I visited Pompeii and its less touristy sister town Herculaneum in a day, and the experiences couldn't have been more different

Tom Murray in PompeiiTom Murray in PompeiiTom Murray / Business Insider

Despite its population's annihilation almost 2,000 years ago, Pompeii's streets still swell and hum with life every day of the year. Instead of Roman citizens, Pompeii now plays host to a constant flow of camera-snapping tourists from all corners of the globe.

The ancient ruins welcome some 15,000 visitors a day, but archaeologists are worried about the strain tourism is placing on this fragile site.

Pompeii is undoubtedly the most famous of Mt Vesuvius' victims, but Herculaneum is also located just 15 kilometers away, and has all the appeals of antiquity that makes it's larger relative so appealing.

I decided to book a 7-hour walking tour of the two cities on Airbnb Experiences in order to see how they compared. Unfortunately, I elected to do so in the midst of Europe's deadly heatwave.

Read more: I visited Pompeii in the middle of Europe's deadly heat wave, and I couldn't believe how many tourists braved the sweltering temperatures

While both towns were home to similar societies and got buried by the same volcanic eruption, visiting them in the 21st century couldn't have been a more contrasting experience.

Scroll down to see why.

{{}}

View As: One Page Slides

I arrived at Pompeii at 9:45 a.m. sharp, which allowed time to get tickets before our tour began at 10.

I arrived at Pompeii at 9:45 a.m. sharp, which allowed time to get tickets before our tour began at 10.

As an under-24 with a European passport, I got a massive and totally unexpected discount on my entry fee, paying €2 ($2) instead of the standard €15 ($17).

As an under-24 with a European passport, I got a massive and totally unexpected discount on my entry fee, paying €2 ($2) instead of the standard €15 ($17).

I'd booked a tour through Airbnb Experiences with Michele (pictured) who was an archaeologist as well as a guide for Pompeii and Herculaneum. I would fully recommend booking a guide when visiting these sites as, frankly, they're big, and Michele was able to efficiently take us around the most interesting areas and illuminate their significance in a way that a pamphlet never could.

I'd booked a tour through Airbnb Experiences with Michele (pictured) who was an archaeologist as well as a guide for Pompeii and Herculaneum. I would fully recommend booking a guide when visiting these sites as, frankly, they're big, and Michele was able to efficiently take us around the most interesting areas and illuminate their significance in a way that a pamphlet never could.

It's hard not to notice just how busy Pompeii is at the entrance. We crossed the first bridge into the ruins amid a cacophony of foreign languages, dodging selfie sticks and large backpacks.

It's hard not to notice just how busy Pompeii is at the entrance. We crossed the first bridge into the ruins amid a cacophony of foreign languages, dodging selfie sticks and large backpacks.

On a good day (depending on how you want to look at it), the ancient ruins welcome some 15,000 visitors. While the city's population boasted similar numbers in its prime, those residents weren't all coming and going on the same day, crowding around one artifact, or drinking from the same water fountain.

On a good day (depending on how you want to look at it), the ancient ruins welcome some 15,000 visitors. While the city's population boasted similar numbers in its prime, those residents weren't all coming and going on the same day, crowding around one artifact, or drinking from the same water fountain.

I would later be told that archaeologists were worried about the strain tourism was placing on this fragile site.

I would later be told that archaeologists were worried about the strain tourism was placing on this fragile site.

The first big stop inside the city walls is the forum, a vast piazza which was the center of social life in Pompeii.

The first big stop inside the city walls is the forum, a vast piazza which was the center of social life in Pompeii.

Centuries after its inception, the forum is still the nucleus of Pompeii. When I visited, it was a hubbub of tourists waiting for their guides, taking photos, and sheltering in the shade.

Centuries after its inception, the forum is still the nucleus of Pompeii. When I visited, it was a hubbub of tourists waiting for their guides, taking photos, and sheltering in the shade.

The forum is also home to some artwork. That statue behind Michele is not a period artifact, but a piece of modern art designed by Polish-French artist Igor Mitoraj who passed away in 2014.

