These Maps Show That Android Is For Poor People
This map showing the locations of 280 million individual posts on Twitter shows a depressing divide in America: Tweets coming from Manhattan tend to come from iPhones. Tweets coming from Newark, N.J., tend to come from Android phones.If you live in the New York metro area, you don't need to be told that Manhattan is where the region's rich people live, and the poor live in Newark. Manhattan's median income is $67,000 a year. Newark's is $17,000, according to U.S. Census data.
The map was created by Mapbox, which markets beautiful mapping software. You can use it to zero in on your ZIP code and see how your neighborhood breaks down.Even within Manhattan, the iPhone / Android divide picks out the wealthier neighborhoods from the poorer ones. Here is the split along the border of the Village (think brownstones and chic little designer stores) and Chinatown and the Lower East side (noodle joints and bodegas, plus a large public housing complex):
Here is San Francisco:
Here is an even more dramatic one. Everyone knows that the Miami Beach area of Florida is where the rich go to play. But check out what happens near the airport, where there are a couple of trailer parks:
Cennydd Bowles, a U.K.-based design lead at Twitter, raised the issue recently in a thoughtful article on Medium titled, "Why don't designers take Android seriously?" He wanted to know why app developers don't like working for Android: "It's likely that Android will reach a larger proportion of humanity than any comparable technology, if it hasn't already."
Mike Segar/Reuters'Why don't designers take Android seriously?'
Android has about an 80% market share in some areas of the world. "Android is the dominant platform of the next decade. Why aren't designers paying it more attention?" Bowles asked.
To make his point, he noted that WhatsApp's 450 million users are mostly on Android. WhatsApp helps people save money via bypassing a phone user's data plan in favor of free Wi-Fi. With audiences of that size, it was odd to him that app developers still regarded Android as an also-ran. He got a bunch of responses from his colleagues and readers:The ... replies were mostly variations on the theme that Android users don't pay for apps, they don't have data plans, you can't monetize them easily, and designers are all iPhone users and don't really understand Android users.
A socio-economic split on class lines, in favor of iPhone over Android.Note the recurring theme: Android users are less lucrative than iPhone users, and designers are iPhone users. It's a socio-economic split on class lines, in favor of iPhone over Android.
Mobile traffic data to e-commerce sites bears this out. Every quarter, a mobile market research company called Monetate publishes data on mobile shoppers and how much they spend online. On almost every metric, Apple users come out ahead as spenders. Here's the data for Q4 2013:
- iPad: 87%
- Kindle: 2%
- Android: 11%
Average order value from tablets
- iPad: $155
- Kindle: $123
- Android: $110
- iPhone: 60%
- Android: 39%
- Windows: 1%
- iPhone: $126
- Android: $136
- Windows: $106
Only on phones do Android users spend more, but if you look at the dominant share of iPad as a shopping device and how much iPad users spend - $155 on 87% of visits - it's almost as if Apple users do their shopping on iPad and only use their phones for the loose-change stuff:
That "loose change," unfortunately, is roughly the most that Android users spend, on average.This finding has been repeated - broadly - by IBM, which monitors holiday shopping on mobile devices. From Black Friday through Christmas Day, iOS users spent $93.94 per order, nearly twice that of Android users, who spent just $48.10.
Simon Khalaf, CEO of Flurry, one of the larger mobile advertising platforms, recently told Business Insider the same thing: "We have seen and published reports that an Android user is worth one-quarter of an iOS user, but that is based on virtual goods sales (mainly games). The IBM data seems to suggest that this is almost the same ratio for sales of physical goods (m-commerce)."
The economic split between Apple and Android isn't surprising, given that Apple generally demands $600 to $700 for an iPhone, and rarely tolerates discount pricing of its newest models. The chart above shows how consistent iPhone pricing is over time.
With Android, however, all the talk at the recent Mobile World Conference in Barcelona - a huge mobile industry confab - was about the Chinese Android companies marketing smartphones for just $35.
Kantar Worldpanel ComTech says that the Moto G was particularly popular with men aged 16-24 in "lower income" groups: 83% of buyers were male, and 40% have annual earnings of below £20,000.
What's happening in China?Apple has recently started paying attention to the Chinese market, hoping to sell more phones there. So Chinese consumers may change their tastes. But until recently, Android dominated much of Asia. This chart from Distimo appears to show that sales on Apple vs. Android devices are split evenly, by geography. But ...
There may be signs this is changing.
As the sheer size of the Android audience grows, businesses are paying more attention to it, and some Android users are behaving more like iPhone users. This chart shows that monetization of Android apps by developers is catching up to the iPhone, but Android still has a long way to go:
I do hope, given tech's rhetoric about changing the world and disrupting outdated hierarchies, that we don't really think only those with revenue potential are worth our attention. A designer has a duty to be empathetic; to understand and embrace people not like him/herself. A group owning different devices to the design elite is not a valid reason to neglect their needs.
- The decision not to have a kid is personal — but the social pressure against the choice is all-pervasive
- K'taka budget will focus on welfare of women & their development: CM
- Global consumer spending on apps to reach $270 billion annually by 2025
- Farmers announce series of Mahapanchayats in March
- Huawei aims to make electric cars later this year