It looks like Republicans have shot down the FCC's plan to kill the cable box
Earlier this week, Republicans in Congress urged FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler to avoid looking at any contested policy issues until President-elect Trump, whose administration is expected to be far less open to telecom and cable industry regulation than the current one, takes office.
In a letter sent to Wheeler on Wednesday, Sen. John Thune (R-S.D.) requested the FCC to not direct its resources to "complex, partisan, or otherwise controversial items" that the Trump administration or forthcoming Republican-majority Congress will "have an interest in reviewing."
Representatives Fred Upton (R-Mich.) and Greg Walden (R-Ore.) sent a similar letter (via Ars Technica) on Wednesday, noting how Democrats in Congress made a comparable request of the FCC just before President Obama took office in early 2009.
Later that day, the FCC complied, deleting all of the major items scheduled for its monthly Open Commission Meeting on Thursday. Those items included votes on funding to expand mobile broadband networks, lowering price caps on small businesses reliant on telecom company special access lines, and requiring TV networks to expand the availability of audio descriptions for the blind, among others.
How the FCC wanted to kill the cable box
That leaves Wheeler's plans for cable box reform in serious doubt. Though Wheeler said the FCC will "keep trying" to come to a consensus, Republican Commissioners Ajit Pai and Michael O'Reilly have consistently objected to Wheeler's proposals, and they will soon have the backing of Congress and the White House.
The FCC would not say if its decision to delete objected items at Thursday's meeting will apply to the set-top box proposal as well, merely noting that it will remain "under consideration on circulation."
The Commission first voted to end cable company control over the set-top box market in February. At the time, Wheeler wanted cable and satellite companies to give their programming information to third-party streaming device makers, who would then be able present pay-TV content on their boxes, through their own user interfaces.
The proposal won the approval of President Barack Obama, but did not go over well with the cable industry, which cited concerns over piracy, disrupted licensing deals, and technical challenges. It also threatened the billions of dollars in revenue the industry makes from set-top box fees each year.
After months of objections, Wheeler issued a revised plan in September, which made a number of concessions to industry concerns. Instead of giving pay-TV content to a Roku or Google, cable and satellite companies would only be mandated to make that content available in apps for major streaming platforms, which they would have full control over. The actual look of cable TV wouldn't need to be any different; you just wouldn't be forced to rent a separate box to watch it.
However, even though Wheeler's revision was based on a counterproposal presented by the cable industry earlier in the year - and even though several cable companies have made their content available in apps as it is - the cable industry has objected. This is largely due to a provision that would let the FCC set a universal license, instead of letting pay-TV companies negotiate licensing rates with streaming device makers on a case-by-case basis (thus allowing them to ask for more cash from some than others).
Zach Gibson/Getty Images
Where a Trump FCC goes from here
Now, it appears the cable industry will win out. Though Wheeler is technically allowed to stay on as Chairman through 2018, the Trump administration will be able to name a successor upon assuming the presidency.
Furthermore, a Reuters report earlier this week cited two FCC sources that said the Commission is not expected to vote on the set-top box proposal going forward.
Meanwhile, consumer advocacy groups like Public Knowledge are already urging Trump to follow Wheeler's lead on the issue.
Wheeler said on Thursday that he is "committed to a smooth transition," but that he has not picked a departure date yet. If he were to remain with the FCC beyond January, it would likely be as a Commissioner - something that's at least possible, after a Washington Post report said that leading Senate Democrats want to block the reconfirmation of Rosenworcel, whose term ends at the end of the year.
To that presumed end, Trump has appointed Jeffrey Eisenach, an economist and former telecoms industry consultant, as the head of his transition team's telecoms- and FCC-related policy. Eisenach has been a general proponent of light-touch telecoms regulation in the past, defending controversial practices like zero-rating, and opposing Wheeler's landmark decision to treat the internet as a public utility, which is the basis of the current net neutrality rules that force internet service providers like Comcast and AT&T to treat all content equally.
Speaking about Trump's potential telecoms approach on C-SPAN last month, Eisenach said, "I think, in general, taking his broader views on regulation into account, you would expect him to appoint to the FCC one who would be inclined to take a less regulatory position."
It all strongly suggests that the federal government won't be telling cable companies to change their tack going forward. If the cable box does go away, don't expect the FCC to be the ones pushing it out the door.
- Toyota was right about hybrid cars all along
- The youngest son of Asia's richest man is getting married, and the pre-wedding event features Rihanna, a 9-page dress code, and live animals
- Check out some of the best and most daring looks at Ambani's pre-wedding bash — from Rihanna to Mark Zuckerberg
- Bengaluru cafe blast: Karnataka CM Siddaramaiah to chair meeting with top police officials today
- India retains full policy space for benefit of farmers, fishermen at WTO: Goyal
- Sensex, Nifty settle at new closing high levels in first part of special live trading session
- Passive Income Streams
- Gas stoves create more nanoparticle pollution than a busy street with diesel and gas cars, study finds