Link Copied

After Trying $2 Billion Grocery Startup Instacart, I'd Rather Just Go To The Store

To get started, first enter your zip code to see if Instacart delivers in your area. The entry page boasts that it will deliver your groceries in an hour.

To get started, first enter your zip code to see if Instacart delivers in your area. The entry page boasts that it will deliver your groceries in an hour.
Share Slide

You then get to choose the grocery store you want to order from.

You then get to choose the grocery store you want to order from.
Share Slide

After I chose Fairway as my store, the app showed me what food items I could buy from there.

After I chose Fairway as my store, the app showed me what food items I could buy from there.
Share Slide

Once I chose everything, it showed my total cost and estimated delivery time. Delivery was free because it was my first order, but it usually costs $7.99 for orders under $35 and $3.99 for orders over $35.

Once I chose everything, it showed my total cost and estimated delivery time. Delivery was free because it was my first order, but it usually costs $7.99 for orders under $35 and $3.99 for orders over $35.
Share Slide

It also asked me if the Instacart shopper could substitute a different kind of pasta in case the one I had chosen was out of stock. Sometimes the shopper will call the customer to ask what they'd like to replace out-of-stock items with. I didn't get a call, but I've heard other people complain about shoppers calling them multiple times to ask about alternative items.

It also asked me if the Instacart shopper could substitute a different kind of pasta in case the one I had chosen was out of stock. Sometimes the shopper will call the customer to ask what they'd like to replace out-of-stock items with. I didn't get a call, but I've heard other people complain about shoppers calling them multiple times to ask about alternative items.
Share Slide

Same-day delivery is one of the biggest perks Instacart promises. When I ordered my groceries, though, there wasn't a delivery slot available until noon the next day. It wasn't exactly what I was expecting. Plus, I was going to be at work at that time, so having groceries delivered then wouldn't work.

Same-day delivery is one of the biggest perks Instacart promises. When I ordered my groceries, though, there wasn't a delivery slot available until noon the next day. It wasn't exactly what I was expecting. Plus, I was going to be at work at that time, so having groceries delivered then wouldn't work.
Share Slide

I gave up and tried to order again two days later. My order still couldn't come that day — it was New Year's Day, a big holiday — but they offered me a delivery slot for the following day.

I gave up and tried to order again two days later. My order still couldn't come that day — it was New Year's Day, a big holiday — but they offered me a delivery slot for the following day.
Share Slide

My groceries arrived at about 3:15 p.m. the next day, which was early in the delivery slot. They came in a canvas bag that touted one-hour grocery delivery. Hmmph.

My groceries arrived at about 3:15 p.m. the next day, which was early in the delivery slot. They came in a canvas bag that touted one-hour grocery delivery. Hmmph.
Share Slide

The shopper who delivered my bag was friendly, but she left before I could really check out the contents. I only ordered a few basic things and soon realized that they had left out the pasta I ordered, which I had planned to eat for dinner that night.

The shopper who delivered my bag was friendly, but she left before I could really check out the contents. I only ordered a few basic things and soon realized that they had left out the pasta I ordered, which I had planned to eat for dinner that night.
Share Slide

I emailed customer service to see if I could either have my item replaced or get a refund. I was slightly annoyed that I would still have to go out to buy pasta for dinner. To their credit, customer service responded within minutes and said I would get a refund.

I emailed customer service to see if I could either have my item replaced or get a refund. I was slightly annoyed that I would still have to go out to buy pasta for dinner. To their credit, customer service responded within minutes and said I would get a refund.
Share Slide

Instacart sounds great in theory, and it only cost me $20, but it seems like they still have some kinks to figure out. People with exceptionally busy schedules may find it's worth paying a small price to have their groceries come to them, even if the shoppers mix some things up in the process. Personally, I think I'll stick to regular grocery shopping in the meantime.

Instacart sounds great in theory, and it only cost me $20, but it seems like they still have some kinks to figure out. People with exceptionally busy schedules may find it's worth paying a small price to have their groceries come to them, even if the shoppers mix some things up in the process. Personally, I think I'll stick to regular grocery shopping in the meantime.
Share Slide
More from our Partners