Link Copied

I tried KFC's new sauces and compared them with Chick-fil-A's to see which comes out on top

I tried KFC's new sauces and compared them with Chick-fil-A's to see which comes out on top
  • Kentucky Fried Chicken launched its new "KFC Sauce" along with revamped versions of its core condiment lineup in the fall.
  • The "KFC Sauce" features a sweet and smokey flavor, a strikingly similar mix of flavors to Chick-fil-A's signature sauce.
  • I tried KFC's new line of sauces and compared it with Chick-fil-A's to see whose lineup was the best.
  • While KFC's are still dunk-worthy, Chick-fil-A is still the reigning champion of sauces.

Chicken tenders are great, but the real superstars to any fast food cuisine are the dipping sauces.

In recognition of the importance of sauces, Kentucky Fried Chicken launched a new suite of condiments, including a never-before-seen, "KFC Sauce."

The restaurant chain describes its new sauce as "tangy and sweet, with a bit of smokiness."

For chicken-aficionados out there, you'll notice KFC Sauce's flavor profile is similar to Chick-fil-A Sauce, which the company describes as, "honey mustard and a smoky tang."

KFC's effort to create a competing sauce against Chick-fil-A is no small feat, but it is vital as the Georgia-based company continues to expand.

Chick-fil-A was the third-largest restaurant chain in the US in 2019, garnering a whopping $11.3 billion and earning more than Taco Bell, Wendy's, and Burger King.

And Chick-fil-A isn't slowing down anytime soon as the company plans to continue expanding outside of the south.

That could spell trouble for KFC, who is already competing with the growing chain for dining dollars.

So who is saucy enough to reign supreme? I dipped in and compared KFC's new line of sauces against Chick-fil-A's lineup to see who is the best.

KFC sent me its line of new sauces in anticipation of its launch at all US restaurants on October 12.

KFC sent me its line of new sauces in anticipation of its launch at all US restaurants on October 12.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

I ordered a four-pack of the chain's extra crispy tenders to dunk into the dipping sauces.

I ordered a four-pack of the chain's extra crispy tenders to dunk into the dipping sauces.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

I also ordered four-piece chicken strips from Chick-fil-A.

I also ordered four-piece chicken strips from Chick-fil-A.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement
Advertisement

To kick things off, I tried KFC's new "Honey BBQ" sauce.

To kick things off, I tried KFC's new "Honey BBQ" sauce.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

The sauce was sweet and lived up to the "honey" in its name. It tasted fine, but the flavor was pretty tame.

The sauce was sweet and lived up to the "honey" in its name. It tasted fine, but the flavor was pretty tame.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

Next, I tried Chick-fil-A's barbecue sauce.

Next, I tried Chick-fil-A's barbecue sauce.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

This was closer to a traditional barbecue sauce found at a grill out.

This was closer to a traditional barbecue sauce found at a grill out.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

The flavor was less sweet and relied more on savory-smokey tones. But it was still pretty muted and didn't have any spice or pepperiness to it.

The flavor was less sweet and relied more on savory-smokey tones. But it was still pretty muted and didn't have any spice or pepperiness to it.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

Between KFC and Chick-fil-A, the barbecue sauces were tied. Picking one just depends on whether you're in the mood for sweet or savory.

Between KFC and Chick-fil-A, the barbecue sauces were tied. Picking one just depends on whether you're in the mood for sweet or savory.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

For my second round of sauces, I went for KFC's honey mustard.

For my second round of sauces, I went for KFC's honey mustard.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

KFC's honey mustard had a tiny hint of sharpness.

KFC's honey mustard had a tiny hint of sharpness.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

But mostly, it was a watery-consistency and didn't taste out of the ordinary.

But mostly, it was a watery-consistency and didn't taste out of the ordinary.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

Chick-fil-A's honey mustard was sweeter in comparison to KFC's version of the sauce.

Chick-fil-A's honey mustard was sweeter in comparison to KFC's version of the sauce.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

It had a brownish-yellow tone and a vinegary-consistency.

It had a brownish-yellow tone and a vinegary-consistency.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

Still, it was nothing out of the ordinary. They were both just okay.

