The best mascara overall
Our winner, Chanel Le Volume, lives up to its name, adding plenty of lash-boosting volume without clumping, which is often a problem with volumizing mascaras. It has a spiky brush with a blend of short and long bristles that are designed to separate and lift.
The creamy formula plumps lashes, and in our tests, we really noticed our lashes looked longer and curled upward, too, making eyes pop. All you need is one coat for daytime or two for a night out. The color is rich and bold, plus, it coats your lashes easily. In case you want it, this mascara comes in a waterproof formula, too.
Celebrity makeup artists, Kara Yoshimoto Bua and Rachel Goodwin, swear by this mascara and it is one of Elle's top mascaras. It also gets rave reviews from women who wear it every day.
One buyer who wrote a review on Macy's website said she had compliments from her co-workers the first day she wore it. One reviewer did say she experienced a little clumping, but it's easy enough to solve the issue.
Pros: Easy to apply, adds volume, length and curl, long-wearing, no flaking or smudging
Cons: High price tag
Buy Chanel le Volume Mascara at Nordstrom for $32The best drugstore mascara
Many people swear by drugstore mascaras, and this bestseller certainly has a cult following. L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Lash Paradise outdoes many more expensive types of mascaras and, in fact, is often compared to Too Faced's best-selling Better than Sex mascara.
Our drugstore favorite comes in an all-pink tube and is easy to apply, thanks to the wavy brush, which has more than 200 bristles. We were impressed with the volume and length it created with our lashes.
It also feathers lashes, really opening up the eyes. For a more dramatic look, just add a second coat. We didn't see clumping or flaking, and it stays on for hours. The formula is washable, although we found it better to use makeup remover when you take it off.
L'Oreal's mascara was even named Harper's Bazaar's Best Mascara of all time. It gets rave reviews on Influenster, with one customer saying, "it is amazing for separating lashes and really getting mascara on to each and every single one, creating a very full looking lash." It also comes in a waterproof formula.
Pros: Volumizes, lengthens, curls, washable
Cons: Possibility of some clumping
Buy L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Lash Paradise in Black from Target for $6.49 (originally $8.99)The best volumizing mascara
It's hard not to fall in love with this fabulous mascara. Lancôme's Monsieur Big claims to deliver 12 times more volume with 24-hour wear, and in our tests, it seemed to deliver. It certainly lasted all day and made our lashes look thick.
The wavy brush is easy to use and the soft bristles won't scratch your eyelids. The creamy formula contains polymers that pack lashes full of thickness, length, and jet black color. It opens up your eyes and extra coats create insane volume as well as length, for a false lash effect that we loved. It also looks as good after a night out as it does when you first put it on.
This mascara gets consistently high ratings from beauty experts and was a winner in Allure's Best of Beauty Awards in 2017. It has 10,000 likes on Sephora, with one buyer saying it was her new Holy Grail mascara.
Pros: Easy to apply, adds exceptional volume and length, very long-wearing, doesn't smudge
Cons: Can be difficult to remove
Buy Lancôme's Monsieur Big from Sephora for $25The best lengthening mascara
Short lashes be gone. Estée Lauder's Double Wear Zero-Smudge Lengthening Mascara aims to give you extra long lashes with 15-hour staying power. In our tests, the mascara lifted our lashes and made them seem longer by adding a nice curl. Even after wearing it all day and into the evening, the mascara hadn't smudged, which is a huge plus.
The brush has micro-fiber bristles to lengthen and separate to help you avoid clumping, while the formula features smudge-proof technology and polymers that coat each lash and give it a glossy, intense color. A big plus is that this mascara can resist high temperatures and humidity, making it perfect on a hot, summer's day.
Beautypedia's experts gave this mascara a perfect score, and it gets superb reviews with one Influenster reviewer, who said it made her lashes so long and her eyes look much bigger. However, there were a few reports of clumping.
Pros: Lengthens and curls lashes, doesn't smudge, stays on all day.
Cons: Needs more than one coat, tube can dry out, high price tag, easy to remove
Buy Estée Lauder Double Wear Zero-Smudge Lengthening Mascara from Sephora for $27.50 (originally $26)The best curling mascara
Benefit's Roller Lash mascara is specially designed to curl and lift lashes. In our testing, this award-winning, best-selling mascara worked wonders on our straight lashes. Its instant curve-setting formula holds for about 12 hours, too, so you keep your lashes curled to perfection.
