YouTuber Lohanthony said that he didn't go to conversion therapy and defended 'Christian celibacy' in a new video. Experts say his rhetoric could still be cause for concern.
Advertisement
Rachel E. Greenspan,Kat Tenbarge
Aug 28, 2020, 00:33 IST
Lohanthony attends The 5th Annual Streamy Awards Nomination Celebration at Annenberg Community Beach House on August 12, 2015 in Santa Monica, California.Kevin Winter/Getty Images
YouTuber Anthony Quintal, better known as Lohanthony, has shocked followers with his new commitment to "Christian celibacy" as he turns his previously pro-LGBTQ channel toward Jesus Christ.
Quintal, 21, who came out as gay as a teenager, returned to YouTube to clarify his previous videos and deny suggestions that he participated in or is encouraging conversion therapy.
"I support abandoning consuming lusts, both homosexual and heterosexual alike," Quintal said, but conversion therapy experts told Insider his rhetoric still stigmatizes gay relationships.
"I apologize for the hurt I caused with my videos regarding my celibacy, regarding my sobriety, regarding being saved by Lord Jesus Christ," said Quintal, better known by his username Lohanthony. "I hope you can forgive me if my words offended you in any way."
As a teen, Quintal was a beloved openly gay YouTuber known for his pop culture commentary, liberal politics, and for inspiring young LGBTQ fans worldwide, gaining over 1.3 million subscribers at his peak.
Now, Quintal has surprised those followers with a very public shift in his branding. In one August 21 YouTube video, Quintal said that he would no longer have relationships with men. Quintal had previously come out as gay in a YouTube video that has since been made private on his channel.
"It's no coincidence that through pursuing my same-sex attraction I was also addicted to alcohol, I was also addicted to weed, I was also trying hallucinogenics, I was also addicted to money, I was also addicted to views, I was addicted to attention," Quintal said.
Advertisement
Quintal's rhetoric, which conflated his addiction issues with his gay relationships, concerned LGBTQ advocates. Mathew Shurka, co-founder of the anti-conversion therapy advocacy organization Born Perfect, told Insider at the time that Quintal's language was "dangerous" for young gay people discovering their sexuality.
"It's incredibly dangerous and it's so upsetting," said Shurka, who is himself a survivor of a conversion therapy program. "That scares me, because a lot of teenagers to 20-something-year-olds are definitely watching him."
A post shared by lohanthony (@lohanthony)
In his new video, Quintal said he did not mean to condemn gay relationships. "I support abandoning consuming lusts, both homosexual and heterosexual alike. No person is safe from lusting over whoever we're attracted to, both single or in marriage," he said.
Previously, Matthew Vines, an expert in 'ex-gay' Christian rhetoric, told Insider that Quintal's video echoed a new wave of conservative Christian thought that encourages Christians to pursue celibacy or mixed-orientation marriages instead of same-sex attraction and same-sex partnerships.
Vines, the director of an LGBTQ Christian inclusion non-profit called The Reformation Project, said Quintal associated negative experiences like childhood sexual trauma, drug addiction, and addiction to social media fame with same-sex attraction, a justification for "Christian celibacy" that echoes the rhetoric of conversion therapy.
A post shared by lohanthony (@lohanthony) on Aug 23, 2020 at 1:23pm PDT
One study in 2017 documented the trend of "Christian celibacy," finding that many gay Christian men chose a life of celibacy in lieu of same-sex relationships.
Having watched Quintal's follow-up video, Vines says that while he's "softened his rhetoric," Quintal is still describing that same-sex attraction as a problem, even if he seems to equate same-sex lust with heterosexual lust.
"Many conservative Christians view all same-sex relationships as 'consuming lusts," Vines told Insider. "As a result, they believe that avoiding lust for straight people means getting married, but for gay people, it means lifelong singleness and celibacy."
Vines says that if Quintal believes those in same-sex relationships can honor God in the same way heterosexual relationships can, "he should make that clear."
"Unfortunately, nothing in this new video contradicts his earlier stigmatization of all same-sex relationships," Vines told Insider.
Advertisement
However, after watching Quintal's new video, Shurka told Insider that he's glad the YouTuber has at least rebuked the practice of conversion therapy. "I'm happy to see that Anthony clearly condemns conversion therapy. I think that it is especially important for his younger followers," he said.
Quintal has not responded to Insider's request for comment.
NewsletterSIMPLY PUT - where we join the dots to inform and inspire you. Sign up for a weekly brief collating many news items into one untangled thought delivered straight to your mailbox.