Gold offers better returns than real estate even though that's where the average Indian household chooses to keep most of its wealthBCCL
The amount of debt that Indians have taken on has nearly doubled over the past five years.
Most of the borrowing has been done in the name of buying up more real estate even though it offers the worst returns.
Gold offers the highest returns yet accounts for only 11% of a household’s total wealth and they borrow against it.
Advertisement
The average Indian household has been taking on more debt for nearly half a decade now. In fact, debt has nearly doubled with loans becoming cheaper to pick up over the past five years.
This includes everything from home loans to vehicle loans — and even gold loans, where gold is given up as collateral in exchange for money.
This year alone, loans against gold have increased sharply even as banks are left craving for borrowers.
Company
Growth in gold loans
Muthoot Finance
32%
Manappuram Finance
33.40%
Overall bank credit growth
5.50%
*Data as of July-end except for Manappuram, which is as of June-end
Household debt is rising but where is the money going? Indians are famous for their love of gold but the biggest chunk of their investment is still real estate.
Advertisement
While Indians still have a lot more gold than the average household in peer economies, their investments in real estate also race ahead — funded mostly by home loans.
India outpaces China, Thailand and other countries around the world both in buying gold and property. But, the return of real estate has not even managed to beat the average inflation rate of the last five years. Whereas gold has given better returns than any other asset.
Returns on various asset classes
(% of returns from 2008 till...)
Till 2014
Till 2016
Till 2019
Real estate
4.9%
4.7%
4.3%
Gold
11.7%
9.5%
10%
Equity
6.8%
5.1%
7.2%
Debt
7.8%
7.7%
7.6%
Home loans may be cheap, but they’re harder to pay off Owning property remains an aspiration for the average household in a developing economy like India.
However, to buy more real estate, one needs a home loan. And, right now, home loan interest rates are at an all-time low. It makes them attractive but hardly adds to the household net worth.
Advertisement
While cheap loans have, to some extent, supported the demand for real estate, they have also kept property prices from falling. So much so that, despite the struggles of the property developers in the last few years, homes have only become less affordable.
This affordability — measured by the amount of EMI compared to the monthly income of a household — would have only gotten worse in 2020 as the pandemic took away jobs and slashed salaries.
NewsletterSIMPLY PUT - where we join the dots to inform and inspire you. Sign up for a weekly brief collating many news items into one untangled thought delivered straight to your mailbox.