$110, available at Everlane
I always feel like I look like I'm ready to take your drinks and appetizer order when I wear a regular button-down shirt, so I gravitate toward button-downs with embellishments. The tie cuffs on this shirt are exactly what I look for — they make it feel special without going over the top.
What's even more special is the construction of the shirt, which feels soft and drapes well. It was a heavier silk fabric than I expected, but still breathable. After washing it, it still felt as soft as the first time I wore it, and it didn't shrink. However, I was a little disappointed to see that it was wrinkly. Even if you follow Everlane's care instructions, I think experiences can really differ based on what types of laundry products you use, so I would just consider that before you buy the shirt. — Connie Chen, reporter
I've been on the hunt for a good silk button-down for a while now. You would think I would have found one by now, it's not that hard right? My problem is silk shirts skew pretty expensive and I always get less wear out of them than I'd like, simply because I'm too lazy to constantly make those trips to the dry cleaner. That said, I was really excited to try Everlane's washable silk.
I really like the style of this shirt. It fits well and the tie cuffs add some femininity to an otherwise simple silhouette. But the shirt didn't have the silky feel I was expecting. I have, and love, Everlane's Clean Silk Shirt ($98), which has that luxuriously light feel that I've come to expect from the fabric. This washable silk shirt is still obviously silk, but doesn't have as much of a lightweight, smooth feel.
After putting it through the wash, it didn't lose any shape, but it didn't feel as soft as the first wear. Ultimately, this is a really cute shirt and I'll definitely wear it again, but I wasn't really impressed by the washable silk aspect. If you're looking for a classic silky shirt, I'd go for one of Everlane's regular silk options — they're high quality and relatively affordable. You'll have to go the extra step of getting them dry-cleaned, but I think it's worth it if a great silk shirt is what you want. — Remi Rosmarin, reporter