Here's when you should start cooking every dish for Thanksgiving

Madeline DiamondNov 18, 2020, 02:52 IST

Timing all of your Thanksgiving dishes isn't difficult as long as you have a plan.April Walloga

Cooking an entire Thanksgiving meal can be stressful, even if it's just for a few people.
Between turkey, mashed potatoes, stuffing, and dessert, it can be overwhelming to determine an efficient cooking schedule.
Insider worked with Dan Holzman, chef and co-owner of The Meatball Shop, to come up with a Thanksgiving timeline that will help you figure out when to start cooking every dish.

When it comes to making a Thanksgiving dinner, it can be stressful, even if you're only cooking for a few people this year. With a seemingly endless menu of classic side dishes, pies, and of course, a turkey, timing everything right is no easy feat. Plus, you want to leave time to enjoy yourself.

To help relieve a bit of stress, Insider spoke with Dan Holzman, chef and co-owner of The Meatball Shop in New York City, about the best timeline for your Thanksgiving menu.

"If you are the type of person that loves to get stuff out of the way, there are a bunch of dishes and prep work that you can do ahead of time," Holzman said. "But from an efficiency perspective, there's a lot of down time in between roasting a turkey or even making mashed potatoes."

Here's what you should be prepping beforehand:

Up to one week before:

Make and refrigerate cranberry sauce.
Prepare turkey or vegetable stock (if you are using homemade).

The day before:

Bake all desserts, including pies.
For stuffing, prepare dried bread one to two days in advance.

With proper planning, however, it's possible to make a full dinner primarily the day of. It's also possible to avoid most of the hassle and stress typically associated with the food-centric holiday.

Keep reading for our timeline of when you should cook every dish for Thanksgiving dinner.

Homemade cranberry sauce can be prepared up to a week in advance.

Homemade cranberry sauce. Brent Hofacker/Shutterstock

When you should start cooking: About a week before Thanksgiving.

Cranberry sauce will last up to a week and a half in the refrigerator, so it's the perfect dish to prepare in advance.

Plus, making cranberry sauce requires giving it several hours to cool down to achieve the right texture, as "the thickening process happens when [cranberry sauce] cools," according to Holzman.

When you should start cooking: About a week before Thanksgiving.

Cranberry sauce will last up to a week and a half in the refrigerator, so it's the perfect dish to prepare in advance.

Plus, making cranberry sauce requires giving it several hours to cool down to achieve the right texture, as the thickening process happens when [cranberry sauce] cools, according to Holzman.

Get the hassle of dessert out of the way by baking a couple of pies the night before.

Pumpkin pie. Crystal Cox/Business Insider

When you should start cooking: The day before Thanksgiving.

Pies may be the last dish that you'll eat on Thanksgiving, but they can be one of the first menu items that you prepare. Baking pies the night before Thanksgiving is an easy way to get ahead and avoid stress on Thanksgiving day.

"The oven space on Thanksgiving is the number one commodity," Holzman said.

Since pies require precious oven space and very specific temperatures, it's best to prepare desserts ahead of time.

When you should start cooking: The day before Thanksgiving.

The oven space on Thanksgiving is the number one commodity, Holzman said.

Since pies require precious oven space and very specific temperatures, it's best to prepare desserts ahead of time.

Turkey is far less intimidating than it seems. Simply season it the night before and then pop it in the oven Thanksgiving morning.

Turkey, the main event. Shutterstock

When you should start cooking: Season the turkey the night before, and start cooking it Thanksgiving morning.

While it's best to actually cook your turkey on Thanksgiving day, Holzman recommends seasoning your turkey the night before. Since it's the main event, the turkey should be the first dish you start cooking in the morning.

"The resting process is an absolutely imperative part of the cooking process," Holzman said. Many people overcook their turkeys in the oven and overlook letting them rest, rendering the final product dry and rubbery.

By taking your turkey out of the oven before it is fully cooked, you'll allow the heat to redistribute, allowing heat from the outside to seep in, leaving you with a perfectly cooked, juicy turkey, Holzman explained.

To finish off the process, Holzman suggests carving the turkey, and then broiling it in the oven to complete cooking and crisp the skin.

When you should start cooking: Season the turkey the night before, and start cooking it Thanksgiving morning.

The resting process is an absolutely imperative part of the cooking process, Holzman said. Many people overcook their turkeys in the oven and overlook letting them rest, rendering the final product dry and rubbery.

To finish off the process, Holzman suggests carving the turkey, and then broiling it in the oven to complete cooking and crisp the skin.

After putting the turkey in the oven, start focusing on the gravy.

Turkey gravy. Darasp Kran/Shutterstock

When you should start cooking: The same time you start cooking your turkey.

Roasting bones and vegetables that you'll be using for gravy early on Thanksgiving day is a good way to get ahead of the game.

When you should start cooking: The same time you start cooking your turkey.

Roasting bones and vegetables that you'll be using for gravy early on Thanksgiving day is a good way to get ahead of the game.

