A federal agency says it won't ban gas stoves in the US after the debate about how to handle the appliances' health risks boils over
- A federal safety agency on Wednesday clarified that it won't ban gas stoves in the US.
- Gas stoves release carbon monoxide and nitrogen dioxide that boost the risk of respiratory damage.
Disagreements over how to deal with the health risks of gas stoves boiled over in Washington on Wednesday and led a federal safety agency to announce it had no plans to ban the appliances.
Richard Trumka Jr., a commissioner of the Consumer Product Safety Commission, told Bloomberg on Monday that a gas stove ban was on the table.
The comments set off a firestorm among Republican politicians and Senator Joe Manchin, a Democrat from West Virginia, who tweeted that the federal government has no business telling families how to cook their dinner.
On Wednesday, the CPSC clarified that it is not looking to ban gas stoves but is considering other ways to reduce the hazards. President Joe Biden doesn't support a ban, either, said White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre.
Burning gas releases pollutants like carbon monoxide, nitrogen dioxide, and formaldehyde, which increase the risk of respiratory damage. A recent study found that cooking on a gas stove carries similar risks for childhood asthma as secondhand smoke.
The study, published in the peer-reviewed International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, attributed 12.7% of childhood asthma cases in the US to air pollutants from gas stoves.
"This is preventable," Brady Seals, a manager at the think tank RMI's Carbon-Free Buildings program and coauthor of the study, told Insider. "We hope this study can raise awareness and give policymakers the data they need to do something about this issue."
The results are based on an analysis of previous research that estimated children living in homes with gas stoves were 34% more at risk of developing asthma. That risk factor, combined with data from 2019 showing that more than one-third of US households primarily cooked with gas, indicated that about 650,000 kids likely had asthma because of gas stoves, the study found.
Seals, whose employer advocates for electrifying buildings, said there were decades' worth of studies on the correlation between gas stoves and childhood asthma but it's been siloed or shelved away. Now, some climate advocates are putting the pieces together to bolster the case for phasing out fossil fuels in buildings, which account for about 13% of US greenhouse-gas emissions, according to the Environmental Protection Agency.
"This adage of, 'If it's bad for the climate, it's probably bad for your health,' led us to start researching this topic about three years ago," Seals said.
RMI and Rewiring America, another electrification group that helped author the study, advocate for building codes that ban gas hookups in new construction. Dozens of cities, primarily in California, have had that policy since 2019.
The momentum was met with an opposition campaign by the gas industry and their allies in state legislatures. At least 20 mostly red states have enacted laws that prohibit local governments from restricting fossil fuels in buildings.
The American Gas Association, a trade group representing the natural gas industry, in a statement criticized the methodology underlying the study on childhood asthma, in part because researchers used estimated health risks and didn't conduct their own measurements on appliance usage, emissions, or exposures.
The gas industry also often points out that proper ventilation significantly reduces the concentration of pollutants from gas stoves.
While that's true, Seals said many states and cities didn't require gas stoves to be vented to the outdoors — a distinction from appliances like furnaces and water heaters. Exhaust hoods and fans aren't guaranteed to clean the air, and people might not always use them.
Seals added that federal agencies should step up oversight. The Environmental Protection Agency doesn't regulate indoor air quality, but it could issue nonbinding guidance that helps influence state and local officials who update building codes.
CPSC, for its part, will open a public comment period later this winter on the hazards from the appliance to help guide the agency's next steps, Trumka said.
Last month, Democrats in Congress asked the agency to take steps to protect people from the hazards.
An earlier version of this story appeared on January 7, 2023.
- Gen Z faces more pressure at work than previous generations because technology has eliminated work-life boundaries, a psychology professor says
- All 81 movies based on Marvel comics, ranked according to critics
- EY and Deloitte are scrutinizing staff workloads and quietly letting some workers go, report says
- EPFO adds a net 15.62 lakh members in Dec; 8.41 lakh new subscribers join workforce
- Zee Entertainment reaches out to Sony to revive terminated merger
- India's AI market to touch $17-billion by 2027: Nasscom-BCG report
- Worried about 'forever chemicals' in your water? Try electron-beaming it!
- Wetlands in the icy Arctic have begun releasing 9% more planet-warming methane in the past two decades: study