I tried Guy Fieri's barbecue on a cruise in the middle of the ocean, and even as a non-meat eater, it lived up to the hype

Advertisement
I tried Guy Fieri's barbecue on a cruise in the middle of the ocean, and even as a non-meat eater, it lived up to the hype
  • I was aboard the Carnival Vista, which was Carnival's first ship to sail from the US since 2020.
  • I spent my seven-day trip feasting at the ship's eateries, which included not one, but two buffets by Guy Fieri.
  • Guy's Pig and Anchor Bar-B-Que Smokehouse was the only place on the ship where I was able to get comfort foods like mac and cheese.
Advertisement

I spent a week aboard the Carnival Vista, which was Carnival Cruise Line's first ship to leave the US since 2020.

I spent a week aboard the Carnival Vista, which was Carnival Cruise Line's first ship to leave the US since 2020.
The Carnival Vista docked in Cozumel, Mexico. Monica Humphries/Insider

The vaccinated cruisers I spoke with were excited to be back in the open ocean - and so was I.

The vaccinated cruisers I spoke with were excited to be back in the open ocean - and so was I.
A selfie of the author on the Carnival Vista. Monica Humphries/Insider
Advertisement

And most of us were thrilled about the food. The Carnival Vista has more than a dozen places to eat - including not one, but two buffets created by celebrity chef and Food Network legend Guy Fieri. Both of Fieri's eateries were included in the cost of the cruise.

And most of us were thrilled about the food. The Carnival Vista has more than a dozen places to eat - including not one, but two buffets created by celebrity chef and Food Network legend Guy Fieri. Both of Fieri's eateries were included in the cost of the cruise.
The two buffets that were created by Guy Fieri on the Carnival Vista. Monica Humphries/Insider

So on the third day of my trip, I navigated to deck five and hopped in line at Guy's Pig and Anchor Bar-B-Que Smokehouse, which, hence the name, is the chef's barbecue-themed eatery.

So on the third day of my trip, I navigated to deck five and hopped in line at Guy's Pig and Anchor Bar-B-Que Smokehouse, which, hence the name, is the chef's barbecue-themed eatery.
A passenger studies the menu before stepping into Guy's Pig abd Anchor Bar-B-Que Smokehouse's buffet line. Monica Humphries/Insider
Advertisement

From pork butt and smoked andouille sausage to comfort foods like mac and cheese, the buffet seemed to have all the traditional fixings of a typical barbecue restaurant.

From pork butt and smoked andouille sausage to comfort foods like mac and cheese, the buffet seemed to have all the traditional fixings of a typical barbecue restaurant.
The menu to Guy's Pig and Anchor Bar-B-Que Smokehouse. Monica Humphries/Insider

I'm a pescetarian, so I planned to skip the red meat. Luckily, I think the sides are always the best part of a meal, and I planned to try them all.

I'm a pescetarian, so I planned to skip the red meat. Luckily, I think the sides are always the best part of a meal, and I planned to try them all.
A passenger eyes the barbecue food. Monica Humphries/Insider
Advertisement

Crew members dished out hefty portions of the mac and cheese, coleslaw, and potato salad onto my metal plate.

Crew members dished out hefty portions of the mac and cheese, coleslaw, and potato salad onto my metal plate.
My plate of sides, which included coleslaw, mac and cheese, and potato salad. Monica Humphries/Insider

I also tried the three barbecue sauces available at the time: bourbon brown sugar, spicy Sriracha, and a Kansas City smokey and sweet sauce.

I also tried the three barbecue sauces available at the time: bourbon brown sugar, spicy Sriracha, and a Kansas City smokey and sweet sauce.
The three different barbecue sauces I tried. Monica Humphries/Insider
Advertisement

First up was the mac and cheese. This was the only place on the ship where I found this dish, so I was happy to indulge in the comfort food. The noodles were cooked just right, and the cheese sauce was delicious.

First up was the mac and cheese. This was the only place on the ship where I found this dish, so I was happy to indulge in the comfort food. The noodles were cooked just right, and the cheese sauce was delicious.
A close-up image of the mac and cheese. Monica Humphries/Insider

However, the potato salad was unmemorable. I thought the potatoes were undercooked and the dressing was flavorless.

However, the potato salad was unmemorable. I thought the potatoes were undercooked and the dressing was flavorless.
The potato salad was my least favorite side. Monica Humphries/Insider
Advertisement

The buffet's coleslaw stood out the most. It had a nice crunch and just the right amount of creaminess.

The buffet's coleslaw stood out the most. It had a nice crunch and just the right amount of creaminess.
Coleslaw was my favorite side. Monica Humphries/Insider

Meanwhile, the barbecue sauces were the biggest disappointment. I thought the three flavors tasted nearly identical to one another.

Meanwhile, the barbecue sauces were the biggest disappointment. I thought the three flavors tasted nearly identical to one another.
The four hot sauces at Guy's Pig and Anchor Bar-B-Que Smokehouse. Monica Humphries/Insider
Advertisement

After I finished my plate, I searched for passengers who tried the meat at the Pig and Anchor Bar-B-Que Smokehouse. But Fieri had some tough competition, because many of the passengers I spoke to were from Texas and took their barbecue seriously.

After I finished my plate, I searched for passengers who tried the meat at the Pig and Anchor Bar-B-Que Smokehouse. But Fieri had some tough competition, because many of the passengers I spoke to were from Texas and took their barbecue seriously.
Crew members load meat onto a plate at Guy's Pig and Anchor Bar-B-Que Smokehouse. Monica Humphries/Insider

Some passengers mentioned enjoying the buffet, while others told me that they planned to wait until they got back home before indulging in barbecue again.

Some passengers mentioned enjoying the buffet, while others told me that they planned to wait until they got back home before indulging in barbecue again.
A passenger looks at her options at Guy's Pig and Anchor Bar-B-Que Smokehouse. Monica Humphries/Insider
Advertisement

Unfortunately, the nearby Guy's Burger Joint lacked veggie burgers, so I stayed clear of that buffet. But from the looks of the long line, it seemed worth the wait.

Unfortunately, the nearby Guy's Burger Joint lacked veggie burgers, so I stayed clear of that buffet. But from the looks of the long line, it seemed worth the wait.
The front of Guy's Burger Joint on the Carnival Vista. Monica Humphries/Insider

There, crew members cooked burgers on a flat-top stove, served up fries, and a topping bar awaited passengers with every addition imaginable.

There, crew members cooked burgers on a flat-top stove, served up fries, and a topping bar awaited passengers with every addition imaginable.
A passenger grabs his burger from Guy's Burger Joint on the Carnival Vista. Monica Humphries/Insider
Advertisement

Overall, Guy's barbecue added much-needed variety from the daily buffet and dining room. And as Insider previously reported, cruise superfans agree that it's always a good idea to explore all the dining options a cruise has to offer.

Overall, Guy's barbecue added much-needed variety from the daily buffet and dining room. And as Insider previously reported, cruise superfans agree that it's always a good idea to explore all the dining options a cruise has to offer.
I enjoyed the food overlooking the expansive sea. Monica Humphries/Insider

Read more tips from cruise superfans who spoke with Insider aboard the Carnival Vista, who shared the 10 common mistakes they see passengers make.