Judge uses baseball analogy to explain why a cop who shot 15 times at an unarmed couple wasn't found guilty
Tony Dejak/Pool/Reuters
Brelo fired 49 rounds at Timothy Russell and his passenger, Malissa Williams, who were killed after a car chase through the city, according to The New York Times. Notably, The Times reports, Brelo fired at least 15 shots after reloading and climbing onto the hood of the couple's car - after the other officers had stopped firing.
While there were reports of gunfire coming from the car before the chase began, prosecutors argued that "the noise apparently was the result of the car's backfiring," according to The Times. On Saturday, 71 people were arrested in Cleveland during protests following Brelo's acquittal, according to Cleveland.com.
Even though Cuyahoga Common Pleas Judge John P. O'Donnell determined that Brelo fired shots at both Russell and Williams that would have killed them, Ida Lieszkovszky reports at Cleveland.com, he did not find that Brelo alone was responsible for their deaths - the basis for voluntary manslaughter.
"O'Donnell concluded that prosecutors failed to prove in both cases that Brelo's shots were the ones that ultimately killed the two people," Lieszkovszky reports.
Aaron Josefczyk/Reuters
The judge explained his ruling by citing an argument Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia made last year in the case Burrage v. United States, which concerned responsibility over a person's death from a drug overdose.
Basically, Scalia argues that there is a difference in the importance of a single home run between winning a baseball game 1-0 and winning 5-2. In the former score, it's clear that the home run is responsible for the team's win, but in the latter score, the home run "played a nonessential contributing role" in the game's outcome.
"If the effect - the baseball team's win in the analogy, Russell's death in this case - would have resulted even without the cause - the first inning home run in the analogy, Brelo's fatal shot in this case - then the result cannot be connected to the conduct beyond a reasonable doubt and the crime isn't proved," O'Donnell writes.
REUTERS/Aaron Josefczyk
Here's the full excerpt O'Donnell cites from Scalia's argument:
Consider a baseball game in which the visiting team's leadoff batter hits a home run in the top of the first inning. If the visiting team goes on to win by a score of 1 to 0, ever person competent in the English language and familiar with the American pastime would agree that the victory resulted from the home run. This is so because it is natural to say that one event is the outcome or consequence of another when the former would not have occurred but for the latter ... By contrast, it makes little sense to say that an event resulted from or was the outcome of some earlier action if the action merely played a nonessential contributing role in producing the event. If the visiting team wound up winning by 5 to 2 rather than 1 to 0, one would be surprised to read in the sports page that the victory resulted from the leadoff batter's early, non-dispositive home run.
You can read Judge John P. O'Donnell's full ruling at Cleveland.com.
NOW WATCH: These facts about Texas will blow your mind
- US buys 81 Soviet-era combat aircraft from Russia's ally costing on average less than $20,000 each, report says
- 2 states where home prices are falling because there are too many houses and not enough buyers
- A couple accidentally shipped their cat in an Amazon return package. It arrived safely 6 days later, hundreds of miles away.
- Foreign tourist arrivals in India will cross pre-pandemic level in 2024
- Upcoming smartphones launching in India in May 2024
- Markets rebound in early trade amid global rally, buying in ICICI Bank and Reliance
- Women in Leadership
- Rupee declines 5 paise to 83.43 against US dollar in early trade
- JNK India IPO allotment date
- JioCinema New Plans
- Realme Narzo 70 Launched
- Apple Let Loose event
- Elon Musk Apology
- RIL cash flows
- Charlie Munger
- Feedbank IPO allotment
- Tata IPO allotment
- Most generous retirement plans
- Broadcom lays off
- Cibil Score vs Cibil Report
- Birla and Bajaj in top Richest
- Nestle Sept 2023 report
- India Equity Market