There are 3 big problems buried in Tesla's annual report
Bill Pugliano / Getty
And after going through all 98 pages of the filing, analysts at Barclays found three big problems, which reaffirm the firm's view of Tesla's growth path.
Barclays thinks shows that progress is being made at Tesla, though things are "far from rosy."
Here's Barclays:
- Tesla is not only selling "build to orders" cars, but also selling cars available for immediate sale. While elevated finished goods inventory is somewhat a function of in-transit vehicles, it is also a reflection of a new strategy of holding new cars available for immediate sale (beyond loaners and showroom models), as well as potentially used cars. This is a departure from the past - indicating that Tesla production is not as much of a build-to-order model as it had been historically.
- Capital spending has been for Tesla Model S and Model X upgrades - not its big gigafactory. Capital spending data (as seen in "Construction in Progress" PP&E) indicates that Tesla is spending ahead of demand. However, with only $107mn of spend on the gigafactory to date, plus minimal spend on gigafactory/Model 3 reflected in R&D and SG&A, it is yet another reminder that Tesla has yet to realize the uptick in spend associated with the gigafactory and Model 3.
- Customer deposits now include pre-delivery prepayments. Whereas the customer deposit line has historically been a gauge of order activity, the inclusion of prepayments now makes it more difficult to gauge underlying order activity.
On the bright side, Barclays said that Tesla is making progress on some key product milestones, as stock grant data shows that the Model X Beta prototype is complete, while the Model 3 Alpha prototype is considered "probable of achievement." Barclays has "Equal Weight" rating and a $190 price target on Tesla shares.
This report on Tesla comes after analysts at Bank of America said last week that Tesla could be facing a huge collapse, writing: "We believe Tesla has seemingly managed to offset a steady stream of negative news and weak financial results by issuing long-term targets that, in our view, are often quite difficult to fathom."
Last week, Tesla's Model S was named the top pick by Consumer Reports for the second year in a row.
- Manchester United named world’s most valuable football club! MLS dominates top 50 list - the Messi effect?
- Rahul Dravid will have to reapply if he wants to continue as head coach after June: Jay Shah
- BPCL shares rally 5% after earnings announcement
- Markets bounce back in early trade on firm global trends; buying in ITC, Reliance
- Rupee trades in narrow range against US dollar in early trade