As we mentioned,
Everlane does basics really well, and part of that is due to their keen eye for trendy but classic design. This oversized option is under $70, comfortable, and the perfect mix of slouchy and fitted.
Everlane's reputation is owed to its ethically made, transparently priced basics. But, it actually excels because of its precise designing of classic wardrobe staples — like the button-down — that feel simultaneously vintage and perfectly updated.
The Silky Cotton Oversized Shirt is a textbook example. As Everlane puts it, this is the "perfect button-down you can never find, found." It's not so oversized that it feels like you actually stole a tall man's button-down and wore it to work, but it has the breezy spaciousness of one. It's fitted through the shoulders and arms, and most of the volume is contained to the back, so you get the Meg-Ryan-walking-through-the-park, je-ne-sais-quoi effect rather than the sheet-as-a-toga-dress costume effect. Wear it loose, tucked in, or front-tucked, and to work during the week or the farmer's market on the weekend.
The Silky Cotton Oversized Shirt is also appropriately named. It's smooth and cool to the touch, and the colors include a rich blue indigo (shown above), off-white, black, and even a grey pinstripe option. You can pick it up in sizes 00-16, and though I often size down when something is described as "oversized," I found this to be true to size.
In terms of cons, you won't often find popular items like this at a discount at Everlane; they consider transparent prices to essentially be a year-round sale. But, if you think $60 is justifiable for one perfect version of the oversized button-down, I think you'll be happy with your purchase. You also may find four colors to be a limited selection, and some sizes can be prone to sell out due to popularity. — Mara Leighton
Pros: Transparent and environmentally responsible production, the perfect combination of slouchy and fitted style, comfortable to wear
Cons: Unlikely to see sales, relatively pricey
Check out Everlane's selection of button-downs