Prep the bread for the stuffing the night before, then combine all the ingredients on Thanksgiving day.

Traditional stuffing. Sarah Schmalbruch/Insider

When you should start cooking: Prepare bread the night before, start cooking midday.

Based on whether you prefer making stuffing with fresh or dried bread, or even croutons, there are steps you can take days before Thanksgiving to prepare this dish.

"Drying croutons overnight or over the course of two days is easier than drying them in the oven at the last minute," Holzman said.

When you should start cooking: Prepare bread the night before, start cooking midday.

Based on whether you prefer making stuffing with fresh or dried bread, or even croutons, there are steps you can take days before Thanksgiving to prepare this dish.

Drying croutons overnight or over the course of two days is easier than drying them in the oven at the last minute, Holzman said.

If you have some downtime, start chopping up vegetables for a salad.

Apple walnut salad. Shutterstock

When you should start cooking: While your turkey and stuffing are in the oven.

Chopping and assembling salad is a great way to use downtime while other dishes are in the oven. When dinnertime arrives, all you'll have to do is throw together the ingredients and add dressing.

When you should start cooking: While your turkey and stuffing are in the oven.

Chopping and assembling salad is a great way to use downtime while other dishes are in the oven. When dinnertime arrives, all you'll have to do is throw together the ingredients and add dressing.

Side dishes taste the best fresh out of the oven, so don't start on them until Thursday afternoon.

Green bean casserole. Matthew Mead / AP

When you should start cooking: In the afternoon, while other dishes are in the oven.

Various side dishes, such as green bean casserole, are best when served fresh. After salads have been prepped and other dishes are in the oven, you can get started on more of your family's favorite side dishes.

Green bean casserole takes about an hour to make, including prep and cook time, so it's best when made no more than a few hours before dinnertime.

When you should start cooking: In the afternoon, while other dishes are in the oven.

Green bean casserole takes about an hour to make, including prep and cook time, so it's best when made no more than a few hours before dinnertime.

Sweet potato casserole is another easy side dish that can be prepared in the afternoon.

Sweet potato casserole. Shutterstock/vm2002

When you should start cooking: In the afternoon, while other dishes are in the oven.

Sweet potato casserole is another dish that takes about an hour to make, so it can be prepared closer to dinnertime.

When you should start cooking: In the afternoon, while other dishes are in the oven.

Sweet potato casserole is another dish that takes about an hour to make, so it can be prepared closer to dinnertime.

While the oven is hot, pop in the brussel sprouts and other hearty vegetables an hour or two before dinner.

Roasted brussel sprouts. Brent Hofacker / Shutterstock

When you should start cooking: A couple hours before dinnertime.

Once more complicated and prep-heavy dishes are in the oven, you can start roasting vegetables like green beans or brussels sprouts, neither of which should take very long.

When you should start cooking: A couple hours before dinnertime.

Once more complicated and prep-heavy dishes are in the oven, you can start roasting vegetables like green beans or brussels sprouts, neither of which should take very long.

You can make the mashed potatoes a few hours before dinner, and then keep them warm on the stovetop.

A bowl of homemade mashed potatoes. Paul Howritz/ Shutterstock

When you should start cooking: A couple hours before dinnertime.

"Mashed potatoes are best served when they're hot and just made," Holzman said. To keep them hot until dinner is served, put them in a dish on a low flame on the stove or on low heat in the oven.

When you should start cooking: A couple hours before dinnertime.

Mashed potatoes are best served when they're hot and just made, Holzman said. To keep them hot until dinner is served, put them in a dish on a low flame on the stove or on low heat in the oven.

Mapping out a timeline is a great way to ensure your Thanksgiving is stress-free. Plus, if you do all the cooking, you can ask others to do all the dishes.

A complete Thanksgiving dinner. Rawpixel.com / Shutterstock

I tested Kim Kardashian and Kylie Jenner's McDonald's orders but one seemed too wasteful to really enjoy

Cookies on the Business Insider India website

Here's when you should start cooking every dish for Thanksgiving

Homemade cranberry sauce can be prepared up to a week in advance.

Get the hassle of dessert out of the way by baking a couple of pies the night before.

Turkey is far less intimidating than it seems. Simply season it the night before and then pop it in the oven Thanksgiving morning.

After putting the turkey in the oven, start focusing on the gravy.

Prep the bread for the stuffing the night before, then combine all the ingredients on Thanksgiving day.

If you have some downtime, start chopping up vegetables for a salad.

Side dishes taste the best fresh out of the oven, so don't start on them until Thursday afternoon.

Sweet potato casserole is another easy side dish that can be prepared in the afternoon.

While the oven is hot, pop in the brussel sprouts and other hearty vegetables an hour or two before dinner.

You can make the mashed potatoes a few hours before dinner, and then keep them warm on the stovetop.

Mapping out a timeline is a great way to ensure your Thanksgiving is stress-free. Plus, if you do all the cooking, you can ask others to do all the dishes.