The new Galaxy S10e is what Apple's iPhone XR should have been all along

Advertisement
The new Galaxy S10e is what Apple's iPhone XR should have been all along

samsung galaxy s10e

YouTube/MKBHD

Advertisement

Samsung last week introduced five (!) new phones, including the Galaxy S10e.

At $750, the Galaxy S10e might seem like Samsung's challenger to the iPhone XR, which has an identical starting price. But the Galaxy S10e is a better phone than the iPhone XR - and more importantly, it has a more logical place in Samsung's smartphone lineup.

Complimentary Tech Event
Transform talent with learning that works
Capability development is critical for businesses who want to push the envelope of innovation.Discover how business leaders are strategizing around building talent capabilities and empowering employee transformation.Know More

It's unclear whether or not Apple will release a successor to the iPhone XR in 2019 - but if it does, it should take a page from Samsung's Galaxy S10e.

Here's why.

Advertisement

This is an opinion column. The thoughts expressed are those of the author.

{{}}

Many people will compare the Galaxy S10e to Apple's iPhone XR, as the two phones share the same starting price. But in many ways, the Galaxy S10e feels more like Samsung's version of Apple's iPhone XS — but $250 cheaper, of course.

Many people will compare the Galaxy S10e to Apple's iPhone XR, as the two phones share the same starting price. But in many ways, the Galaxy S10e feels more like Samsung's version of Apple's iPhone XS — but $250 cheaper, of course.

The Galaxy S10e looks almost identical to the $1,000 iPhone XS. Both phones have a flat 5.8-inch OLED screen, which produces bright and crisp images.

The Galaxy S10e looks almost identical to the $1,000 iPhone XS. Both phones have a flat 5.8-inch OLED screen, which produces bright and crisp images.
Advertisement

Meanwhile, Apple's $750 iPhone XR has an LCD screen, which isn't as good.

Meanwhile, Apple's $750 iPhone XR has an LCD screen, which isn't as good.

The Galaxy S10e and iPhone XS also share two cameras on the back — the iPhone XR only has a single rear lens.

The Galaxy S10e and iPhone XS also share two cameras on the back — the iPhone XR only has a single rear lens.
Advertisement

The Galaxy S10e doesn't have anything like Face ID, Apple's facial recognition system for unlocking the phone or making purchases; instead, it has a traditional fingerprint sensor on the power button. But that's not a deal-breaker.

The Galaxy S10e doesn't have anything like Face ID, Apple's facial recognition system for unlocking the phone or making purchases; instead, it has a traditional fingerprint sensor on the power button. But that's not a deal-breaker.

The Galaxy S10e feels like the best possible phone Samsung could have made at its size. It makes sense in the lineup as well: Since it lacks the triple-camera system, curved display, and in-screen fingerprint reader of the Galaxy S10 and S10+, it's cheaper than both of those phones.

The Galaxy S10e feels like the best possible phone Samsung could have made at its size. It makes sense in the lineup as well: Since it lacks the triple-camera system, curved display, and in-screen fingerprint reader of the Galaxy S10 and S10+, it's cheaper than both of those phones.
Advertisement

Meanwhile, Apple's Galaxy S10e counterpart, the iPhone XR, is awkward. It's bigger than the iPhone XS, smaller than the iPhone XS Max, but isn't superior to either phone.

Meanwhile, Apple's Galaxy S10e counterpart, the iPhone XR, is awkward. It's bigger than the iPhone XS, smaller than the iPhone XS Max, but isn't superior to either phone.

Given the sacrifices Apple made to its display quality and rear-camera system, the iPhone XR does not feel like the best possible phone Apple could have made at its size.

Given the sacrifices Apple made to its display quality and rear-camera system, the iPhone XR does not feel like the best possible phone Apple could have made at its size.
Advertisement

Apple's phones still have plenty of advantages over the Galaxy phones, in general. The Apple ecosystem, the stability of iOS, and the frequent software updates straight from Apple still make any iPhone a very appealing choice. But Samsung is closing the gap, thanks to its hardware prowess.

Apple's phones still have plenty of advantages over the Galaxy phones, in general. The Apple ecosystem, the stability of iOS, and the frequent software updates straight from Apple still make any iPhone a very appealing choice. But Samsung is closing the gap, thanks to its hardware prowess.

The Galaxy S10e is what Apple's iPhone XR should have been all along: the smallest and most affordable "new" phone in the lineup.

The Galaxy S10e is what Apple's iPhone XR should have been all along: the smallest and most affordable "new" phone in the lineup.
Advertisement

The iPhone XR would have made more sense as a smaller alternative to the iPhone XS. But without the OLED screen, it's very hard to choose the iPhone XR over the iPhone XS objectively, due to that noticeable gap in display quality.

The iPhone XR would have made more sense as a smaller alternative to the iPhone XS. But without the OLED screen, it's very hard to choose the iPhone XR over the iPhone XS objectively, due to that noticeable gap in display quality.

The new Galaxy phones are easier to understand from a customer's perspective. Every phone has an OLED screen, but some phones have more screen real estate, or an extra camera lens. For each step up in size, you're also getting a slight step up in quality.

The new Galaxy phones are easier to understand from a customer's perspective. Every phone has an OLED screen, but some phones have more screen real estate, or an extra camera lens. For each step up in size, you're also getting a slight step up in quality.
Advertisement

Apple's iPhone lineup is the weakest it's been in years, and that's due to the confusion created by the iPhone XR — an iPhone that's sized between the iPhone XS and XS Max, but inferior to both phones.

Apple's iPhone lineup is the weakest it's been in years, and that's due to the confusion created by the iPhone XR — an iPhone that's sized between the iPhone XS and XS Max, but inferior to both phones.

Apple is still the gold standard for the seamless integration of hardware, software, and services, but Samsung and others are catching up.

It would behoove Apple to consider the logic of the Galaxy S10 lineup, where price correlates with size but not quality, when considering how to produce and market its 2019 iPhones.