bi_cube_banner
bi_cube_banner
bi_cube_banner
bi_cube_banner

China is hoping to begin deliveries of its first mainline airliner soon. Here's how the jet compares to its Boeing and Airbus competition.

Advertisement
China is hoping to begin deliveries of its first mainline airliner soon. Here's how the jet compares to its Boeing and Airbus competition.
  • China hopes to begin delivery of its first-ever home-built mainline airliner, the Comac C919, this year.
  • The planemaker's jet does not stack up to Boeing and Airbus' competing narrowbodies, analysts say.
Advertisement

State-owned aerospace manufacturer Commercial Aircraft Corporation of China (Comac) is hoping to deliver its first-ever C919 passenger jet this year.

State-owned aerospace manufacturer Commercial Aircraft Corporation of China (Comac) is hoping to deliver its first-ever C919 passenger jet this year.
Comac C919.Reuters

Production of the plane started in 2011 and the first prototype rolled off the assembly line in 2015.

Production of the plane started in 2011 and the first prototype rolled off the assembly line in 2015.
The first C919 rolls off the assembly line in 2015.STR/AFP via Getty Images
Advertisement

Two years later, in May 2017, the C919 took its maiden flight over Shanghai.

Two years later, in May 2017, the C919 took its maiden flight over Shanghai.
Comac C919 test flight.Reuters

While the company hoped the twin jet would enter the market before 2020, regulatory, technological, and supply issues turtled the process.

While the company hoped the twin jet would enter the market before 2020, regulatory, technological, and supply issues turtled the process.
Comac C919.Getty Images/Stringer
Advertisement

Specifically, Comac was impacted by restrictions imposed by the Trump Administration in 2020 that blackballed shipments of things like fight controls and jet engines.

Specifically, Comac was impacted by restrictions imposed by the Trump Administration in 2020 that blackballed shipments of things like fight controls and jet engines.
CFM LEAP engines.PIERRE VERDY/AFP via Getty Images

Source: Nikkei Asia

According to a report by the Center for Strategic & International Studies, a think tank based in Washington, DC, about 60% of the C919 parts are supplied by American companies.

According to a report by the Center for Strategic & International Studies, a think tank based in Washington, DC, about 60% of the C919 parts are supplied by American companies.
Cockpit mockup of the C919.Reuters

Source: Nikkei Asia

Advertisement

As a result, Comac was forced to rely on special licenses from entities like General Electric and Honeywell to get the parts it needed for the C919 jet.

As a result, Comac was forced to rely on special licenses from entities like General Electric and Honeywell to get the parts it needed for the C919 jet.
Honeywell headquarters.DAVID BREWSTER/Star Tribune via Getty Images

Source: Nikkei Asia

In addition to supply challenges, the Civil Aviation Administration of China (CAAC), the country's aviation regulator, has not yet certified the jet to fly.

In addition to supply challenges, the Civil Aviation Administration of China (CAAC), the country's aviation regulator, has not yet certified the jet to fly.
Comac C919.Reuters

Source: Nikkei Asia

Advertisement

CAAC spokesperson Yang Zhenmei told Reuters that the plane has only completed 34 out of the required 276 test flights needed for certification, as of December 2021.

CAAC spokesperson Yang Zhenmei told Reuters that the plane has only completed 34 out of the required 276 test flights needed for certification, as of December 2021.
Comac C919.STR/AFP via Getty Images

Source: Reuters

Nevertheless, the agency says the C919's approval is an important focus for 2022. According to Zhenmei, the agency has imposed strict airworthiness standards for the plane, including over 40,000 days of manpower to review everything.

Nevertheless, the agency says the C919's approval is an important focus for 2022. According to Zhenmei, the agency has imposed strict airworthiness standards for the plane, including over 40,000 days of manpower to review everything.
Production of the C919.Reuters

Source: Global Times

Advertisement

Despite the setbacks, Comac is hoping its first delivery will happen in 2022.

Despite the setbacks, Comac is hoping its first delivery will happen in 2022.
Comac C919.Reuters

Source: Reuters

Once the C919 hits the market, it will compete with the world's leading aircraft manufacturers — Boeing and Airbus.

Once the C919 hits the market, it will compete with the world's leading aircraft manufacturers — Boeing and Airbus.
Boeing 737 MAXBlueBarronPhoto/Shutterstock

Source: CNET

Advertisement

"They've [Comac] decided to spend as much as needed and take as long as necessary until they have their own plane that can rival Boeing and Airbus," Center for Strategic and International Studies advisor, Scott Kennedy, told American media website CNET.