Still, it was nothing out of the ordinary. They were both just okay.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

Up next was KFC's "classic" ranch.

Up next was KFC's "classic" ranch.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

The sauce hit all the checkpoints I look for in a homemade ranch.

The sauce hit all the checkpoints I look for in a homemade ranch.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

The consistency was buttery and thick.

The consistency was buttery and thick.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

There was a slight lactic-milk taste, but the herb mix was strong enough to contrast it with an oniony-kick.

There was a slight lactic-milk taste, but the herb mix was strong enough to contrast it with an oniony-kick.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

Overall, it met my Midwestern obsession for high-quality ranch.

Overall, it met my Midwestern obsession for high-quality ranch.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

I cracked open Chick-fil-A's "Garden Herb Ranch," and while it was good, it didn't live up to the KFC version.

I cracked open Chick-fil-A's "Garden Herb Ranch," and while it was good, it didn't live up to the KFC version.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

It still had a nice, herby-zing to it, but the sauce was thinner.

It still had a nice, herby-zing to it, but the sauce was thinner.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

If I brought KFC's ranch to a Super Bowl party, people would be thanking me.

If I brought KFC's ranch to a Super Bowl party, people would be thanking me.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

Finally, I popped open KFC's new house sauce.

Finally, I popped open KFC's new house sauce.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

The KFC sauce tasted similar to a honey mustard with subtle hints of a smokey barbecue sauce.

The KFC sauce tasted similar to a honey mustard with subtle hints of a smokey barbecue sauce.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

KFC Sauce isn't thick, but it's still packed with contrasting flavors that made each dip delightful.

KFC Sauce isn't thick, but it's still packed with contrasting flavors that made each dip delightful.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

I enjoyed it more than the other KFC sauces and expect it to become a popular addition for tender dippers everywhere.

I enjoyed it more than the other KFC sauces and expect it to become a popular addition for tender dippers everywhere.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

Next up, I compared it to the iconic Chick-fil-A sauce.

Next up, I compared it to the iconic Chick-fil-A sauce.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

Both Chick-fil-A Sauce and KFC Sauce have a similar taste profile: Sweet, yet smokey. Tangy, but sharp. They were also similar in color.

Both Chick-fil-A Sauce and KFC Sauce have a similar taste profile: Sweet, yet smokey. Tangy, but sharp. They were also similar in color.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

Chick-fil-A sauce was a tad bit sweeter, but the flavor was bolder than KFC's offering.

Chick-fil-A sauce was a tad bit sweeter, but the flavor was bolder than KFC's offering.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

It also tasted like a sweet barbecue sauce mixed with sharp mustard.

It also tasted like a sweet barbecue sauce mixed with sharp mustard.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

Its satisfyingly thick consistency and sweet, honey taste made Chick-fil-A Sauce absolutely addictive and superior to KFC Sauce.

Its satisfyingly thick consistency and sweet, honey taste made Chick-fil-A Sauce absolutely addictive and superior to KFC Sauce.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

Overall, the honey mustard and barbecue sauces from both chains were on par with each other.

Overall, the honey mustard and barbecue sauces from both chains were on par with each other.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

KFC's creamy ranch was definitely superior to Chick-fil-A's offering.

KFC's creamy ranch was definitely superior to Chick-fil-A's offering.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

But if you put Chick-fil-A Sauce and KFC Sauce head-to-head, there is no doubt the beloved yellow sauce packet is still at the top of the pecking order.

But if you put Chick-fil-A Sauce and KFC Sauce head-to-head, there is no doubt the beloved yellow sauce packet is still at the top of the pecking order.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

The sauce's unique honey mustard and barbecue blend made me want to dunk my pizza into it, or maybe even drizzle it on a salad.

The sauce's unique honey mustard and barbecue blend made me want to dunk my pizza into it, or maybe even drizzle it on a salad.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement

But while KFC's attempt to match its growing rival fell short, all of the new sauces, including KFC Sauce, are still dunk-worthy.

But while KFC's attempt to match its growing rival fell short, all of the new sauces, including KFC Sauce, are still dunk-worthy.
Linh Ta/Business Insider
Advertisement