+

Cookies on the Business Insider India website

Business Insider India has updated its Privacy and Cookie policy. We use cookies to ensure that we give you the better experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we\'ll assume that you are happy to receive all cookies on the Business Insider India website. However, you can change your cookie setting at any time by clicking on our Cookie Policy at any time. You can also see our Privacy Policy.

Close
HomeQuizzoneWhatsappShare Flash Reads
 

ZUGZWANG: 'China arguably has 6 to 12 months before FX reserves fall below comfort levels'

Feb 23, 2016, 17:06 IST

Some of the Lewis Chessmen, which are made from walrus ivory and whales' teeth and were discovered in 1831 on the Isle of Lewis in the Outer Hebrides, are pictured on display at the National Museum of Scotland in Edinburgh, Scotland April 30, 2014. Eleven of the ancient chess pieces dated from 1150-1200 AD, are kept at the National Museum of Scotland, and 82 are in the British Museum. Scottish separatists are closing the gap on their unionist rivals as a September independence referendum draws nearer, according to a poll. But pollster TNS said it would still be a &quotmajor task" for them to draw level in time. In a poll of 995 adults, TNS found that support for the pro-independence campaign had grown by two points to 32 percent compared with last month, while the campaign to reject independence had slipped back a point to 41 percent. In the run-up to the vote, Reuters photographer Suzanne Plunkett took a series of close-up pictures of food, drink and various objects typically associated with Scotland. Picture taken April 30, 2014.REUTERS/Suzanne Plunkett
REUTERS/Suzanne PlunkettSome of the Lewis Chessmen, which are made from walrus ivory and whales' teeth and were discovered in 1831 on the Isle of Lewis in the Outer Hebrides.

The long, grinding economic slowdown in China is coming to a head, and the country has entered a "zugzwang," according to Barclays analysts Ajay Rajadhyaksha and Jian Chang:

Advertisement

In chess, the concept of zugzwang refers to a point in the game where any change in the status quo weakens a player's position. The ideal choice would be to not make a move, except that "pass" is not an option.

This concept effectively explains the choices that confront China's policy makers, who will have to make a decision about the country's currency and monetary policy in the next few quarters. None of the choices are terribly appealing, and all carry risks for financial markets.

That decision - whether to move interest rates, manipulate the value of the renminbi, or stop printing money - is being forced by the declining base of China's foreign currency reserves (the foreign money its central bank uses to trade its own currency and bonds, and that of other countries).

This is how fast China's reserves have gone down recently:

Advertisement

  • China's reserves declined by $500 billion in 2015.
  • They now sit about $750 billion below their 2014 peak.
  • Reserves declined by about another $300 billion in the last three months.
  • Currently, reserves are about $3.2 trillion, according to Barclays.

"China still has $3.2trn in FX reserves, which is a very large number. However, it is not infinite," the Barclays analysts say.

China's economy is so massive that if only 4% of Chinese were to move $50,000 out of the country in a single year (for instance, to protect it from devaluing as the RMB collapses) then "the hypothetical capital outflows would theoretically wipe out the entire remaining stock of foreign reserves."

That scenario is unlikely, Rajadhyaksha and Chang say, because it would require the People's Bank of China to adopt a suicidal defence of the RMB that would trigger a run on the bank until its FX reserves hit zero. However, it is plausible that China's reserves might continue to deplete as capital flees the country, bringing China nearer to the bottom of the "cushion" that reassures everyone that China can still defend its currency if it needs to. That "cushion" isn't very far away, they say:

The IMF has developed a formulaic approach to estimate a safe level of a country's FX reserves. Based on that, a safe level for China is USD2-2.75trn (Figure 7). We do not know the level of FX reserve decline the PboC is comfortable with; perhaps the answer is $2trn or perhaps it is $2.5trn. Our point is that most of the $3.2trn is not pure "cushion." If we are right that the pace of money creation is driving capital outflows, there is no reason to expect outflows to suddenly slow down; we believe further outflows are "baked in the cake." At the current pace of FX reserve decline, China arguably has six to 12 months before FX reserves fall below comfort levels.

China has three options for dealing with this, none of them good. (Hence the zugzwang.)

Advertisement
  • The PBOC could enforce capital controls, preventing Chinese from moving money abroad. That type of solution is very rare and very unpopular, and likely not the bank's first choice.
  • China could tighten its interest rates upward. But that might hurt the economy and trigger a crisis anyway, because "when credit conditions tighten, defaults often jump exponentially," Barclays says.
  • China could allow the RMB to depreciate in moderation, to signal to investors that the currency has reached the bottom of it valuation and thus encourage investors to buy it, given that increases would appear to be coming in the future. But that policy might exacerbate capital flight as long as investors continued to believe the RMB was not in fact hitting bottom, but still had a way to go.

NOW WATCH: How Donald Trump used bankruptcy to stay rich

Please enable Javascript to watch this video
Next Article