The forum is also home to some artwork. That statue behind Michele is not a period artifact, but a piece of modern art designed by Polish-French artist Igor Mitoraj who passed away in 2014.

Something to remember about ancient ruins is just how little shade they provide. I had the misfortune of visiting Pompeii in the midst of Europe's deadly heatwave at the end of June, when temperatures were hitting close to 40 degrees Celsius (104 Fahrenheit).

 Something to remember about ancient ruins is just how little shade they provide. I had the misfortune of visiting Pompeii in the midst of Europe's deadly heatwave at the end of June, when temperatures were hitting close to 40 degrees Celsius (104 Fahrenheit).

Read more: I visited Pompeii in the middle of Europe's deadly heat wave, and I couldn't believe how many tourists braved the sweltering temperatures

Some prudent tourists had the foresight to bring umbrellas along with them ...

Some prudent tourists had the foresight to bring umbrellas along with them ...

... While others weren't prepared to let the heat stop them from snapping the perfect photo.

... While others weren't prepared to let the heat stop them from snapping the perfect photo.

Fortunately, Pompeii is dotted with water fountains where thirsty tourists line up to refill their depleted bottles for the umpteenth time.

Fortunately, Pompeii is dotted with water fountains where thirsty tourists line up to refill their depleted bottles for the umpteenth time.

Despite the oppressive heat, Pompeii was jam-packed with tourists. I couldn't believe how many people had decided to brave the sweltering temperatures in the name of culture. If I wasn't working, I certainly would have taken the day to hit the beach.

Despite the oppressive heat, Pompeii was jam-packed with tourists. I couldn't believe how many people had decided to brave the sweltering temperatures in the name of culture. If I wasn't working, I certainly would have taken the day to hit the beach.

One of the most popular sights in the forum was the city's grain stores, which are today filled with plaster casts of some of the city's dead.

One of the most popular sights in the forum was the city's grain stores, which are today filled with plaster casts of some of the city's dead.

Michele told us that many animals were able to sense the eruption before the humans and thus escaped. However, some animals, like this dog, were not so fortunate as they were kept by Pompeiians. You can still see the evidence of a collar around the neck of the dog, meaning it was chained up at the time of its death.

Michele told us that many animals were able to sense the eruption before the humans and thus escaped. However, some animals, like this dog, were not so fortunate as they were kept by Pompeiians. You can still see the evidence of a collar around the neck of the dog, meaning it was chained up at the time of its death.

While as many as 17,000 Pompeiians may have managed to escape the eruption, around 3,000 were either not able to or decided to try and stick it out. This man was evidently a slave due to the belt visible around his waist.

While as many as 17,000 Pompeiians may have managed to escape the eruption, around 3,000 were either not able to or decided to try and stick it out. This man was evidently a slave due to the belt visible around his waist.

Pompeii was conquered by the Romans in 89 BC and, as far as conquerors go, the Romans were pretty popular ones. That's because living conditions usually vastly improved under Roman rule, Michele told us. For instance, the Roman's introduced public baths like the one below, which had separate areas for men and women ...

 Pompeii was conquered by the Romans in 89 BC and, as far as conquerors go, the Romans were pretty popular ones. That's because living conditions usually vastly improved under Roman rule, Michele told us. For instance, the Roman's introduced public baths like the one below, which had separate areas for men and women ...

... And these thermopoliums, which are basically ancient fast food stalls where workers or those who could not afford private kitchens could stop for a quick fix.

... And these thermopoliums, which are basically ancient fast food stalls where workers or those who could not afford private kitchens could stop for a quick fix.

The Romans also made Pompeii a lot cleaner via the introduction of a drainage and sewage disposal system. These stepping stones from one sidewalk to another allowed Pompeiians to cross the streets without stepping in the sewage below.

The Romans also made Pompeii a lot cleaner via the introduction of a drainage and sewage disposal system. These stepping stones from one sidewalk to another allowed Pompeiians to cross the streets without stepping in the sewage below.

They also had a sneakier, more lucrative purpose. Michele told us that because of the distance between each stone, foreign carts would not have the right dimensions to pass between them. Therefore, they would have to pay a Pompeiian driver once they reached the city to transport their goods within. You can still see the grooves made by wheels in the road today.

