I drove a $69,000 RAM 1500 and a $57,000 Chevy Silverado to find out which is the better pickup truck. Here's the verdict.

Advertisement

First up is the 2019 RAM 1500 Crew Cab. I tested a Western-themed Laramie "Longhorn" edition, which was $54,000 before the addition of many extra features. As tested, the price was $68,500.

First up is the 2019 RAM 1500 Crew Cab. I tested a Western-themed Laramie "Longhorn" edition, which was $54,000 before the addition of many extra features. As tested, the price was $68,500.
I reviewed the previous generation of the RAM 1500 last year.
Advertisement

The pickup was equipped with a short bed. The "Patriot Blue Peal" paint job was stunning.

The pickup was equipped with a short bed. The "Patriot Blue Peal" paint job was stunning.
Advertisement

The RAM 1500 is a critically important truck for Fiat Chrysler Automobiles in the hyper-competitive, highly-profitable full-size pickup segment.

The RAM 1500 is a critically important truck for Fiat Chrysler Automobiles in the hyper-competitive, highly-profitable full-size pickup segment.
Advertisement
Advertisement

The RAM front end is a study in forcefulness, intended to invoke semis and deliver a singular road presence.

The RAM front end is a study in forcefulness, intended to invoke semis and deliver a singular road presence.
Advertisement

That's a whole lotta chrome!

That's a whole lotta chrome!
Advertisement

The RAM 1500 weighs about 5,400 lbs. and can tow 12,750 lbs.

The RAM 1500 weighs about 5,400 lbs. and can tow 12,750 lbs.
Advertisement

There's Longhorn-edition badging at the rear ...

There's Longhorn-edition badging at the rear ...
Advertisement

... Plus an indication that this is a 4x4 pickup.

... Plus an indication that this is a 4x4 pickup.
Advertisement

But just in case you weren't sure.

But just in case you weren't sure.
Advertisement

The RAM logo and another Longhorn shoutout are rendered in thick chrome.

The RAM logo and another Longhorn shoutout are rendered in thick chrome.
Advertisement

My truck didn't come with a cover for the bed.

My truck didn't come with a cover for the bed.
Advertisement

I tested it out by taking my son and friend sledding. Not much of a test!

I tested it out by taking my son and friend sledding. Not much of a test!
Advertisement

The rear step bumper made getting in and out of the bed relatively simple.

The rear step bumper made getting in and out of the bed relatively simple.
Advertisement

And of course you have the RAM badge, served up in chunky chrome.

And of course you have the RAM badge, served up in chunky chrome.
Advertisement

So how about we examine that legendary Hemi motor?

So how about we examine that legendary Hemi motor?
Advertisement

My RAM 1500's Hemi had an innovative feature ...

My RAM 1500's Hemi had an innovative feature ...
Advertisement

... A mild-hybrid "eTorque" system coupled to the 5.7-liter V8, making a total of 395 horsepower with 410 lb-ft of torque. The 0-60 time is about six seconds. Fuel economy is OK: 17 mpg city/22 highway/19 combined.

... A mild-hybrid "eTorque" system coupled to the 5.7-liter V8, making a total of 395 horsepower with 410 lb-ft of torque. The 0-60 time is about six seconds. Fuel economy is OK: 17 mpg city/22 highway/19 combined.
Advertisement

The automatically retracting running boards make climbing in and out of the crew-cab effortless. Plus, the pickup's air suspension can raise and lower the truck.

The automatically retracting running boards make climbing in and out of the crew-cab effortless. Plus, the pickup's air suspension can raise and lower the truck.
Advertisement

The interior was "Mountain Brown/Light Mountain Brown," and it was the nicest I've experienced in a pickup in the past few years. Seats are heated and cooled.

The interior was "Mountain Brown/Light Mountain Brown," and it was the nicest I've experienced in a pickup in the past few years. Seats are heated and cooled.
Advertisement

The rear seat was capacious — adults would be comfortable back there.

The rear seat was capacious — adults would be comfortable back there.
Advertisement

Yet more Longhorn call-outs!

