I got the same breakfast at Tim Hortons in Canada and Dunkin' in the US to see how they stack up

Sophie-Claire HoellerJun 30, 2020, 02:07 IST

Insider

Canada's Tim Hortons is often compared to Dunkin'.
To see how the two compare, I tried the same breakfast items at both during a trip in January: a hot black coffee, an iced coffee with milk, an English muffin breakfast sandwich, and hash browns.
I preferred the food at Tim Hortons, though I found the coffee was similar at both.
I found breakfast at Tim Hortons was cheaper than Dunkin'.

If America runs on Dunkin', Canada runs on Tim Hortons.

Much like Dunkin', Tim Hortons is a casual, counter-service spot for coffee, breakfast sandwiches, and pastries that can be found on almost every corner in Canada — with almost 5,000 locations, it's Canada's largest restaurant chain and claims to serve almost eight of every 10 cups of coffee sold in the country.

On a trip to Quebec City back in January, I had to see for myself why Timmy's (as it's affectionately called by Canadians) is so synonymous with Canada — as well as how it stacks up to its US counterpart.

In terms of décor, I found Tim Hortons and Dunkin' to be incredibly similar.

A Tim Hortons in Quebec City, Canada. Sophie-Claire Hoeller/Insider

Both are counter-service spots, and have a primarily beige and orange color scheme with lots of ads on the walls. Neither particularly screams "stay a while," in my opinion.

Both are counter-service spots, and have a primarily beige and orange color scheme with lots of ads on the walls. Neither particularly screams stay a while, in my opinion.

I ordered an iced coffee with milk, black hot coffee, English muffin breakfast sandwich, and hash brown at each.

I ordered a hot black coffee, an English muffin egg, cheese and ham/bacon sandwich, and hash browns. Sophie-Claire Hoeller/Insider

At Tim Hortons, the hot coffee, breakfast sandwich, and hash brown came as a combo deal, and cost $4.50 ($5.99 CAD).

At the Dunkin' location I visited in New York City, I saw no such deal on the menu and wasn't made aware of one when ordering, so I paid $7.98 for those three items. The hash brown was $1.30, the small hot coffee $2.29, and the sandwich $4.39.

The iced coffee at Tim Hortons was $1.27 ($1.69 CAD). At the Dunkin' I visited, it cost $2.99. It's worth noting that fast-food prices can vary depending on your location, so they may be different in your area.

At Tim Hortons, the hot coffee, breakfast sandwich, and hash brown came as a combo deal, and cost $4.50 ($5.99 CAD).

Tim Hortons' iced coffee was absolutely delicious, but not at all what I expected. It was incredibly sweet and tasted more like a Frappuccino than a regular iced coffee.

The iced coffee at Tim Hortons was very sweet. Sophie-Claire Hoeller/Insider

No one asked me what kind of milk or sweetener I wanted: I assumed I would add those in myself, but it came pre-mixed.

The iced coffee at Timmy's was so sweet and rich that I wondered whether it had actual ice cream in it, like iced coffees in Europe (I was in French Canada after all). But I suspect they just put in cream and sugar, which I'm not used to since I tend to drink my coffee with only a splash of whole milk.

Tim Hortons' iced coffee was absolutely delicious, but not at all what I expected. It was incredibly sweet and tasted more like a Frappuccino than a regular iced coffee.

No one asked me what kind of milk or sweetener I wanted: I assumed I would add those in myself, but it came pre-mixed.

The hot coffee at Tim Hortons was super hot when it came out. Once it cooled, it was easy to drink: not too strong, smooth, maybe a touch watery. A solid cup, but nothing to write home about.

The coffee came out piping hot. Sophie-Claire Hoeller/Insider

While the coffee was a little watery for my taste, it also lacked the acidity and slightly burnt flavor that I find other fast-food coffee often has — and which I don't like. It was a non-offensive simple cup of coffee that I was easily able to drink black, even though I usually prefer to add milk.

The hot coffee at Tim Hortons was super hot when it came out. Once it cooled, it was easy to drink: not too strong, smooth, maybe a touch watery. A solid cup, but nothing to write home about.

The hash brown was good: crispy on the outside, and soft on the inside.

The hash brown was nice and crispy. Sophie-Claire Hoeller/Insider

My only quibble is that I would have liked it to have a little more salt. While I usually find the sodium content in fast-food is through the roof, this hash brown could have used a touch more seasoning, in my opinion.

The English muffin with egg, cheese, and bacon did not have a lot of meat, unfortunately, but it was still good on the whole.

The muffin was toasted perfectly. Sophie-Claire Hoeller/Insider

This was a solid breakfast sandwich — the cheese was thick and gooey, the bread toasted perfectly, and the egg soft and fluffy — though I would have preferred a little more bacon, and the lone strip that was included in my meal could have been crispier.

The iced coffee at Dunkin' was a lot more like the iced coffee I am used to: slightly bitter, but unobtrusive enough to be easy to drink.

I ordered my iced coffee with a splash of whole milk. Sophie-Claire Hoeller/Insider

Unlike at Tim Hortons, I was asked whether I wanted cream and sugar, which I declined in lieu of a splash of whole milk.

I found the regular coffee at Dunkin' was very similar to that at Tim Hortons. It was mild, smooth, and unremarkable — but in a good way.

The coffee was mild enough for me to drink without milk. Sophie-Claire Hoeller/Insider

It was also unobtrusive and watery enough for me to be able to drink black, and didn't have any hint of the acidity or bitterness often found in fast-food coffee.

Instead of the single hash brown I was expecting, my Dunkin' order came with six little ones. While less crispy than the hash brown at Tim Hortons, these were better seasoned, in my opinion.

