I can't believe I'm typing this in the year of our lord 2023, but no one should feel entitled to comment on their partner's makeup choices or demand that their partner present in a certain way, least of all an American flag-obsessed man.
Taylor has every right to wear as much (or as little!) makeup as she chooses, and JP just should have been flattered that she wanted to look good for him, end of story.
This was the cherry on top of a whole host of red flags, and the most egregious one by far. Men, please do everyone a favor and keep any comment about your partner's appearance — that's not a glowing compliment, that is — to yourselves.