Why you should be celebrating the record number of people saying, 'I quit'

Advertisement
Why you should be celebrating the record number of people saying, 'I quit'
Mixetto/Getty Images
  • In August, 4.3 million Americans quit their jobs, extending a five-month streak of record walkouts.
  • While the exits could hold up the economic recovery, workers who quit likely found better pay.
Advertisement

Americans are ditching their jobs at a record pace. While employers bemoan a labor shortage, the extraordinary amount of quitting suggests the US economy will bounce back stronger than ever.

August marked the fifth month of Americans quitting in nearly record numbers, with 4.3 million workers resigning. The continually elevated departures show that workers are taking more control over their careers - and saying no to low wages and bad working conditions.

There are plenty of reasons for Americans to quit their jobs right now. COVID-19 continues to rage across the country, making some Americans too concerned to work in-person jobs or causing them to leave work to take care of their own or someone else's coronavirus symptoms.

Burnout has become a crisis of its own, particularly in sectors where reopening brought a sudden surge of demand.

And some people are simply leaving their jobs for better work.

Advertisement

That last part is exactly why record-high quitting should be applauded, not feared. Usually quits tick up when the labor market is strong and unemployment is low; indeed, unemployment dropped to 4.8% in September, even as the country added a lower-than-expected number of jobs.

Recent data backs up the idea that workers are quitting amid an abundance of options. Job openings soared to record highs through much of 2021 and, despite falling in August, still totaled more than 10 million, according to data from the Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey published Tuesday.

There's a whole lot of opportunities out there right now, Nick Bunker, an economic-research director at Indeed, told Insider. "We're seeing lots of workers seemingly going out and seizing them," Bunker said.

The benefits of being a quitter

Leaving one's job doesn't just free up new work opportunities. Research suggests it gives way to higher pay and greater productivity.

In fact, it could lead to a whole new economy: Arindrajit Dube, an economics professor at the University of Massachusetts Amherst, wrote on Twitter that if quits stayed elevated through next year, it "could have a fundamental and lasting impact on labor market power and wage norms."

Advertisement

There's a "remarkably strong relationship" between switching jobs and higher wages, economists at the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago found in 2015. Switching jobs tends to push workers up the economic ladder. Generally, a jump in the quit rate leads to stronger wage growth one to two quarters later, that team said.

Quitting can also give way to stronger productivity. Some of the strongest productivity gains of the past decade have taken place during the pandemic when workers were leaving their jobs and looking for new ones. Businesses are pushed to do the same amount of work with fewer employees, forcing adoption of new practices or technologies.

And Americans who quit can better match their skills with a new job. That also lifts productivity and gives workers more power when bargaining for higher pay.

"One of the best ways for a person to boost their earnings is to switch jobs. And I think that's very much likely to be the case right now," Bunker said.

Quits can also send a strong message to companies mired in the status quo

DataTrek Research, an economic-research group, tracks what it calls the "take this job and shove it" indicator. That's the share of job separations that were quits, as opposed to layoffs or other reasons for leaving work.

Advertisement

Jessica Rabe, DataTrek's cofounder, told Insider in an email that the indicator rose to a record 71.1% in August. She said two-thirds of the month's increase in quits came from accommodation and food services - an industry that is historically lower-paying and has been hit hard by labor shortages.

"That tells us workers continue to leave the restaurant industry amid challenging demands put on existing staff due to labor shortages and other requirements, such as mask mandates for customers," Rabe said. And because the quit rate has remained high in leisure and hospitality, "the industry will remain constrained due to the dearth in available workers, which will continue to weigh on overall employment," she added.

To be sure, quit data tells economists only so much about where workers are going next. Quits show that Americans are leaving their jobs, not finding new ones. And JOLTS data doesn't show whether Americans quitting their jobs left for other sectors or stayed in the same industry.

If labor shortages continue, the number of workers quitting might remain stubbornly high.

"The outlook for demands still seems pretty robust moving forward," Bunker said. "So it seems likely we will see quitting stay elevated for quite some time."

Advertisement
{{}}