At Dunkin', you get six mini hash browns. Sophie-Claire Hoeller/Insider

While they were a little softer than I would have liked, they were seasoned much better, and had a herby taste I couldn't place until I looked up the ingredients later: garlic powder and dehydrated parsley.

Instead of the single hash brown I was expecting, my Dunkin' order came with six little ones. While less crispy than the hash brown at Tim Hortons, these were better seasoned, in my opinion.

I got a ham, egg, and cheese English muffin breakfast sandwich at Dunkin', as the fast-food chain doesn't have a bacon version on its menu. While the egg was really good, the bread was way too squishy for my liking.

There was a generous portion of ham, though the cheese looked dubious to me. Sophie-Claire Hoeller/Insider

The muffin was way too flappy and soggy for me. While the ham was good — and there was a generous portion — I personally prefer bacon.

The egg, however, was delicious. It was fluffy and light, and quite thick. While Tim Hortons' egg was more like scrambled eggs in disc form, this one was a fried egg in disc form.

The cheese didn't taste like much to me, however; it had a pale orange color and the consistency of spray cheese, in my opinion. Tim Hortons' cheese looked and tasted more like real cheese to me.

I got a ham, egg, and cheese English muffin breakfast sandwich at Dunkin', as the fast-food chain doesn't have a bacon version on its menu. While the egg was really good, the bread was way too squishy for my liking.

The muffin was way too flappy and soggy for me. While the ham was good — and there was a generous portion — I personally prefer bacon.

The egg, however, was delicious. It was fluffy and light, and quite thick. While Tim Hortons' egg was more like scrambled eggs in disc form, this one was a fried egg in disc form.

The cheese didn't taste like much to me, however; it had a pale orange color and the consistency of spray cheese, in my opinion. Tim Hortons' cheese looked and tasted more like real cheese to me.

Overall, I found the food at Tim Hortons had a slight edge over Dunkin'. It just felt a little fresher and more natural to me, while the muffin and cheese, in particular, stood out as better.

The soggy bread at Dunkin' lost points for me. Sophie-Claire Hoeller/Insider

I also tried Tim Hortons' doughnuts for another taste test, and preferred those over Dunkin' as well. I find that the doughnuts at Dunkin' usually leave an artificial aftertaste in my mouth, and a film on my tongue, which Tim Hortons' doughnuts did not.

Overall, I found the food at Tim Hortons had a slight edge over Dunkin'. It just felt a little fresher and more natural to me, while the muffin and cheese, in particular, stood out as better.

As for the coffee, it's a tie. Both chains offer a solid and easily drinkable, if unremarkable, cup.

Both Tim Hortons and Dunkin' have good coffee. Sophie-Claire Hoeller/Insider

If push came to shove, I'd pick Dunkin' for coffee, because it was maybe a smidge stronger and less sweet, though many people prefer their coffee on the milder and sweeter side.

Generally speaking, I think Tim Hortons offers way more bang for your buck, though, as it was significantly cheaper than my Dunkin' order.

Canada has a cheap fast-food chain famous for its poutine, and it's actually very good

I had the best poutine in Quebec City at a burger joint, and it tasted surprisingly gourmet

I slept in an ice hotel that's a consistent 23 degrees, and the cold was surprisingly not an issue

After years of traveling, I went on my very first cruise and found it was a totally different way of seeing the world

If push came to shove, I'd pick Dunkin' for coffee, because it was maybe a smidge stronger and less sweet, though many people prefer their coffee on the milder and sweeter side.

Generally speaking, I think Tim Hortons offers way more bang for your buck, though, as it was significantly cheaper than my Dunkin' order.

Canada has a cheap fast-food chain famous for its poutine, and it's actually very good

I had the best poutine in Quebec City at a burger joint, and it tasted surprisingly gourmet

I slept in an ice hotel that's a consistent 23 degrees, and the cold was surprisingly not an issue

After years of traveling, I went on my very first cruise and found it was a totally different way of seeing the world

8 easy dishes from Michelin-starred chefs when you're cooking for one

Cookies on the Business Insider India website

I got the same breakfast at Tim Hortons in Canada and Dunkin' in the US to see how they stack up

In terms of décor, I found Tim Hortons and Dunkin' to be incredibly similar.

I ordered an iced coffee with milk, black hot coffee, English muffin breakfast sandwich, and hash brown at each.

Tim Hortons' iced coffee was absolutely delicious, but not at all what I expected. It was incredibly sweet and tasted more like a Frappuccino than a regular iced coffee.

The hot coffee at Tim Hortons was super hot when it came out. Once it cooled, it was easy to drink: not too strong, smooth, maybe a touch watery. A solid cup, but nothing to write home about.

The hash brown was good: crispy on the outside, and soft on the inside.

The English muffin with egg, cheese, and bacon did not have a lot of meat, unfortunately, but it was still good on the whole.

The iced coffee at Dunkin' was a lot more like the iced coffee I am used to: slightly bitter, but unobtrusive enough to be easy to drink.

I found the regular coffee at Dunkin' was very similar to that at Tim Hortons. It was mild, smooth, and unremarkable — but in a good way.

Instead of the single hash brown I was expecting, my Dunkin' order came with six little ones. While less crispy than the hash brown at Tim Hortons, these were better seasoned, in my opinion.

I got a ham, egg, and cheese English muffin breakfast sandwich at Dunkin', as the fast-food chain doesn't have a bacon version on its menu. While the egg was really good, the bread was way too squishy for my liking.

Overall, I found the food at Tim Hortons had a slight edge over Dunkin'. It just felt a little fresher and more natural to me, while the muffin and cheese, in particular, stood out as better.

As for the coffee, it's a tie. Both chains offer a solid and easily drinkable, if unremarkable, cup.