scorecardCalifornia students say they're 'deeply disappointed' after voters cast ballots against affirmative action
  1. Home
  2. Politics
  3. world
  4. news
  5. California students say they're 'deeply disappointed' after voters cast ballots against affirmative action

California students say they're 'deeply disappointed' after voters cast ballots against affirmative action

Inyoung Choi   

California students say they're 'deeply disappointed' after voters cast ballots against affirmative action
PoliticsPolitics4 min read
Pictured above is the campus of UCLA. The Office of the President of the University of California, which includes UCLA, said in a statement that it was "disappointed" that the proposition was rejected.    Damian Dovarganes/AP
  • California voted to reject Proposition 16, which called to allow affirmative action in public employers and education institutions.
  • Proponents of affirmative action have advocated for the need to expand equal opportunity.
  • Student leaders from the University of California told Business Insider why they were "deeply disappointed" to see the rejection of Proposition 16 in California, a state well-known for its progressive values.

California voted to reject a proposition to bring back affirmative action with 56% in opposition as of Wednesday, according to the AP.

Proposition 16 would have allowed public employers and education institutions to "consider race, sex, color, ethnicity, or national origin in order to address diversity," and hence uphold affirmative action in admissions and hiring. Affirmative action, as Business Insider's Erin Fuchs previously reported, originated in the 1960s when former President John F. Kennedy used the term to promote diversity and equality in hiring processes in government contractors.

If this proposition was passed, it would have effectively repealed the 1996 Proposition 209, which terminated affirmative action in public education and employment. While the majority of states do not ban affirmative action, nine states including California, Florida, Michigan, and most recently Idaho have adopted a ban.

"Proposition 16 would have helped reverse the detrimental and far-reaching initiative that banned the consideration of race, ethnicity and gender in admissions across public higher education, and other arenas, almost a quarter-century ago," a statement released Wednesday by the University of California Office of the President said, expressing that the university was "disappointed" by the rejection of the proposition.

Proponents of Proposition 16 say this change would have expanded equal opportunity. Banning affirmative action has been cited to exacerbate gaps in educational opportunities for students from historically underrepresented communities. A study published by the University of Washington Professor of Public Policy and Governance Mark Long and Brookings Institute research analyst Nicole A. Bateman found that Black, Hispanic, and Native American students showed a significant gap in enrollment in the aftermath of the ban on affirmative action, based on data from 19 public universities in states which adopted a ban.

In the statement, University of California President Michael V. Drake said the school "remains steadfast in its commitment to attract and support a student body that reflects California's dynamism and diversity, despite this setback."

Proposition 16 supporters rally during early voting in California
A Proposition 16 rally at Dorsey High School in Los Angeles urges the community to vote yes on the proposition.      Allison Zaucha for The Washington Post via Getty Images

Aidan Arasingham, a senior studying global studies at UCLA and president of the UC Student Association told Business Insider that he was "deeply disappointed" to see the rejection of Proposition 16.

"Unfortunately we didn't live up to our values as a state and our ideals of equity and justice by not passing this proposition," he said. "It would have been a game-changer in increasing diversity and representation at UC."

The UC Student Association, consisting of student representatives across UC campuses, released a statement Wednesday expressing their disappointment to see the failure of the proposition.

"The fight for affirmative action at UC has spanned generations, and we stand on the shoulders of the students on the front lines of this battle since the 1960s," the statement said.

Jose Lopez, a fourth-year student at UC Merced studying political science and sociology and a member of the UC Student Association, said he is the first in his family to attend college and a child of first-generation immigrants from El Salvador. UC Merced's student body is only 8.9% white, but as of 2018, over half of its instructional faculty was white. Lopez said he only had one professor in his four years who he truly personally connected with — a professor who had been a first-generation student as well.

"I feel like throughout my academic career that something that I lacked, I wasn't able to personally connect with a professor on campus, because they didn't represent something that I look like," he told Business Insider.

Lopez said he believed if proposition 16 had been passed, it would have expanded diversity in faculty.

Some students have expressed opposition to the Proposition. A junior at UC Berkeley penned an op-ed in the campus newspaper this past summer penned an op-ed arguing that "the color of a person's skin by itself does not, and should not, affect their academic abilities in any way."

The opposition to the proposition has sounded off an alarm for these students in California, which has voted for Democrats in the presidential election since 1992 and is well-known for its progressive values.

Lopez, who is from Los Angeles, said that he did not believe the proposition would be "be a controversial thing, especially since we're in California."

Alia Sky Reynolds, a fourth-year student at UC Santa Barbara double-majoring in global studies and philosophy and a member of the UC Student Association, told Business Insider the rejection of Proposition 16 showed that while "a lot of times people see California as an extremely progressive state," that was not necessarily the case.

"[If] we just look at the presidential race, it might seem that way, but if we look at the propositions that passed or didn't pass this year, it's clear that we are not necessarily as progressive as we claim to be," she said. She explained the rejection of this proposition showed "we don't recognize [ways] the racism and sexism that still exists in California and what needs to be done to correct that."