction for improper waste disposal.

Advertisement

Here's how the 16 cruise lines fared, from best to worst.

{{}}

16. Disney Cruise Line

16. Disney Cruise Line

Sewage treatment: A

Air-pollution reduction: D+

Water-quality compliance: A

Transparency: A

Criminal violations: No

Overall grade: A-

15. Norwegian Cruise Line

15. Norwegian Cruise Line

Sewage treatment: A

Air-pollution reduction: D-

Water-quality compliance: A

Transparency: F

Criminal violations: No

Overall grade: C-

Advertisement

14. Celebrity Cruises

14. Celebrity Cruises

Sewage treatment: A

Air-pollution reduction: D-

Water-quality compliance: N/A

Transparency: F

Criminal violations: No

Overall grade: D+

Tied: 13. Regent Seven Seas Cruises

Tied: 13. Regent Seven Seas Cruises

Sewage treatment: C-

Air-pollution reduction: F

Water-quality compliance: A

Transparency: F

Criminal violations: No

Overall grade: D

Advertisement

Tied: 13. Royal Caribbean International

Tied: 13. Royal Caribbean International

Sewage treatment: A

Air-pollution reduction: F

Water-quality compliance: N/A

Transparency: F

Criminal violations: No

Overall grade: D

Tied: 13. Silversea Cruises

Tied: 13. Silversea Cruises

Sewage treatment: D

Air-pollution reduction: F

Water-quality compliance: A

Transparency: F

Criminal violations: No

Overall grade: D

Advertisement

10. Oceania Cruises

10. Oceania Cruises

Sewage treatment: C-

Air-pollution reduction: F

Water-quality compliance: C+

Transparency: F

Criminal violations: No

Overall grade: D-

Tied: 1. Princess Cruises

Tied: 1. Princess Cruises

Sewage treatment: B

Air-pollution reduction: C

Water-quality compliance: A-

Transparency: F

Criminal violations: Yes

Overall grade: F

Advertisement

Tied: 1. Holland America Line

Tied: 1. Holland America Line

Sewage treatment: B+

Air-pollution reduction: D-

Water-quality compliance: A

Transparency: F

Criminal violations: Yes

Overall grade: F

Tied: 1. Seabourn Cruise Line

Tied: 1. Seabourn Cruise Line

Sewage treatment: A

Air-pollution reduction: F

Water-quality compliance: B+

Transparency: F

Criminal violations: Yes

Overall grade: F

Advertisement

Tied: 1. Cunard Line

Tied: 1. Cunard Line

Sewage treatment: A

Air-pollution reduction: F

Water-quality compliance: N/A

Transparency: F

Criminal violations: Yes

Overall grade: F

Tied: 1. Carnival Cruise Line

Tied: 1. Carnival Cruise Line

Sewage treatment: F

Air-pollution reduction: D

Water-quality compliance: A

Transparency: F

Criminal violations: Yes

Overall grade: F

Advertisement

Tied: 1. MSC Cruises

Tied: 1. MSC Cruises

Sewage treatment: C-

Air-pollution reduction: F

Water-quality compliance: N/A

Transparency: F

Criminal violations: No

Overall grade: F

Tied: 1. P&O Cruises

Tied: 1. P&O Cruises

Sewage treatment: D-

Air-pollution reduction: F

Water-quality compliance: N/A

Transparency: F

Criminal violations: Yes

Overall grade: F

Advertisement

Tied: 1. Costa Cruises

Tied: 1. Costa Cruises

Sewage treatment: F

Air-pollution reduction: F

Water-quality compliance: N/A

Transparency: F

Criminal violations: Yes

Overall grade: F

Tied: 1. Crystal Cruises

Tied: 1. Crystal Cruises

Sewage treatment: F

Air-pollution reduction: F

Water-quality compliance: N/A

Transparency: F

Criminal violations: No

Overall grade: F

Advertisement