We've reviewed more than 40 sedans - these were the ones that impressed us the most

Advertisement

Kia Stinger

Kia Stinger

Here's what I had to say about the $52,000 test car in our review:

The Stinger takes things to a whole new level. This is easily the best car Kia has ever made, but more than that, it's among the best cars of its type that I've driven. The comparison that jumped immediately to mind was the Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio, a 505-horsepower beast that was a finalist for Business Insider's 2017 Car of the Year.

Advertisement

BMW 7-Series

BMW 7-Series

We were impressed enough the say in our review that the $90,000 bimmer is "easily the finest 7 Series that BMW has ever built."

Plus, we named it a finalist for our 2015 Car of the Year. The new 7-Series is basically incredible. Crammed with technology and capable of BMW-level performance and pure cruising comfort, it has reset expectations for what is probably BMWs history least-loved car.

Advertisement

Audi A4

Audi A4

In our review of a $52,000 tester, BI's Ben Zhang wrote that the "Audi A4 is everything you could want in a modern compact luxury sedan," adding that "it's the best car Audi has ever made."

The A4 was a finalist for BI's 2017 Car of the Year. It was also one onf those cars that we unanimously adored. We literally couldn't find anything wrong with it. Nothing.

Volvo S90

Volvo S90

Our tester was the T6 AWD Inscription, a top trim level, priced at over $66,000 with plenty of options.

In our review, we said that the "S90 is a meaningful departure from the good-old Volvo's of yesteryear and a solid update of the brand's cars from the 2000s and 2010s. But it also has an abundance of Nordic reserve."

Volvo has been making a play to join the upper levels of the luxury market, after occupying a sort of sub-niche for decades. The S90 make a strong case for that strategy.

Advertisement

Buick LaCrosse

Buick LaCrosse

When I tested a LaCrosse that came in a just under $50,000, I was charmed:

I'm not sure Buick can produce a better sedan than this, for around $50,000 with plenty of options. With the brand now more than saved — an "Avenir" sub-brand to serve up more luxurious trim levels is the next step — it's been perfected, in its latest incarnation.

And the market was ready for a very good Buick. Not everyone wants a stiff, high-strung German luxury car. Buyers both young (but not too young) and old appreciate the Great American Car aspect of a vehicle like LaCrosse. It's a deeply satisfying set of wheels.

BMW 5-Series

BMW 5-Series

Our test car was about $72,000. And worth it.

"The new 5-Series is, simply put, excellent," I said in my review. "It's a lovely freeway cruiser, but it can go all BMW and stiffen up, rewarding a driver who wants to tuck into some corners. The steering could be crisper, but that's nitpicking."

And I added: "What we have here is a literally perfectly boring car. BMW has had decades to set the bar, and it has gotten very good at that responsibility to the legacy of the 5-Series. It cannot disappoint, and it doesn't."

Advertisement

Porsche Panamera

Porsche Panamera

It must be pretty good. The Panamera was our 2017 Business Insider Car of the Year.

"It's a cliché to suggest that a car can make you a different person, but that Panamera makes good on that promise," we wrote.

"It looks good, feels good, sounds good. As with all great machines, the thrill is a combination of the visceral and the cerebral. Everything about the Panamera says quality and the engineering is beyond world class. When you drive the car, you know why many people think Porsche is the best automaker on the planet."

It will set you back anywhere from $85,000 to $180,000, depending on trim level and options.

Cadillac CT6 plug-in hybrid

Cadillac CT6 plug-in hybrid

This is what we call a sleeper Caddy. The non-hybrid CT6 is the flagship. But the hybrid is the secret weapon.

"I typically don't make purchasing recommendations, but if I were going to buy a Caddy, and I wasn't going for something bonkers like the Corvette-with-four-doors CTS-V, I'd get the CT6 plugin," I wrote in my review.

"It has everything the regular CT6 does, plus excellent MPG numbers. And at less than $80,000, with Cadillac's premium appointments, a nice big back seat, and GM's industry-leading suite of infotainment and connectivity features, it's an excellent value even before you add up the fuel savings."

Advertisement

Lincoln Continental

Lincoln Continental

Speaking of flagships, how about this American classic?

Our tester came in at $72,000, well-options, and was a runner-up for our 2016 Car of the Year. What did I think?

"I decompressed with every minute I spent behind the wheel of the new Continental, and over the hours I was consumed by a Zen-like state of emotional and intellectual clarity," I wrote in my rave review. "Did I want to sling this big sedan around corners? Nope. But it isn't made for that. The 7-Series and, to a degree, the CT6 are."

And I added: "But the Lincoln Continental doesn't go there. It doesn't need to. It never went there even before it went away for a little while. This car is for the smooth rollers in life. And if you aren't a smooth roller, the Continental might make you want to be one."

Acura TLX A-Spec

Acura TLX A-Spec

The Acura TLX A-Spec was a surprise contender for 2017's Car of the Year.

"The TLX A-Spec offers a convincing alternative to a BMW 3-Series with comparable options, given that everything can be had standard for the just a scooch more than $45,000, with the only uptick from the $44,800 ticker being the $950 destination charge," I wrote in my review.

"This is how Acura greatness sneaks up on you. And it's why the brand should always be in the top-tier luxury conversation, even if it's rarely included in that club. I should have known that this would be one of the best cars we'd drive all year"

Advertisement

Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio

Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio

Woof! What a car! Again, a sedan — and a 2017 Car of the Year finalist.

Our tester was well-equipped, coming in a few grand under $80,000. I was smitten. In my review, I cited, "the savage growl of its glorious 505-horse six-banger" and noted that "there's Ferrari DNA in there ... this is the same engine that goes into the new twin-turbo V-8 in the 488 GTB, minus a pair of cylinders."

I also adored "the marvelously light and balanced feel of the car," adding that "the Alfa comes off as downright tossable in your hands. At 3,800 pounds, it isn't a featherweight, but its power-to-weight ratio is ideal and makes it drive like a leaf on the wind."

Cadillac CTS-V

Cadillac CTS-V

We'll make it an even dozen with the four-door Corvette, the mighty Caddy CTS-V.

Our tester was $85,000, and it was something special.

"Cadillac has been working on taking it to BMW's M cars for some time now, and with the CTS-V ... well, it may have taken it PAST the M's," I wrote in my review.

"The CTS-V bears no resemblance to the Caddys of the Carter and Reagan administrations, and it has grabbed the sports-sedan concept and pushed it into new territory. You can now have your midlife crisis without embarrassing yourself."

Advertisement