Yet more Longhorn call-outs!
Advertisement

These rear-seat pouches get the rodeo treatment.

These rear-seat pouches get the rodeo treatment.
Advertisement

I kid you not — the RAM 1500 Crew Cab Laramie Longhorn Edition is a glorious place to spend time.

I kid you not — the RAM 1500 Crew Cab Laramie Longhorn Edition is a glorious place to spend time.
Advertisement

The massive moonroof puts it right over the top.

The massive moonroof puts it right over the top.
Advertisement

This Longhorn package is FLASH-Y! The trim on the gauges looks like tooled silver, the steering wheel has both leather wrapping and wood trim. The steering wheel is heated.

This Longhorn package is FLASH-Y! The trim on the gauges looks like tooled silver, the steering wheel has both leather wrapping and wood trim. The steering wheel is heated.
Advertisement

In the midst of some beautiful textured wood trim we find the stop-start button.

In the midst of some beautiful textured wood trim we find the stop-start button.
Advertisement

The RAM has no shifter. Instead, you have to use a space-saving knob, where you also control the 4WD setup. The RAM 1500 has an eight-speed automatic transmission.

The RAM has no shifter. Instead, you have to use a space-saving knob, where you also control the 4WD setup. The RAM 1500 has an eight-speed automatic transmission.
Advertisement

The details through the interior of the Laramie Longhorn Edition are impressive.

The details through the interior of the Laramie Longhorn Edition are impressive.
Advertisement

Cupholders!

Cupholders!
Advertisement

And lots of space under the center armrest.

 And lots of space under the center armrest.
Advertisement

Didn't expect this! Handy formulas and graphs to assist with jobsite calculations.

Didn't expect this! Handy formulas and graphs to assist with jobsite calculations.
Advertisement

That grained wood is just lovely.

That grained wood is just lovely.
Advertisement

The RAM offers a dual glove box for document storage.

The RAM offers a dual glove box for document storage.
Advertisement

And you have an additional place to stash small items on the dashboard.

And you have an additional place to stash small items on the dashboard.
Advertisement

The Harman Kardon audio systems has 19 speakers. It sounds fantastic.

The Harman Kardon audio systems has 19 speakers. It sounds fantastic.
Advertisement

The 12-inch center touchscreen is stunning. The infotainment system is FCA's Uconnect, which we've found to be excellent.

The 12-inch center touchscreen is stunning. The infotainment system is FCA's Uconnect, which we've found to be excellent.

GPS navigation is solid, and the system offers a suite of apps to go along with USB/AUX ports for device connection. Bluetooth pairing is easy, and the RAM 1500 has wireless charging. Apple CarPlay and Android Auto are also available.

Advertisement

Admittedly, the combination of buttons, knobs, and screen might seem cluttered and overly complicated. But that's until you have to handle the RAM 1500 while wearing gloves in sub-freezing weather.

Admittedly, the combination of buttons, knobs, and screen might seem cluttered and overly complicated. But that's until you have to handle the RAM 1500 while wearing gloves in sub-freezing weather.
Advertisement

In summary, the 2019 RAM 1500 Laramie Longhorn Crew Cab 4x4 is a staggeringly good pickup truck. The secret weapon, of course, is the four-corner air suspension —competitive pickups from Ford and Chevy continue to use rear leaf-springs.

In summary, the 2019 RAM 1500 Laramie Longhorn Crew Cab 4x4 is a staggeringly good pickup truck. The secret weapon, of course, is the four-corner air suspension —competitive pickups from Ford and Chevy continue to use rear leaf-springs.

The RAM 1500 also has abundant driver-assist features, including stop-and-go cruise control, forward collision warning, lane-departure warning, and an awesome surround-view camera setup.

Advertisement

On to the $57,000 2019 Silverado LTZ Crew Cab. A base Silverado is a mere $30,000, but my test truck added a heap of options.

On to the $57,000 2019 Silverado LTZ Crew Cab. A base Silverado is a mere $30,000, but my test truck added a heap of options.
Read the review.
Advertisement

Our test truck came with a short bed. It was more than adequate for testing.

