We visited a Claire's store the day the teen retailer filed for bankruptcy - and it was like stepping back in time

Advertisement

The store that we visited was located on Broadway in New York, between the busy shopping areas of Herald Square and Times Square. While this particular store is not plagued by the problems that come with being in a mall, this area is somewhat of a no-man's land for shopping.

The store that we visited was located on Broadway in New York, between the busy shopping areas of Herald Square and Times Square. While this particular store is not plagued by the problems that come with being in a mall, this area is somewhat of a no-man's land for shopping.
Advertisement

This store is not one of the 92 slated to close. When we arrived, there was even a sign that said, "We're hiring."

This store is not one of the 92 slated to close. When we arrived, there was even a sign that said, "We're hiring."

We could not find any job postings for this location online.

The company has not yet released its fourth-quarter earnings or confirmed whether it closed stores in 2017. In 2016, it closed 166 stores.

Advertisement

Claire's is perhaps best known for its ear-piercing service, which is one of the biggest things that attracts customers to its stores. As soon as we walked into the store, an eager shop assistant asked if we were here to have our ears pierced.

Claire's is perhaps best known for its ear-piercing service, which is one of the biggest things that attracts customers to its stores. As soon as we walked into the store, an eager shop assistant asked if we were here to have our ears pierced.

The front section of the store was devoted to earrings.

The front section of the store was devoted to earrings.
Advertisement

There were endless racks of similar-looking products ...

There were endless racks of similar-looking products ...

... which shoppers could easily find for lower prices at other online stores.

... which shoppers could easily find for lower prices at other online stores.
Advertisement

Claire's doesn't only have online sellers to reckon with — low-cost rivals such H&M and Forever 21 are also an issue for the store. These stores sell similar jewelry and accessories, but often at cheaper prices. At Forever 21, you can spend as little as $1.90 on a pair of hoops, and you'll struggle to spend over $10 on any earrings.

Claire's doesn't only have online sellers to reckon with — low-cost rivals such H&M and Forever 21 are also an issue for the store. These stores sell similar jewelry and accessories, but often at cheaper prices. At Forever 21, you can spend as little as $1.90 on a pair of hoops, and you'll struggle to spend over $10 on any earrings.

At Claire's, equivalent gold hoops cost $8.99.

Even in the clearance section, prices were still above Forever 21's.

Even in the clearance section, prices were still above Forever 21's.
Advertisement

The shop assistant told us that the store had announced a new sale that day: "Buy three items, get three free."

The shop assistant told us that the store had announced a new sale that day: "Buy three items, get three free."

Most of the store was on sale.

Most of the store was on sale.
Advertisement

The signs worked like white boards. Sales assistants could scrub out old discounts and change them each day.

The signs worked like white boards. Sales assistants could scrub out old discounts and change them each day.

The ear-piercing service is what sets the retailer apart, as it's an experience that can't be recreated online and isn't offered at rival stores like H&M and Forever 21. This is a service that Macy's offers at some stores, however.

The ear-piercing service is what sets the retailer apart, as it's an experience that can't be recreated online and isn't offered at rival stores like H&M and Forever 21. This is a service that Macy's offers at some stores, however.

Big signs at the front of the store remind you that this is a service it offers.

Advertisement

However, the actual ear-piercing area looked tired and unappealing. It consisted of a bench and an old chair. If the store wants to entice customers in, it should be showing off its biggest strength and making this more of an attractive experience.

However, the actual ear-piercing area looked tired and unappealing. It consisted of a bench and an old chair. If the store wants to entice customers in, it should be showing off its biggest strength and making this more of an attractive experience.

The sales assistant told us that prices for ear piercing vary depending on what stud you choose. It starts at $30.99 for a 3mm ball stud and goes up to $199.99 for a 14-karat, white-gold stud with a diamond. A starter kit is included in this price.

There was a small beauty section in this store. It had everything from eye masks and nail polish to brushes and blushes.

There was a small beauty section in this store. It had everything from eye masks and nail polish to brushes and blushes.
Advertisement

While the majority of the store was stocked with jewelry and accessories, there was also a large toy section. These "Ty" tags were a blast from the past.

While the majority of the store was stocked with jewelry and accessories, there was also a large toy section. These "Ty" tags were a blast from the past.

The store is clearly trying to appeal to a new generation of teens who spend more money on technology. However, the prices often felt out of reach for this age group, especially as this tech-savvy generation can easily shop online for deals.

The store is clearly trying to appeal to a new generation of teens who spend more money on technology. However, the prices often felt out of reach for this age group, especially as this tech-savvy generation can easily shop online for deals.

Outside of the sale, these iPhone cases cost between $10 and $15. At Forever 21, you can find trendy styles for under $10.

Advertisement

Overall, the store felt tired. Shopping here was like stepping back into the '90s, and it seemed that the store was struggling to compete for the modern teen shopper.

Overall, the store felt tired. Shopping here was like stepping back into the '90s, and it seemed that the store was struggling to compete for the modern teen shopper.