"They've [Comac] decided to spend as much as needed and take as long as necessary until they have their own plane that can rival Boeing and Airbus," Center for Strategic and International Studies advisor, Scott Kennedy, told American media website CNET.
Airbus A320neoAirbus

Source: CNET

"The political ambition from the top leaders is that China has its own aircraft because, in their mind, great nations have their own airliners," he continued.

"The political ambition from the top leaders is that China has its own aircraft because, in their mind, great nations have their own airliners," he continued.
Comac C919.Shi Yuge/VCG via Getty Images

Source: CNET

Advertisement

Boeing's 737 variants and Airbus' A320 family have ruled the narrowbody market for decades, so it will be a tough road ahead for the Chinese planemaker, regardless of whether the jet ever operates outside the country.

Boeing's 737 variants and Airbus' A320 family have ruled the narrowbody market for decades, so it will be a tough road ahead for the Chinese planemaker, regardless of whether the jet ever operates outside the country.
Boeing and Airbus.Boeing/Airbus

One of the biggest challenges Comac will face is overcoming Boeing's influence in China, especially since the 737 MAX was recently cleared to fly in the country again after two fatal crashes grounded the plane in 2019.

One of the biggest challenges Comac will face is overcoming Boeing's influence in China, especially since the 737 MAX was recently cleared to fly in the country again after two fatal crashes grounded the plane in 2019.
Ethiopian Airlines' 737 MAX crashed in 2019.Skycolors/Shutterstock

Source: Reuters

Advertisement

Boeing stocks skyrocketed after the decision, strengthening the planemaker's position in the Asian nation. The move will allow more than 100 MAX planes to be delivered to Chinese carriers.

Boeing stocks skyrocketed after the decision, strengthening the planemaker's position in the Asian nation. The move will allow more than 100 MAX planes to be delivered to Chinese carriers.
China Southern Boeing 737 MAX 8.aapsky/Shutterstock

Source: VOA News

Meanwhile, Airbus has a strong presence in China as well, delivering 142 planes to Chinese companies in 2021, 130 of which were single-aisle aircraft.

Meanwhile, Airbus has a strong presence in China as well, delivering 142 planes to Chinese companies in 2021, 130 of which were single-aisle aircraft.
Chinese carrier Spring Airlines operates the A320.Markus Mainka/Shutterstock

Source: China Daily

Advertisement

Overall, about 2,100 Airbus aircraft and over 330 Airbus helicopters were operating in China as of the end of last year, according to data from the planemaker.

Overall, about 2,100 Airbus aircraft and over 330 Airbus helicopters were operating in China as of the end of last year, according to data from the planemaker.
Airbus Helicopters plant in Spain.Hans Geel/Shutterstock

Source: China Daily

To further strengthen ties between the manufacturers and China, both Boeing and Airbus have also established aircraft assembly facilities in the nation.

To further strengthen ties between the manufacturers and China, both Boeing and Airbus have also established aircraft assembly facilities in the nation.
A Flair Airlines Boeing 737 Max 8.Philippe Godin / Shutterstock.com

Source: CNET

Advertisement

Boeing has a 737 completion and delivery center in Zhoushan, which is a joint plant between Comac and the planemaker.

Boeing has a 737 completion and delivery center in Zhoushan, which is a joint plant between Comac and the planemaker.
Site of the first Boeing 737 MAX delivery from its completion center in China.Comac

Source: Boeing

Meanwhile, Airbus has an A320 final assembly line in Tianjin, China.

Meanwhile, Airbus has an A320 final assembly line in Tianjin, China.
A320 assembly in Tianjin.MARK RALSTON/AFP/GettyImages

Source: Airbus

Advertisement

In addition to the burden of competing against powerful household names, the C919 will also have to prove itself in terms of efficiency and performance.

In addition to the burden of competing against powerful household names, the C919 will also have to prove itself in terms of efficiency and performance.
Comac C919.Reuters

Unfortunately for Comac, the plane falls short of the 737 MAX and A320neo, according to Richard Aboulafia of AeroDynamic Advisory, a US-based consulting company.

Unfortunately for Comac, the plane falls short of the 737 MAX and A320neo, according to Richard Aboulafia of AeroDynamic Advisory, a US-based consulting company.
Production of the C919.Reuters
Advertisement

"There's no technological selling point for this jet," he told CNET and also explained to Insider.

"There's no technological selling point for this jet," he told CNET and also explained to Insider.
Comac C919.Costfoto/Barcroft Media via Getty Images

Shukor Yusof of Endau Analytics, a Malaysia-based advisory and research company, echoed Aboulafia, saying China lags behind the US and Europe in terms of technology.

