scorecard
  1. Home
  2. strategy
  3. news
  4. Is your CEO brilliant, a jerk, or both? Here's how to tell

Is your CEO brilliant, a jerk, or both? Here's how to tell

Marc J. Epstein, Rob Shelton   

Is your CEO brilliant, a jerk, or both? Here's how to tell
Strategy2 min read

Adam Neumann

Fortune Brainstorm

Adam Neumann.

Rob Shelton

Courtesy of Rob Shelton

Rob Shelton.

Adam Neumann's actions at WeWork are classic "brilliant jerk." He is a smart, entrepreneurial visionary with great charisma. But, he also established a corporate culture that was filled with large doses of alcohol and drugs (according to employees who spoke to Business Insider and saw both passed around at company parties). Many questioned if the business could ever be profitable, given the significant upfront lease commitments, especially in the face of an economic turndown or less than stellar occupancy rates. He had lots of self-dealing where he received large payments from the company to buy or lease his personal assets. And, he had control of the company through dual class shares that gave him ten votes for each of his shares. Finally, the directors and funders had to admit that Adam Neumann was not cut out for the CEO job, and they fired him.

Is the creative CEO in the company you work for or in the company that you are investing in brilliant, a jerk, or both? We have seen numerous examples of visionary corporate leaders who set out to change the world. Some have succeeded, like Steve Jobs, who built Apple into a trillion-dollar company. Others are like Elizabeth Holmes, who created Theranos as an innovative blood testing company and then took the company into bankruptcy, losing investors almost a billion dollars.

Marc Epstein

Courtesy of Marc Epstein

Marc Epstein.

Jobs has certainly been referred to as a "brilliant jerk." Elon Musk, trailblazer CEO at Tesla, has behaved erratically in the past and, for some, undermined his credibility as a leader. Travis Kalanick's leadership at Uber has helped change the way transportation operates in cities around the world, but his brash operating style and the company culture he created led him to be tossed out of the company. One exasperated Uber board member proposed adding "No brilliant jerks allowed" to Uber's list of cultural values.

READ MORE ARTICLES ON


Advertisement

Advertisement