Our test truck came with a short bed. It was more than adequate for testing.
Advertisement

The Silverado tips the scales at 5,000 pounds — but that's several hundred less than the outgoing generation, thanks to lightweight steel and aluminum. It can tow 12,000 lbs.

The Silverado tips the scales at 5,000 pounds — but that's several hundred less than the outgoing generation, thanks to lightweight steel and aluminum. It can tow 12,000 lbs.
Advertisement

I'm not a huge fan of the Silverado's front end. The LED headlights are too small, messing up the balance of the other elements: chrome grille and gold bowtie badge.

I'm not a huge fan of the Silverado's front end. The LED headlights are too small, messing up the balance of the other elements: chrome grille and gold bowtie badge.
Advertisement

The Chevrolet nameplate stretches across the liftgate, as it has for oh-so-many Chevys for oh-so-many decades.

The Chevrolet nameplate stretches across the liftgate, as it has for oh-so-many Chevys for oh-so-many decades.
Advertisement

My test truck was equipped with a proper four-wheel-drive system.

My test truck was equipped with a proper four-wheel-drive system.
Advertisement

The Silverado name is bold and rendered in shimmering chrome.

The Silverado name is bold and rendered in shimmering chrome.
Advertisement

We see it again at the rear.

We see it again at the rear.
Advertisement

The LTZ trim level is also indicated.

The LTZ trim level is also indicated.
Advertisement

Unlike with the RAM, my Silverado featured a foldable tonneau cover.

Unlike with the RAM, my Silverado featured a foldable tonneau cover.
Advertisement

If you look carefully, you can see that I have a Christmas tree in the bed.

If you look carefully, you can see that I have a Christmas tree in the bed.
Advertisement

These helpful, recessed steps assist in climbing in and out of the bed. It's a little thing, but the RAM lacks them.

These helpful, recessed steps assist in climbing in and out of the bed. It's a little thing, but the RAM lacks them.
Advertisement

Let's have a look at the 6.2-liter V8!

Let's have a look at the 6.2-liter V8!
Advertisement

After popping the hood ...

After popping the hood ...
Advertisement

... You don't get that much of an eyeful. The V8 makes 420 horsepower with a whopping 460 lb-ft of torque. It can propel the truck to 60 mph in about six seconds, sending the power through a 10-speed automatic transmission. The MPGs are actually respectable, at 16 city, 20 highway, and 17 combined.

... You don't get that much of an eyeful. The V8 makes 420 horsepower with a whopping 460 lb-ft of torque. It can propel the truck to 60 mph in about six seconds, sending the power through a 10-speed automatic transmission. The MPGs are actually respectable, at 16 city, 20 highway, and 17 combined.

If you're keeping score, the Silverado's V8 is more powerful than the RAM 1500's.

Advertisement

The running boards on my Silverado didn't extend and retract automatically.

The running boards on my Silverado didn't extend and retract automatically.
Advertisement

The "Gideon/Very Dark Atmosphere" interior is oddly named, but still quite pleasant, if a bit on the utilitarian side. This is where you can see a significant difference between the Silverado and the more expensive RAM 1500.

The "Gideon/Very Dark Atmosphere" interior is oddly named, but still quite pleasant, if a bit on the utilitarian side. This is where you can see a significant difference between the Silverado and the more expensive RAM 1500.
Advertisement

The back seat is roomy, yet drab. Adults won't struggle to fit, however.

The back seat is roomy, yet drab. Adults won't struggle to fit, however.
Advertisement

Of course, some owners might not want a lot of cowboy flash in their trucks. The front seats are heated and cooled, a nice extra. The rear seats are merely heated.

Of course, some owners might not want a lot of cowboy flash in their trucks. The front seats are heated and cooled, a nice extra. The rear seats are merely heated.
Advertisement

The Silverado's instrument panel and steering wheel, for the LTZ trim level, aren't especially snazzy. But the steering wheel is heated.