They also had a sneakier, more lucrative purpose. Michele told us that because of the distance between each stone, foreign carts would not have the right dimensions to pass between them. Therefore, they would have to pay a Pompeiian driver once they reached the city to transport their goods within. You can still see the grooves made by wheels in the road today.

Not all Roman innovations had a positive influence on the city. There was at least one brothel or Lupanar, meaning wolf den, which you can still see today.

Not all Roman innovations had a positive influence on the city. There was at least one brothel or Lupanar, meaning wolf den, which you can still see today.

Michele told us that the beds were designed to be uncomfortable so that clients wouldn't overstay their welcome.

Michele told us that the beds were designed to be uncomfortable so that clients wouldn't overstay their welcome.

Frescos depicting erotic scenes are still clearly visible on the walls.

Frescos depicting erotic scenes are still clearly visible on the walls.

Pompeii was a wealthy city in its heyday with plenty of large, stately houses. The largest is the House of the Faun, named after the statue in the front courtyard.

Pompeii was a wealthy city in its heyday with plenty of large, stately houses. The largest is the House of the Faun, named after the statue in the front courtyard.

Mosaics were a great indicator of wealth back in Roman times, so it's only fitting that the House of the Faun had one of the most impressive, depicting the Battle of Issus between Alexander the Great and Darius III of Persia.

Mosaics were a great indicator of wealth back in Roman times, so it's only fitting that the House of the Faun had one of the most impressive, depicting the Battle of Issus between Alexander the Great and Darius III of Persia.

The house still serves its primary purpose today: impressing lots of visitors.

The house still serves its primary purpose today: impressing lots of visitors.

Some things haven't changed much since the Roman era. This entrance mosaic depicts a fearsome dog with the inscription 'Cave Canem' — Latin for 'beware of the dog.'

Some things haven't changed much since the Roman era. This entrance mosaic depicts a fearsome dog with the inscription 'Cave Canem' — Latin for 'beware of the dog.'

After 3 hours exploring Pompeii in the oppressive heat, it was time to break for lunch before making the short hop over to Herculaneum by train.

After 3 hours exploring Pompeii in the oppressive heat, it was time to break for lunch before making the short hop over to Herculaneum by train.

The restaurants near Pompeii's exit were unsurprisingly crammed with tourists, many of whom were just sheltering from the sun. Despite the abundance of tourists, the restaurants were unexpectedly good value — I had a freshly-made pizza nearby for $5 that easily surpassed some I could have bought back home for three times the price.

The restaurants near Pompeii's exit were unsurprisingly crammed with tourists, many of whom were just sheltering from the sun. Despite the abundance of tourists, the restaurants were unexpectedly good value — I had a freshly-made pizza nearby for $5 that easily surpassed some I could have bought back home for three times the price.

After lunch, it was finally time to make our way to the second destination on the itinerary: Herculaneum.

After lunch, it was finally time to make our way to the second destination on the itinerary: Herculaneum.

Herculaneum welcomes about a tenth of the visitors that Pompeii does every year — and the difference was immediately noticeable.

Herculaneum welcomes about a tenth of the visitors that Pompeii does every year — and the difference was immediately noticeable.

Source: The Local.

The quiet entrance was a stark contrast to the crowds queueing at its sister town.

The quiet entrance was a stark contrast to the crowds queueing at its sister town.

I could have spent all afternoon in the cool, air-conditioned gift shop. The mosaic on the floor reading 'have' means welcome in Latin.

I could have spent all afternoon in the cool, air-conditioned gift shop. The mosaic on the floor reading 'have' means welcome in Latin.

While Pompeii was a living, breathing metropolis, Herculaneum was a resort town for the Roman elite, Michele explained.

While Pompeii was a living, breathing metropolis, Herculaneum was a resort town for the Roman elite, Michele explained.

It was immediately obvious how much deeper Herculaneum had been buried than Pompeii.

It was immediately obvious how much deeper Herculaneum had been buried than Pompeii.

According to mythology, Herculaneum was founded by — you guessed it — Hercules after he defeated the monster Cacus who stole his cattle.

