Morgan Stanley on San Francisco rents: It'll take 'more than a mild slowdown' for rents to drop
Images Money/Flickr
In a note to clients on Friday, Morgan Stanley analyst Vance Edelson said, "it will take more than a mild slowdown in tech activity to break down favorable supply demand fundamentals in the Bay Area."
That's favorable to homeowners and landlords, not renters or new buyers.
And, the kicker: "We think supply/demand would remain favorable even if current Bay Area job growth forecasts were cut in half." (Emphasis ours.)
The Bay Area's rent growth is a direct result of a shortage of housing to match the (largely tech-driven) increase in jobs, Morgan Stanley wrote. Looking at construction data, the new apartment supply is expected to only increase by 15,000 units in 2016-2017, they said.
Right now, the forecasts point to 145,000 new jobs in the Bay Area. 145,000 new jobs versus 15,000 new units is a ratio of 9.4x. That's terrible if you're hoping rents will drop.
Morgan Stanley calculated that in low home-ownership markets, like the Bay Area, a traditional ratio is 4 jobs for every apartment, or a 4x ratio. At that ratio, the market is in something like equilibrium.
In 2015, the job/supply ratio was 8.9x, according to the note.
So it's getting worse, not better.
The wild card is what happens to tech job growth. If the tech sector slows, there could be fewer than 145,000 new jobs created.
But there needs to be "more than a mild slowdown" for rents to drop - even if the estimate of new jobs is cut in half, the market will remain favorable to owners:
Morgan Stanley
- I spent $2,000 for 7 nights in a 179-square-foot room on one of the world's largest cruise ships. Take a look inside my cabin.
- Saudi Arabia wants China to help fund its struggling $500 billion Neom megaproject. Investors may not be too excited.
- One of the world's only 5-star airlines seems to be considering asking business-class passengers to bring their own cutlery
- From terrace to table: 8 Edible plants you can grow in your home
- India fourth largest military spender globally in 2023: SIPRI report
- New study forecasts high chance of record-breaking heat and humidity in India in the coming months
- Gold plunges ₹1,450 to ₹72,200, silver prices dive by ₹2,300
- Strong domestic demand supporting India's growth: Morgan Stanley