A deal between Iran and China shows that 'getting tough' doesn't solve the US's problems
- Reporting indicates that
Iranand Chinaare set to sign a multibillion-dollar trade and security pact.
- That deal would bring to the US's biggest foes together, and that cooperation demonstrates that "getting tough" on both of them is not going to get the US want it wants, writes Daniel L. Davis, a senior fellow for
- This is an
opinioncolumn. The thoughts expressed are those of the author(s).
This month, it was reported that China and Iran had all but completed a long-rumored security and economic pact, again showing the consequences of our steadfast refusal to recognize the futility of the "
The deal between Beijing and Tehran extends into the "sectors of trade, economy,
Washington's diplomatic activity, backed up by our powerful military, is supposed to create conditions beneficial to our country.
The intent, in dealings with any foreign power — whether friend or foe — is to foster conditions that make America more secure, lessen the chances of conflict, and increase the opportunity to enhance prosperity for our citizenry. Against that standard, US foreign policy has been an abject failure for many years. It's time to stop the losing streak.The first step in that process is acknowledging the difference between preferred outcomes and hard interests. We can prefer to see Tehran give up its nascent nuclear program, dismantle its ballistic missile inventory, and cease support for terrorism abroad. We can prefer that China renounce the use of force as a means of solving their Taiwan issue. We can prefer that North Korea completely denuclearize before we give them any sanctions relief.
Interests, however, are a different matter, especially where vital national interests are concerned.
For example, while we want Iran, North Korea, and China to accommodate our preferences, it is vital for our security and prosperity that we deter each from using force, that we prevent any from becoming a hegemonic power at our expense, and that we preserve an environment favorable to maximize economic opportunities abroad.While we are unlikely to make any of these countries our friends, neither should we unnecessarily and permanently relegate them to being outright enemies.
Americans like to be tough. We like to win. Those are traits that have often served our nation well in the international arena. But "tough" isn't a strategy; it is merely one approach.In the days and months following 9/11, we understandably relied heavily on military power to reassure a scared and jittery American public. Unfortunately, however, "being tough" became the default mode in the years and now decades that followed. By any objective measure, such reliance has manifestly worsened our security and interests in the world.
It is crucial, therefore, that we stop repeating failure and start using more powerful and beneficial tools of statecraft. We will always have a need to back up any diplomacy with a mighty military, but it's time to rediscover effective diplomacy, of engaging in more open discussions where others can come out with something they want, and start allowing other countries to take responsibility for their own security.American security and prosperity are not dependent on Washington providing a solution to every problem in the world and guaranteeing the security of all democracies. It is found in engaging effectively with our partners, on deterring any adversary from attacking us, and by focusing on taking care of our own internal challenges — and less on trying to do the impossible abroad.
Daniel L. Davis is a Senior Fellow for Defense Priorities and a former Lt. Col. in the US Army who retired in 2015 after 21 years, including four combat deployments. Follow him @DanielLDavis1.
- 1.28 lakh people over 60 years get 1st dose of COVID vaccine on first day
- Chinese hackers target Indian vaccine makers SII and Bharat Biotech: Report
- GST revenue up 7% year-on-year in February to over ₹1.13 lakh crore
- Here is the list of common side-effects of COVID-19, so that you don't panic if you get these
- These are the top 10 likely IPOs scheduled in March 2021