Shukor Yusof of Endau Analytics, a Malaysia-based advisory and research company, echoed Aboulafia, saying China lags behind the US and Europe in terms of technology.
JetBlue A320 aircraft.Marcus Mainka/Shutterstock

Source: CNET

Advertisement

This is a problem for Comac because its own engineers are not as experienced in plane-making.

This is a problem for Comac because its own engineers are not as experienced in plane-making.
Production of the C919.Reuters

Source: CNET

As a result, the C919 is not technologically advanced or more fuel-efficient compared to Airbus and Boeing's products, which is a priority for safety and cost-sensitive airlines.

As a result, the C919 is not technologically advanced or more fuel-efficient compared to Airbus and Boeing's products, which is a priority for safety and cost-sensitive airlines.
An Alaska Airlines Boeing 737 Max 9 EcoDemonstrator.Thomas Pallini/Insider

Source: CNET

Advertisement

"I would describe [the C919] like a Nokia phone competing against Apple's iPhone and Samsung's Galaxy S," Yosuf told CNET. "It's just not "cool."

"I would describe [the C919] like a Nokia phone competing against Apple's iPhone and Samsung's Galaxy S," Yosuf told CNET. "It's just not "cool."
Comac C919.Reuters

Source: CNET

According to the plane's specifications, its size and wingspan are similar to the 737 MAX and the A320neo, but its frame is closer to Airbus' narrowbody. However, its range is shorter than both rivals.

According to the plane's specifications, its size and wingspan are similar to the 737 MAX and the A320neo, but its frame is closer to Airbus' narrowbody. However, its range is shorter than both rivals.
C919 cockpit on display in 2017.Associated Press

Source: Insider

Advertisement

Specifically, the jet has a max range of 5,555 kilometers (3,452 miles), which is less than its competing narrowbodies.

Specifically, the jet has a max range of 5,555 kilometers (3,452 miles), which is less than its competing narrowbodies.
Comac C919.Reuters

Source: Comac

Boeing's 737 MAX 8, the company's most popular MAX variant, can fly up to 6,570 kilometers (4,082 miles), while the A320neo can fly up to 6,300 km (3,915 miles).

Boeing's 737 MAX 8, the company's most popular MAX variant, can fly up to 6,570 kilometers (4,082 miles), while the A320neo can fly up to 6,300 km (3,915 miles).
WestJet Boeing 737 MAX 8Joel Serre/Shutterstock

Source: Boeing, Airbus

Advertisement

As far as passenger capacity, the C919 falls short once again, offering a maximum of 168 seats.

As far as passenger capacity, the C919 falls short once again, offering a maximum of 168 seats.
C919 cabin interior display.Reuters

Source: Comac

Meanwhile, the A320neo can hold between 150 and 180 people in two cabins, and up to 194 in a high-density configuration…

Meanwhile, the A320neo can hold between 150 and 180 people in two cabins, and up to 194 in a high-density configuration…
The cabin of a Frontier Airlines Airbus A320neo.Thomas Pallini/Insider

Source: Airbus

Advertisement

…while the MAX 8 can carry up to 178 seats in a two-class configuration. The maximum number of seats the plane can carry is 210.

…while the MAX 8 can carry up to 178 seats in a two-class configuration. The maximum number of seats the plane can carry is 210.
Singapore Airlines 737 MAX business class cabinSingapore Airlines

Source: Boeing

As far as engines, the C919 uses Leap engines produced by CFM, a joint venture between General Electric and French aerospace company Safran. Both the 737 MAX and A320neo also use the company's engine.

As far as engines, the C919 uses Leap engines produced by CFM, a joint venture between General Electric and French aerospace company Safran. Both the 737 MAX and A320neo also use the company's engine.
REMY GABALDA/AFP via Getty Images

Source: CNET, Boeing, Airbus

Advertisement

However, China hopes to eventually use its own homegrown engines to lessen its reliance on foreign technology. So, the country is developing the AECC CJ-1000A, a turbofan jet engine that it hopes will be complete by 2025.

However, China hopes to eventually use its own homegrown engines to lessen its reliance on foreign technology. So, the country is developing the AECC CJ-1000A, a turbofan jet engine that it hopes will be complete by 2025.
China-made CJ1000 engine.Feature China/Barcroft Media via Getty Images

Source: Reuters

While the C919 is lagging behind its competitors in almost every facet of its design, there is one thing that could make it competitive in the market — its price.

While the C919 is lagging behind its competitors in almost every facet of its design, there is one thing that could make it competitive in the market — its price.
Comac C919.STR/AFP via Getty Images
Advertisement

Although the exact price tag has not been made public by Comac, analysts estimate a single plane would cost buyers about $50 million.

