#10 Penny House Café
732 Washington Avenue, Brooklyn
Prospect Heights
It may be a hole-in-the-wall, but customers go nuts for Penny House’s breakfast sandwiches and bagels, especially with the spicy tuna salad, and the shop’s Brooklyn-y vibe.
“Loved the lox and cream cheese bagel—perfect proportions,” writes Yelp reviewer Rachel M. “What a delightful spot. Playing NPR with yummy food and air conditioning? Yes please!”
Note: Yelp's search results are based on an algorithm that is designed to provide the best results based on a number of different factors including review text, ratings, and number of reviews. Because several factors are taken into account, this is why you may see a 3.5-star restaurant with 500 reviews showing above a 4-star one with 15 reviews.
#9 Murray's Bagels Chelsea
242 8th Avenue
Chelsea
The slogan for Murray’s Bagels is “we don’t toast.” That just goes to show how fresh their bagels are.
Try their new David Burke special, says Allison S. Named for the famous chef, it’s “their traditional lox but with ‘pastrami salmon.’ Gives it more a cured-salty taste. Absolutely satisfying.”
Note: Yelp's search results are based on an algorithm that is designed to provide the best results based on a number of different factors including review text, ratings, and number of reviews. Because several factors are taken into account, this is why you may see a 3.5-star restaurant with 500 reviews showing above a 4-star one with 15 reviews.
#8 Barney Greengrass
541 Amsterdam Avenue
Upper West Side
Barney Greengrass may not sound like the name of a bagel shop, but don’t let that stop you from enjoying a bagel with some of their specialty fishes like lox, whitefish, or tuna.
“The whitefish salad here on an everything bagel will CHANGE your life,” raves Michelle L. And just as an added perk, scenes from the movie “You’ve Got Mail” were filmed here.
Note: Yelp's search results are based on an algorithm that is designed to provide the best results based on a number of different factors including review text, ratings, and number of reviews. Because several factors are taken into account, this is why you may see a 3.5-star restaurant with 500 reviews showing above a 4-star one with 15 reviews.
#7 Bagels on the Square
7 Carmine Street
West Village
Bagels on the Square is a no-nonsense shop; customers love quick, efficient service, and the bagels made while they wait.
“Pure NY bliss,” says Luxury P. “There are no good bagels in L.A. We all know it's the water. Whenever I go to NY, I bring back at least a dozen bagels.”
Note: Yelp's search results are based on an algorithm that is designed to provide the best results based on a number of different factors including review text, ratings, and number of reviews. Because several factors are taken into account, this is why you may see a 3.5-star restaurant with 500 reviews showing above a 4-star one with 15 reviews.
#6 David's Bagels
273 1st Avenue
Stuyvesant Town
With so many young professionals moving into the Stuy Town neighborhood, David’s Bagels is conveniently located for a quick bagel pick-up on the way to work.
"I've been going to David's Bagel for over ten years... Two location changes later, I still got to David's Bagels even though there are two bakeries between my apartment and their current location,” wrote Ed L.
Note: Yelp's search results are based on an algorithm that is designed to provide the best results based on a number of different factors including review text, ratings, and number of reviews. Because several factors are taken into account, this is why you may see a 3.5-star restaurant with 500 reviews showing above a 4-star one with 15 reviews.
#5 H&H Midtown Bagels East
1551 2nd Avenue
Upper East Side
H&H may as well be an abbreviation for “bagels.” This staple New York bagel joint simply makes all-around great bagels.
“I'm from California, and I never really understood this whole 'NYC bagels are the best' talk until I came to H&H bagels,” writes Christine L. “They are incredibly tasty.”
Note: Yelp's search results are based on an algorithm that is designed to provide the best results based on a number of different factors including review text, ratings, and number of reviews. Because several factors are taken into account, this is why you may see a 3.5-star restaurant with 500 reviews showing above a 4-star one with 15 reviews.
#4 Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company
286 8th Avenue
Chelsea
Customers rave about the quality of the bagels and the variety of cream cheeses and spreads at the Chelsea branch of Brooklyn Bagel (which ironically has no locations in Brooklyn).
“I'd make the trip from Philly to New York just to hit up Brooklyn Bagel,” Amina W. said. “Anytime I'm in the city I have to stop in here, and sometimes I'll get a dozen and pop them in the freezer. Not nearly as good as fresh, but I've gotta get my fix somehow.”
Note: Yelp's search results are based on an algorithm that is designed to provide the best results based on a number of different factors including review text, ratings, and number of reviews. Because several factors are taken into account, this is why you may see a 3.5-star restaurant with 500 reviews showing above a 4-star one with 15 reviews.
#3 Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company
35-05 Broadway, Queens
Astoria
Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company comes so highly recommended that both of its locations made the list.
“I love this place,” writes Joan H. “It's just got some super high quality bagels and amazing cream cheese choices.” Not to mention their cream cheese flavors of the week, which ranges in flavors from salted caramel to Snickers to cherry habañero.
Note: Yelp's search results are based on an algorithm that is designed to provide the best results based on a number of different factors including review text, ratings, and number of reviews. Because several factors are taken into account, this is why you may see a 3.5-star restaurant with 500 reviews showing above a 4-star one with 15 reviews.
#2 Ess-A-Bagel
831 3rd Avenue
Midtown East
Ess-A-Bagel is a longtime family establishment with lots of bagel and shmear choices. The line out the door is only a testament to how popular it really is.
“This place represents to me what a Bagel shop should look like and what a bagel should taste like,” raves Mohammed K.
Note: Yelp's search results are based on an algorithm that is designed to provide the best results based on a number of different factors including review text, ratings, and number of reviews. Because several factors are taken into account, this is why you may see a 3.5-star restaurant with 500 reviews showing above a 4-star one with 15 reviews.
#1 Absolute Bagels
2788 Broadway
Upper West Side
“PERFECT bagels,” says Brieann A. “[They’re] soft, doughy. Lots of selection in terms of type of bagel and spreads. Generous serving, especially considering the price. Ideal for grab and go.”
Fans of Absolute Bagels recommend going before lunchtime when the bagels are freshest and the line isn’t too long.
Note: Yelp's search results are based on an algorithm that is designed to provide the best results based on a number of different factors including review text, ratings, and number of reviews. Because several factors are taken into account, this is why you may see a 3.5-star restaurant with 500 reviews showing above a 4-star one with 15 reviews.
