I compared Target's and Walmart's Hanukkah sections, and Walmart's quirky items are perfect for Hanukkah parties

Advertisement
I compared Target's and Walmart's Hanukkah sections, and Walmart's quirky items are perfect for Hanukkah parties
  • I went to Target and Walmart the night before Hanukkah began to compare their Hanukkah sections.
  • It took three Target employees to find the small selection at the store I visited in New Jersey.
Advertisement

My first stop for Hanukkah shopping was Target in Cherry Hill, New Jersey.

My first stop for Hanukkah shopping was Target in Cherry Hill, New Jersey.
Target in Cherry Hill, New Jersey.Talia Lakritz/Insider

I went shopping the night before Hanukkah, which was the Saturday night following Black Friday, so the parking lot was full of shoppers.

The Target had a giant holiday section with aisles of seasonal items, but I didn't see any Hanukkah supplies there.

The Target had a giant holiday section with aisles of seasonal items, but I didn't see any Hanukkah supplies there.
Target's holiday section.Talia Lakritz/Insider

The first Target employee I asked about Hanukkah items recommended checking out the holiday section, but it was entirely Christmas-themed.

Advertisement

Another Target employee suggested trying a different holiday display near the household essentials, but there was no sign of Hanukkah there, either.

Another Target employee suggested trying a different holiday display near the household essentials, but there was no sign of Hanukkah there, either.
A holiday display at Target.Talia Lakritz/Insider

There were more generic holiday items like scented candles and red pillows, but no menorahs or dreidels.

Finally, a third Target employee looked up where to find the Hanukkah shelves and located them tucked away at the end of an aisle.

Finally, a third Target employee looked up where to find the Hanukkah shelves and located them tucked away at the end of an aisle.
Target's Hanukkah section.Talia Lakritz/Insider

At this particular store, the menorahs and candles were located between the arts and crafts and party supplies. It's possible that other Targets have Hanukkah items for sale near the rest of the seasonal displays.

Advertisement

They had a plethora of gold menorahs retailing for $15, as well as candles.

They had a plethora of gold menorahs retailing for $15, as well as candles.
Menorahs for sale at Target.Talia Lakritz/Insider

There were also larger, silver menorahs for $25.

The Hanukkah section featured a dreidel game set for $5.

The Hanukkah section featured a dreidel game set for $5.
A dreidel game kit.Talia Lakritz/Insider

"Dreidel" is Yiddish for "spinning top." It has four sides with a different Hebrew letter on each one. Players start with a supply of coins, chocolate or otherwise, and take turns spinning. Depending on which letter the top lands on, they put a coin in the middle, skip their turn, win half of the coins, or take home the entire pot.

Advertisement

Target also had chocolate coins known as Hanukkah gelt.

Target also had chocolate coins known as Hanukkah gelt.
Hanukkah gelt.Talia Lakritz/Insider

A bag of chocolate coins cost $1.

They even had a "Mitzvah Moose," a blue stuffed animal with light-up candles on its antlers.

They even had a "Mitzvah Moose," a blue stuffed animal with light-up candles on its antlers.
A "Mitzvah Moose."Talia Lakritz/Insider

The "Mitzvah Moose" cost $24.99.

Advertisement

While Target had all of the Hanukkah essentials, I found the Hanukkah shelves to be pretty sparse.

While Target had all of the Hanukkah essentials, I found the Hanukkah shelves to be pretty sparse.
Hanukkah mugs.Talia Lakritz/Insider

To me, the Hanukkah section seemed more like an afterthought, with a narrow selection of mostly basic items.

Next, I drove a little further down the road to Walmart.

Next, I drove a little further down the road to Walmart.
Walmart in Cherry Hill, New Jersey.Talia Lakritz/Insider

Even thought it was Saturday night, Walmart was also packed with Black Friday shoppers.

Advertisement

There were a few Hanukkah-themed items scattered around the store, but a Walmart employee promptly directed me to the Hanukkah shelves amid the seasonal products.

There were a few Hanukkah-themed items scattered around the store, but a Walmart employee promptly directed me to the Hanukkah shelves amid the seasonal products.
Hanukkah socks at Walmart.Talia Lakritz/Insider

These Hanukkah socks, located near the checkout aisles, cost $1.

Walmart's Hanukkah section was also small, but it appeared to be better stocked than the one at the Target I had visited.

Walmart's Hanukkah section was also small, but it appeared to be better stocked than the one at the Target I had visited.
Walmart's Hanukkah section.Talia Lakritz/Insider

Target's shelves had lots of empty space compared to Walmart's shelves bursting with blue and silver.

Advertisement

Walmart's silver menorahs appeared to be inspired by tree trunks.

Walmart's silver menorahs appeared to be inspired by tree trunks.
A silver menorah at Walmart.Talia Lakritz/Insider

The menorahs cost $14.98 each, about the same as menorahs at Target.

Walmart also had a portable electric menorah for those who might be traveling during the holiday.

Walmart also had a portable electric menorah for those who might be traveling during the holiday.
A portable menorah.Talia Lakritz/Insider

The Go Menorah cost $12.98.

Advertisement

Hanukkah-themed stemless glasses, which were actually plastic, retailed for $1.97.

Hanukkah-themed stemless glasses, which were actually plastic, retailed for $1.97.
A plastic "Happy Hanukkah" cup.Talia Lakritz/Insider

I personally liked the colorful designs of Walmart's Hanukkah glasses better than Target's plain mugs.

Walmart's Hanukkah section had tons of holiday decor, which I didn't find at the Target I visited.

Walmart's Hanukkah section had tons of holiday decor, which I didn't find at the Target I visited.
Hanukkah decor.Talia Lakritz/Insider

A hanging sign read "Light it up!" "Eight night," and "Eight lights."

Target does sell Hanukkah-themed decor on its website, but, according to the information there, most of the items are not available in stores.

Advertisement

This 6-foot Hanukkah banner cost $4.97.

This 6-foot Hanukkah banner cost $4.97.
Hanukkah decor.Talia Lakritz/Insider

The banner featured burlap panels decorated with Jewish stars and menorahs.

Some of the Hanukkah decorations veered into Christmas territory, like ceramic light-up Hanukkah trees and Hanukkah gnomes reminiscent of Santa Claus.

Some of the Hanukkah decorations veered into Christmas territory, like ceramic light-up Hanukkah trees and Hanukkah gnomes reminiscent of Santa Claus.
A blue and white Hanukkah tree.Talia Lakritz/Insider

The light-up Hanukkah tree cost $25, and the gnome retails for $7.97.

Advertisement

Walmart didn't stock dreidels or gelt, but I appreciated its vibrant Hanukkah aisle.

Walmart didn't stock dreidels or gelt, but I appreciated its vibrant Hanukkah aisle.
A blue and silver wreath in Walmart's Hanukkah section.Talia Lakritz/Insider

There was nothing Hanukkah-specific about this blue and silver wreath (somehow, blue and silver have become Hanukkah colors the way red and green are Christmas colors), but it did feel festive.

After comparing the experiences at the stores I visited, I preferred Walmart's quirky, easy-to-locate Hanukkah collection.

After comparing the experiences at the stores I visited, I preferred Walmart's quirky, easy-to-locate Hanukkah collection.
I compared Target's and Walmart's Hanukkah sections.Talia Lakritz/Insider

If you're looking for more traditional basics like dreidels and gelt, Target would be the way to go. But I could envision throwing an amazing Hanukkah party with Walmart's wider selection of Hanukkah gifts and decor.

Advertisement