Biden landed punches in the first debate, but you'd barely notice because Trump doesn't fight fair

Biden landed punches in the first debate, but you'd barely notice because Trump doesn't fight fair
U.S. President Donald Trump and former Vice President and Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden speak during the first presidential debate at the Health Education Campus of Case Western Reserve University on September 29, 2020 in Cleveland, Ohio.Morry Gash-Pool/Getty Images
  • Joe Biden has talked about wishing he could have beaten President Donald Trump behind the high-school gym. But on Tuesday evening he seemed surprised to be in the same room with an out-of-control bully.
  • Trump heckled, lied, and steamrolled Biden every time the former vice president tried to speak.
  • Biden got in some good shots, like calling the president "a liar," "a racist," and "the worst president we've ever had."
  • Maybe Biden’s strategy of punching back, but not too hard, will work in the end. But it's a risky bet, because Trump will never fight fair, and these are the last debates of his life.
  • This is an opinion column. The thoughts expressed are those of the author.

The first presidential debate of the 2020 general election was so mortifyingly incoherent and stupid that the CNN anchor Wolf Blitzer said he wouldn't be surprised if turned out to be the last one, too.

It was a clash of grumpy old white men, and for all their mutual viciousness their styles were markedly different.

On the one hand you had the Democratic nominee, Joe Biden, doing his typical "crass but tough old guy" schtick. Opposite him was President Donald Trump, who was an internet troll in the flesh. And he was unleashed on a presidential debate stage.

Rules are pointless when dealing with Trump

Back in the primary, Biden was the old un-politically-correct white guy in the most diverse group of Democratic contenders ever. He was the embodiment of a dated establishment and archaic social mores when much of the rest of the field was trying to out-woke one another.

And he won the nomination, handily.


For the better part of the past two years, the former vice president has played up his Rust Belt working-class roots, his close relationships with the Black communities of Delaware, and his position as Barack Obama's "brother from another mother."

The image was simple. Uncle Joe is the scrappy authentic kid from Scranton. He's mad as hell and not afraid to get his knuckles dirty.

He has even channeled his rough-around-the-edges Irish Catholic roots and has said he would have liked to have beaten up President Donald Trump behind the gym.

But rather than come out swinging in his first debate as the Democratic nominee, he acted surprised to be in a room with a bully who doesn't respect the rules.

Trump relentlessly interrupted Biden every time the former vice president opened his mouth. (Trump interrupted the moderator, Chris Wallace of Fox News, almost as often.) And he got his red-meat-for-the-MAGA-base zingers in.


Early on, Trump knocked Biden's concentration off course after screaming "Bernie Sanders" and "socialized medicine" as Biden was talking about healthcare.

The president, a Wharton School of Business graduate and supposed candidate of the "regular guy" populist right, insulted Biden for attending a state school and name dropped antifa at every opportunity.

Invoking the memory of his late son, Beau, an Army veteran who died of brain cancer in 2015, Biden called out Trump over reports the president had insulted US military dead as "suckers."

The president, quick-witted and without a conscience, retorted, "I don't know Beau." Then he laid into Biden's son Hunter.

Trump got viciously personal, impugning Hunter Biden for his struggle with drug addiction and throwing out innuendos about unproven accusations of foreign payoffs.


Trump even called Biden "number two," in an apparent reference to poop.

That's not to say Biden didn't fight back.

He called Trump a liar and a racist. And if this weren't 2020, it'd be pretty big news that a former vice president called a sitting president those words on a debate stage.

Biden threw in the occasional tough-guy cliché, as when he told Trump, "You picked the wrong guy on the wrong night at the wrong time." He told Wallace it was "hard to get a word in with this clown — excuse me, this person," referring to Trump. Biden also called Trump "unpresidential" and asked, "Would you shut up, man?"

But Biden lacked Trump's conviction when throwing mud, for better or worse. His best line, "You're the worst president that America has ever had," was delivered almost as a muttered sigh.


Biden won the Democratic nomination as the same politician he's always been: the guy who has a lot of friends because he never fights too dirty. His campaign is built on a "return to normalcy," that time when grotesque behavior like Trump's would have turned off the socially conservative voters who became Trump's base.

So it makes sense that Biden wouldn't disrespect the agreed-upon rules of the debate. It's also why he didn't buzz around in Trump's ear with non sequiturs every time he tried to speak, as the president did to him.

If this embarrassing, chaotic, substantively void debate is any indication, for the next debates Trump will do what he always does. He'll lie, steamroll, and make no sense. But he'll look confident doing it.

Maybe Biden's strategy of punching back, but not too hard, will work in the end. Debates usually don't matter all that much, most are quickly forgotten. His tough but civil approach could be the right balance to make it through a few news cycles.

Biden fought rough without coming off as Trump did, which was as a flailing maniac. The strategy worked well enough Tuesday night, even if it did look as if Biden was growing weary at the constant taunting.


It's still a risky strategy for Biden in the next two debates, because Trump will never fight fair, and these are the last debates of his life.