The Silverado's instrument panel and steering wheel, for the LTZ trim level, aren't especially snazzy. But the steering wheel is heated.
Advertisement

The previous-generation's key ignition has been replaced with a push-button start-stop, but ...

The previous-generation's key ignition has been replaced with a push-button start-stop, but ...
Advertisement

... That good old column shifter remains!

... That good old column shifter remains!
Advertisement

Storage is ample. There is a smartphone pad on the center armrest ...

Storage is ample. There is a smartphone pad on the center armrest ...
Advertisement

... Under which hides a compartment with ample space for just about anything.

... Under which hides a compartment with ample space for just about anything.
Advertisement

I quite liked this smartphone perch.

I quite liked this smartphone perch.
Advertisement

There's also a dual glove box.

There's also a dual glove box.
Advertisement

Well, that is a rather small infotainment screen, compared with the RAM. It's a mere eight inches.

Well, that is a rather small infotainment screen, compared with the RAM. It's a mere eight inches.
Advertisement

Apple CarPlay and Android Auto are available. The system — IntelliLink — is wonderful, a breeze to use with a response touchscreen and a few useful knobs and buttons for backup. The 4G LTE Wi-Fi offers speedy device support through GM's OnStar connectivity technology.

Apple CarPlay and Android Auto are available. The system — IntelliLink — is wonderful, a breeze to use with a response touchscreen and a few useful knobs and buttons for backup. The 4G LTE Wi-Fi offers speedy device support through GM's OnStar connectivity technology.

To be honest, GM's systems and Uconnect are neck-and-neck for functionality and features. In the Silverado, IntelliLink was a bit easier to use. GPS navigation was faultless, device pairing was a snap, there were USB/AUX options, and also wireless charging.

Advertisement

To summarize, Silverado handles well, rides smoothly, and, with a robust four-by-four system, should be able to absorb anything that an owner throws at it. The cabin is spacious, comfortable, and, in the LTZ trim, close to luxurious.

To summarize, Silverado handles well, rides smoothly, and, with a robust four-by-four system, should be able to absorb anything that an owner throws at it. The cabin is spacious, comfortable, and, in the LTZ trim, close to luxurious.

The Silverado is also crammed with driver-assist features, including parking aids, lane-change alerts, blind-spot monitoring, and a cross-traffic warning when backing up.

Advertisement

And the winner is ... the 2019 RAM 1500!

And the winner is ... the 2019 RAM 1500!

Even without the upscale Laramie Longhorn package, this is the best full-size pickup truck I've ever tested. I even got to challenge the 4x4 system with about a foot of snow at our suburban New Jersey test center, and the RAM brushed it off like nothing.

OK, I'll accept that the F-150 and Silverado loyalists out there don't like the RAM's suspension. Yes, it could break down under serious stress. But in my testing, this truck was bliss to drive.

"It truly is the level of refinement that the RAM 1500 brings to the segment that helps it stand out, even as Ford and Chevy/GMC sell more trucks," I wrote in my review of the outgoing generation. "RAM has carved out far more than niche at number three and isn't dropping the ball when it comes to what its loyalist expect."

With the all-new 2019 pickup, RAM might have moved past that No. 3 niche and positioned the Silverado in its sights. The RAM 1500 is a no-compromise pickup, perfectly pitched for the new pickup market, which is as much about everyday driving as hardcore performance.

Don't get me wrong — the Silverado is no slouch. And in fairness, the RAM 1500 I tested cost $12,000 more, so it should have been impressive.

But even taking that into account, I think the RAM is a superior full-size beast, and while the 5.7-liter Hemi V8 isn't as powerful on paper as the Silverado's 6.2-liter V8, the RAM's torque-boosting hybrid makes the 1500 feel as though it has more punch. And the RAM's eight-speed transmission, in my hands, felt as though it shifted more smoothly than the Silverado's ten-speed.

Pickup-truck buyers don't want for choices these days. But boy! I challenge anybody seeking a new truck to sample the RAM 1500 and not be tempted by what I think is the best full-size pickup money can buy.

Advertisement