According to mythology, Herculaneum was founded by — you guessed it — Hercules after he defeated the monster Cacus who stole his cattle.

Unlike Pompeii, Herculaneum had been buried under a vast mudslide caused by the eruption, not ash and lava, which was much more destructive. As a result, Herculaneum was much better preserved — just look at how vivid this fresco is ...

Unlike Pompeii, Herculaneum had been buried under a vast mudslide caused by the eruption, not ash and lava, which was much more destructive. As a result, Herculaneum was much better preserved — just look at how vivid this fresco is ...

... And this one depicting Neptune and Amphitrite.

... And this one depicting Neptune and Amphitrite.

Even some multi-story buildings like this one survived.

Even some multi-story buildings like this one survived.

After more than 5 hours walking around in 105-degree heat, half of our tour group decided to call it a day, and I couldn't blame them.

After more than 5 hours walking around in 105-degree heat, half of our tour group decided to call it a day, and I couldn't blame them.

In contrast to the streets of Pompeii that bustled with tourists, Herculaneum's streets were totally tranquil, with just a few people pottering around.

In contrast to the streets of Pompeii that bustled with tourists, Herculaneum's streets were totally tranquil, with just a few people pottering around.

Herculaneum did not have all the same luxuries as Pompeii like the stepping stones between sidewalks, meaning residents would essentially have to walk through open sewage in the streets.

Herculaneum did not have all the same luxuries as Pompeii like the stepping stones between sidewalks, meaning residents would essentially have to walk through open sewage in the streets.

There were some similarities between Pompeii and Herculaneum, though. Herculaneum also boasted public bathhouses, divided by gender with stunning mosaics.

There were some similarities between Pompeii and Herculaneum, though. Herculaneum also boasted public bathhouses, divided by gender with stunning mosaics.

Our tour of Herculaneum ended on a dark note at the town's boathouses.

Our tour of Herculaneum ended on a dark note at the town's boathouses.

Since Herculaneum was built on the sea, it was initially thought that almost all inhabitants had managed to escape, but this wasn't the case. In the 1990s, more than 300 skeletons were found in the boathouses, seemingly awaiting a rescue that never came.

Since Herculaneum was built on the sea, it was initially thought that almost all inhabitants had managed to escape, but this wasn't the case. In the 1990s, more than 300 skeletons were found in the boathouses, seemingly awaiting a rescue that never came.

80% of Herculaneum still lies undiscovered because modern-day Ercolano was built on top of it, and the government lacks the resources to buy residents out of their homes in order to continue excavations. There may be countless other lost treasures lying in wait beneath that town.

80% of Herculaneum still lies undiscovered because modern-day Ercolano was built on top of it, and the government lacks the resources to buy residents out of their homes in order to continue excavations. There may be countless other lost treasures lying in wait beneath that town.

VERDICT: Herculaneum stood out as the better tourist experience, but there's a reason Pompeii is so popular.

VERDICT: Herculaneum stood out as the better tourist experience, but there's a reason Pompeii is so popular.

It's hard to compare Herculaneum and Pompeii when the two were such different places — the former a resort town for the Roman elite and the latter a bustling metropolis with people from all walks of life.

On the day, Herculaneum was the better tourist experience. It was quiet, peaceful, and a much smaller area to cover in the sweltering heat. The superior preservation also brought you a tiny bit closer to feeling what life might have been like all those years ago than Pompeii did.

However, if I could choose to visit only one, I'd choose Pompeii. It may be crowded, but it's crowded for good reason.

While Herculaneum shows you how a specific sector of Roman society liked to spend their vacations, Pompeii offers a full cross-section of society, from the slaves to the nobilis.

While it's possible to visit both sites in a day, I wouldn't recommend it, especially at the height of summer — I finished the day exhausted, dehydrated, and sunburned, though with considerably more knowledge of ancient civilizations than when I started.

Subscribe to whatsappSubscribe to whatsapp
Add Comment()
Comments ()
X
Sort By:
Be the first one to comment.
We have sent you a verification email. This comment will be published once verification is done.