Facebook approved fake political ads 'paid for' by Cambridge Analytica
- A new Facebook tool showing users who is paying for political ads can be easily manipulated.
- Business Insider ran two fake ads listed as "paid for by" the defunct political consultancy Cambridge Analytica, despite the fact Cambridge Analytica is banned from Facebook.
- Facebook's verification and ad approval processes did not catch the two fake ads, which ran for two days to a limited audience.
- Facebook pulled the ads down after they violated its policies. It said the ads transparency tool will be important for users to see who is "accountable for any political ad."
Facebook's new political ad transparency tools allowed Business Insider to run adverts as being "paid for" by Cambridge Analytica, the political consultancy that dragged Facebook into a major data scandal this year.The investigation demonstrates that political advertising on Facebook is still open to manipulation by bad actors, even with greater efforts at transparency. This is despite commitments from chief executive Mark Zuckerberg to solve the company's misinformation problem.Advertisement
Vice first reported last week that the Facebook political ads tool could be manipulated, with the publication securing approval to buy fake Facebook ads on behalf of US Vice President Mike Pence, terrorist group ISIS, and 100 US senators.
Business Insider carried out a similar test, setting up false political ads that were captioned as being "paid for by Cambridge Analytica," the defunct political advertising firm which harvested Facebook data and weaponized it during the 2016 US election. Cambridge Analytica is banned from Facebook and has gone into administration.Earlier this month, Facebook introduced a compulsory "paid for" disclosure for any advert relating to political issues in the UK. The feature has been live in the US since May and is also available in Brazil. The goal is to show users who is paying for ads that are attempting to sway their votes or opinions on significant political issues. Additionally, anyone who wants to post political adverts now has to clear several verification hurdles.
How we got fake ads on Facebook
The test involved Facebook approving Business Insider to place political ads on its services. That required verifying our driver's licence and a UK address.
Shona Ghosh/Business Insider/Facebook
Business Insider set up a page posing as an NGO, called "Insider Research Group," and ran two ads with the disclosure of "paid for by Cambridge Analytica."
We used existing ads that had been run by the Vote Leave and BeLeave campaigns during the UK's Brexit referendum in 2016. We accompanied them with inflammatory captions and links to the Vote Leave and Cambridge Analytica websites.Here's a screenshot of one ad we ran:Advertisement
Shona Ghosh/Business Insider
And the second ad:
Shona Ghosh/Business Insider
We chose to run the ads over two days to a limited local audience in east London to test whether Facebook's moderators or automated filters would pick up on the fake "paid for" disclosure or the Cambridge Analytica name.
Running a campaign and setting it live on Facebook requires further approvals from the company, separate from its requirements for running political ads. But at no point during the verification or approvals process did Facebook flag that the ads did not meet its standards.The adverts were seen by Facebook users and brought to the attention of Observer journalist Carole Cadwalladr, who blew open the Cambridge Analytica scandal in an interview with whistleblower Christopher Wylie in March.Advertisement
Facebook pulls the fake ads down
Facebook confirmed that the adverts violated its policies, even though they were not caught during the approval process. The company did not explain how the adverts slipped the net.A spokesman said: "This ad was not created by Cambridge Analytica. It is fake, violates our policies and has been taken down. We believe people on Facebook should know who is behind the political ads they're seeing which is why we are creating the Ads Library so that you can see who is accountable for any political ad. We have tools for anyone to report suspicious activity such as this."Facebook said it takes both a proactive and reactive approach to approving the "paid for" disclosures. The two ads originally appeared in Facebook's archive of all UK political ads on its site, but have now been labelled as "disapproved." The company emphasised that it needs the help of users, journalists, and researchers to report suspicious activity.Advertisement
Facebook's transparency tools are intended to help people become better informed about potential misinformation and inflammatory political advertising on its platform. The social network has come under close political scrutiny for its role in enabling misinformation during the US 2016 presidential election and, to a lesser degree, the UK's Brexit vote.
Business Insider's investigation follows UK politicians uncovering evidence of a shadowy ad campaign encouraging British citizens to lobby against Prime Minister Theresa May and her plan for Brexit. That campaign pre-dates Facebook's transparency tools, but Conservative politician Damian Collins stated that it was worrying "we have absolutely no idea who is behind it."At the UK launch of the ad tools earlier this month, Facebook said the new service was not explicitly designed to catch malicious actors, but to provide transparency. But Business Insider's small test does raise questions about the efficacy of Facebook's verification processes.Advertisement
- Health Ministry launches portal for info on vaccine, clinical trials
- Elon Musk's SpaceX will launch another 60 Starlink internet satellites into Earth’s orbit tonight
- Farmers protest in India intensify — Kerala MP and Punjab CM to move the Supreme Court, three Punjab BJP leaders resign
- Best smartphones with 256GB of internal storage
- Maharashtra’s restaurants and bars are likely to reopen for dine-in services