Senior US Officials Describe The 'Big Disconnect' In Obama's ISIS Strategy
Rajiv Chandrasekaran of The Washington Post reports that the Syrian opposition force to be recruited, vetted, and trained by the U.S. military and its coalition partners over the next year or so will defend territory held by the Free Syrian Army (FSA) as opposed to taking the fight to ISIS-controlled areas.
That's because an offensive force would require help of forward-deployed US combat teams, which Obama has ruled out in Syria.
"We have a big disconnect within our strategy," a senior U.S. official involved in Syria and Iraq operations told WaPo. "We need a credible, moderate Syrian force, but we have not been willing to commit what it takes to build that force."
Furthermore, the FSA - which Obama considers to be made up of doctors and pharmacists - are fighting for survival in Syria's largest city of Aleppo amid assaults from both Assad and ISIS.
Hussam Marie, the Free Syrian Army spokesman for northern Syria, told The New York Times last month that the loss of FSA positions in and around Aleppo would be "unrecoverable" and "a blow to our shared goals of a moderate Syria."
Basically, the two obvious weakness in Obama's plan are being fully exposed: The US is not willing to partner with current FSA rebels on the ground and is also no longer willing to actively back the rebellion against the regime of Syrian President Bashar al-Assad.
Consequently, Assad is using the breathing room to intensify his bombing campaign on FSA areas, including '200 air force strikes' in 36 hours recently. So it's unclear how much territory the FSA will actually hold when the US-backed force is ready in late 2015 or 2016.
"You cannot field an effective force if you're not on the ground to advise and assist them," a senior U.S. military officer with extensive experience in training the Iraqi and Afghan militaries told WaPo.
The US plans to trained at least 5,000 moderate Syrian fighters, drawn from refugee populations, to fight ISIS.
The fighters would receive "basic training to secure their villages," according to Lt. Gen. William Mayville, the director of operations for the Pentagon's Joint Staff. Lt. Gen. Mayville added that the force "won't have the decisive effect" in the battle against ISIS.
Critics of the plan say that the lack of commitment to oust Assad will hinder the recruitment effort/
"It's immoral to ask these young men to fight and die when we're not going to protect them from Bashar Assad's barrel bombs or from ISIS," Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.), a member of the Senate Armed Services Committee, said recently. "You're not going to get people to volunteer to do that."
The CIA estimates that ISIS has as many as 31,000 fighters. US airstrikes in Iraq and Syria have killed about 464 ISIS fighters since September, according to The Syrian Observatory for Human Rights.
It's unclear how the plan as described would serve to "destroy" and "eradicate" ISIS. As experts have noted since the beginning of the campaign, the elimination of ISIS would require a much stronger commitment.
"If destroying ISIL becomes the near-term policy goal-which seems the likely outcome of saying you are going to 'roll back' the group-then 10,000-15,000 troops vastly understates the true commitment, which will actually require years, direct military action on both sides of the Iraq/Syria border, tens (if not hundreds) of billions of dollars, and many more than 15,000 troops," counterterrorism expert Brian Fishman explained in August.
However, despite the stated goal of the strategy, Obama and US officials are thus far unwilling to put American combat troops in harm's way in Syria (on top of Iraq).
"Thus far, senior military leaders have concurred in public with Obama's decision not to send ground combat troops to Syria and Iraq," Chandrasekaran writes, "but the country's top military officer, Gen. Martin Dempsey, has said that if he determines that it is necessary for U.S. advisers to accompany local forces on attacks against Islamic State targets, he would make such a recommendation to the president."
- SIMPLY PUT: What happened before India got Freedom@Midnight
- Here’s how much banks have increased home loan interest rates
- Avatar 2, Black Panther 2, Ant Man — Here is a complete list of Hollywood movies expected to hit Indian theaters in the next 6-7 months
- Qmin has been profitable business for IHCL from day one, says Jehangir Press
- India's foreign exchange reserves fall to $573 bn