We love the black and pink tube it comes in because it looks very glam. The special Hook 'n Roll brush, inspired by retro hair rollers, separates, lifts, and curls lashes. The formula is also designed to stay put without clumping or flaking. Benefit added pro-vitamin B5 and serin to the formula to help condition your lashes. The mascara is water-resistant, too, so you never have to worry about it running.
Rank and Style named it the best curling mascara, and one happy Sephora customer said it made her lashes look flawless. Other reviewers reported it lasts all day long.
Pros: Curls and separates, adds lengths, doesn't flake, lasts all day, water-resistant, ingredients to condition lashes
Cons: Can smudge after a while
Buy Benefit Roller Lash from Sephora for $25 (Originally $24)The best waterproof mascara
Waterproof mascara is a summer beauty staple. Your lashes need to look lush without drying out and your mascara needs to last all day. It can be hard to find one that lives up to expectations. On our hunt, we tested some top rated waterproof mascaras but were constantly disappointed. Then we came across Urban Decay Cannonball Mascara.
It has a thick, fuzzy brush designed to maximize length and volume without flaking. Once it's on your lashes, the Japanese gel-formula just won't budge.
After testing this mascara, we were very impressed with the effect and its serious staying power, which is why it is our top pick for waterproof mascara.
Instyle's Beauty Team also recommends Urban Decay's mascara, and it gets great reviews from women who wear it every day. One Macy's buyer reporting it never came off even after lots of swimming. When you do want to take it off, you need a good makeup remover.
Pros: Adds volume and length, doesn't come off in the water
Cons: Difficult to remove
Buy Urban Decay Cannonball at Sephora for $20Best fiber formula
Fiber mascaras are infused with teeny-tiny fibers that latch onto your natural lashes to add length and drama without too much effort on your end. Instead of needing to go over your lashes a hundred times to build up volume and length, the fibers do it all for you. I love the double-sided L'Oréal Paris Voluminous X Fiber Mascara for this very reason and it's one of the only things I use on my short, stubby lashes. The fact that it's also affordable at under $7 is icing on the cake (fibers on my lashes?)
You'll first have to swipe on the primer on one end of the tube. Mascara primers aren't totally innovative, but instead of the usual white color, this one is black so it blends into dark lashes and adds drama to light lashes. Then you'll sweep the fiber mascara through your lashes like you would any other regular formula; the two steps might take you a few more seconds but it's worth that additional effort. Your lashes will look super long, fluttery, and voluminous but with none of the clumps that come with piling on several coats of mascara.
It also rinses easily with water (unless you get the waterproof version), and you'll either be freaked out or impressed by the black fibers in the sink after you wash your face.
Marie Claire lauded the product as one of the best fiber mascaras that'll double the volume of your lashes (though the brand claims it's actually 7x) and Glamour dubbed it a 2019 Beauty Award Winner. Looks like both brands were impressed — just like I was.
Pros: Affordable, washes easily without needing special makeup remover, has both regular and waterproof versions
Cons: Two-step formula can be annoying for some
Buy the L'Oréal Paris Voluminous X Fiber Mascara at Target for $6.89Here are all the mascaras we tested
- Benefit They're Real
- Peter Thomas Roth Lashes To Die For The Mascara
- IT Hello Lashes
- Lancôme Definicils
- Lancôme Definicils Waterproof
- L'Oréal Paris Voluminous X Fiber Mascara
- Maybelline Total Temptation
- Maybelline Lash Sensational
- Two Faced Better Than Sex
- Body Shop Lash Hero
- Body Shop Super Volume
- Charlotte Tilbury Full Fat Lashes
- Charlotte Tilbury Legendary Lashes
- Dior Show Plump and Volume
- IT Superhero
- Juice Ultra-Natural Mascara
- Laura Geller Lash Boss
- Lancôme Hypnose Drama
- Lancôme Grandiose Waterproof
- Mac False Lashes Waterproof
- Mac Haute & Naughty Waterproof
- Mac Bold & Bad Lash
- Maybelline Great Lash
- Maybelline The Falsies Volume Express
- Urban Decay Perversion
- Urban Decay Troublemaker