Although the exact price tag has not been made public by Comac, analysts estimate a single plane would cost buyers about $50 million.
Comac C919.ALY SONG/AFP via Getty Images

That is about 60% less than Boeing's 737 MAX 8 and 55% less than Airbus' A320neo, which are $121.6 million and $110.6 million, respectively, as of 2021.

That is about 60% less than Boeing's 737 MAX 8 and 55% less than Airbus' A320neo, which are $121.6 million and $110.6 million, respectively, as of 2021.
A VivaAerobus Airbus A320neo.AaronP/Bauer-Griffin/GC Images
Advertisement

Overall, the C919 falls behind its competitors, but the jet is still a viable option for domestic flying in China or other neighboring countries says Yusof, despite its lacking cabin size and range.

Overall, the C919 falls behind its competitors, but the jet is still a viable option for domestic flying in China or other neighboring countries says Yusof, despite its lacking cabin size and range.
Comac C919.Shi Yuge/VCG via Getty Images

Source: CNET

"There's a desire to offer an Asian-made aircraft to Third World countries at lower prices compared to those marketed by Boeing and Airbus," he said.

"There's a desire to offer an Asian-made aircraft to Third World countries at lower prices compared to those marketed by Boeing and Airbus," he said.
Employees working on the C919.HECTOR RETAMAL/AFP via Getty Images

Source: CNET

Advertisement

"We believe that the C919 will bring new competition to the market and the Chinese market is big enough to have more than two manufacturers, Airbus told CNET. "Airbus was born in competition and thrived in competition."

"We believe that the C919 will bring new competition to the market and the Chinese market is big enough to have more than two manufacturers, Airbus told CNET. "Airbus was born in competition and thrived in competition."
Airbus A320.Airbus

Source: CNET

"Competition makes all of us better as it spurs innovation and the development of new technologies that meet the evolving needs of our customers," the company commented. "This is good for airline and cargo operators and the broader flying public."

"Competition makes all of us better as it spurs innovation and the development of new technologies that meet the evolving needs of our customers," the company commented. "This is good for airline and cargo operators and the broader flying public."
Ashlee D. Smith/Southwest Airlines

Source: CNET

Advertisement

The success of Comac is still uncertain, but the company's only other commercial jet, the ARJ21, has provided the planemaker with some optimism.

The success of Comac is still uncertain, but the company's only other commercial jet, the ARJ21, has provided the planemaker with some optimism.
China Southern ARJ21.Mario Hagen/Shutterstock

The 90-seater "advanced regional jet", which analysts say is similar to the McDonnell Douglas MD-80 plane, first entered commercial service in 2016 with Chengdu Airlines. Since then, the company has delivered 66 units, according to Ascend by Cirium data.

The 90-seater "advanced regional jet", which analysts say is similar to the McDonnell Douglas MD-80 plane, first entered commercial service in 2016 with Chengdu Airlines. Since then, the company has delivered 66 units, according to Ascend by Cirium data.
Chengdu Airlines AJR21.REUTERS/Aly Song
Advertisement

The country hopes the new airliner will make it less reliant on foreign-made technology, which is part of the nation's "Made in China 2025" plan.

The country hopes the new airliner will make it less reliant on foreign-made technology, which is part of the nation's "Made in China 2025" plan.
Comac C919.Reuters

Whether or not the C919 ever gains popularity comparable to its American and European rivals, it is still a symbol of China's push for technological and manufacturing advancements in the world's $200 billion aviation industry.

Whether or not the C919 ever gains popularity comparable to its American and European rivals, it is still a symbol of China's push for technological and manufacturing advancements in the world's $200 billion aviation industry.
Comac C919.ALY SONG/AFP via Getty Images

Source: CNET

Advertisement

First coined in 2015, "Made in China 2025" is the country's goal to be self-sufficient in several industries, like transportation, phones, cars, and medical products.

First coined in 2015, "Made in China 2025" is the country's goal to be self-sufficient in several industries, like transportation, phones, cars, and medical products.
Workers at the assembly line of Chinese automobile manufacturer Leapmotor in Jinhua, Zhejiang Province of China.Li Jianlin/VCG via Getty Images

However, Aboulafia noted to Insider that the plane is not really a Chinese jet. "It's put together in China, but the technologies and systems are from the West," he explained.

However, Aboulafia noted to Insider that the plane is not really a Chinese jet. "It's put together in China, but the technologies and systems are from the West," he explained.
Comac C919.Reuters

Source: Insider

Advertisement

The C919 tackles the transportation sector, and China hopes the plane will generate billions of dollars at home without the burden of tariffs.

The C919 tackles the transportation sector, and China hopes the plane will generate billions of dollars at home without the burden of tariffs.
Production of the C919.Reuters

Source: Insider