We shopped at TJ Maxx and Saks Off 5th to see which store is better for discount shopping - and the winner was obvious

Advertisement

First, we stopped by Saks Off 5th (which was actually off Lexington Avenue).

First, we stopped by Saks Off 5th (which was actually off Lexington Avenue).
Advertisement

The store advertised huge discounts, so we were excited to see the offerings.

The store advertised huge discounts, so we were excited to see the offerings.
Advertisement

We were floored by the regal architecture of the store. The tall marble columns on the sides of the main room were magnificent. This may have been a discount store, but it sure didn't look like one.

We were floored by the regal architecture of the store. The tall marble columns on the sides of the main room were magnificent. This may have been a discount store, but it sure didn't look like one.

We were greeted by a display of beauty products at the front of the store. We then made our way to the other sections.

We were greeted by a display of beauty products at the front of the store. We then made our way to the other sections.
Advertisement

If we didn't know, it would be hard to tell this store apart from a regular Saks Fifth Avenue. The store's design was as chic and as pricey as some other department stores.

If we didn't know, it would be hard to tell this store apart from a regular Saks Fifth Avenue. The store's design was as chic and as pricey as some other department stores.

Even the mannequins — bathed in neon pink light — looked trendy.

Even the mannequins — bathed in neon pink light — looked trendy.
Advertisement

We made our way to the handbag and purse collection. For the most part, the prices were still pretty high.

We made our way to the handbag and purse collection. For the most part, the prices were still pretty high.

This Valentino purse excited us until we saw the price tag — almost $350.

This Valentino purse excited us until we saw the price tag — almost $350.
Advertisement

These glass-enclosed purses looked nice. We couldn't find the prices on them, but our intuition told us they were probably expensive.

These glass-enclosed purses looked nice. We couldn't find the prices on them, but our intuition told us they were probably expensive.

The shoe section had every style from evening wear to sport.

The shoe section had every style from evening wear to sport.
Advertisement

But once again, the prices were through the roof. These platform loafers were listed for almost $600.

But once again, the prices were through the roof. These platform loafers were listed for almost $600.

Saks Off 5th felt like a regular department store through and through, from the prices to the design. We even heard a shopper mutter about not being able to tell the difference between this store and the regular Saks.

Saks Off 5th felt like a regular department store through and through, from the prices to the design. We even heard a shopper mutter about not being able to tell the difference between this store and the regular Saks.
Advertisement

Next, we headed to the clothing section. The quality here was high — and so were the prices. More than a few items were listed at over $1,000.

Next, we headed to the clothing section. The quality here was high — and so were the prices. More than a few items were listed at over $1,000.

Saks Off 5th had a huge selection for the regular department store shopper. For the bargain shopper, not so much.

Saks Off 5th had a huge selection for the regular department store shopper. For the bargain shopper, not so much.
Advertisement

As we left the store, it was hard to determine what made this Saks different from the original. Other than the location "off 5th," this store still felt like a regular department store and not a good fit for a bargain shopper.

As we left the store, it was hard to determine what made this Saks different from the original. Other than the location "off 5th," this store still felt like a regular department store and not a good fit for a bargain shopper.

Next, we stopped by the TJ Maxx in Manhattan's Financial District.

Next, we stopped by the TJ Maxx in Manhattan's Financial District.
Advertisement

From the moment we walked in, we could tell this was going to be different from our experience at Saks Off 5th. The store's design was more casual and looked the way we felt bargain shopping should.

From the moment we walked in, we could tell this was going to be different from our experience at Saks Off 5th. The store's design was more casual and looked the way we felt bargain shopping should.

We were immediately swept away in the racks of the store's main section. We sifted through the clothes in search of some deals. With hundreds of items to choose from, it wasn't hard to find something we liked.

We were immediately swept away in the racks of the store's main section. We sifted through the clothes in search of some deals. With hundreds of items to choose from, it wasn't hard to find something we liked.
Advertisement

We cannot say enough about the prices. We picked up this t-shirt for less than $5.

We cannot say enough about the prices. We picked up this t-shirt for less than $5.

There were also some name-brand items that had great prices. This Vineyard Vines t-shirt was less than $40.

There were also some name-brand items that had great prices. This Vineyard Vines t-shirt was less than $40.
Advertisement

And this Dooney & Bourke bag was only $99.99.

And this Dooney & Bourke bag was only $99.99.

The TJ Maxx Runway section in the center of the store had items on the more expensive side. This pink fluffy dress was $699.99.

The TJ Maxx Runway section in the center of the store had items on the more expensive side. This pink fluffy dress was $699.99.
Advertisement

But almost everything else in the store was a bargain. These pink gowns were only $49.99 and perfect for wedding season.

But almost everything else in the store was a bargain. These pink gowns were only $49.99 and perfect for wedding season.

The undergarments section was teeming with great finds. A lot of items here were less than $5.

The undergarments section was teeming with great finds. A lot of items here were less than $5.
Advertisement

We also found these funny shirts with references to "The Office."

We also found these funny shirts with references to "The Office."

Unlike Saks Off 5th, TJ Maxx had a huge selection of home goods. We loved the Coca Cola tub ($129.99).

Unlike Saks Off 5th, TJ Maxx had a huge selection of home goods. We loved the Coca Cola tub ($129.99).
Advertisement

Downstairs, we followed our noses to this selection of scented candles ...

Downstairs, we followed our noses to this selection of scented candles ...

... which then led us to this wall of wicker baskets.

... which then led us to this wall of wicker baskets.
Advertisement

Around the corner, we even found some food.

Around the corner, we even found some food.

The whole experience at TJ Maxx seemed engineered for the shopper in search of a quick bargain. There were even shopping carts available in some of the sections.

The whole experience at TJ Maxx seemed engineered for the shopper in search of a quick bargain. There were even shopping carts available in some of the sections.
Advertisement

We also found a phone-charging station in the middle of the store.

We also found a phone-charging station in the middle of the store.

TJ Maxx was the clear winner here. The plethora of options and unbeatable prices won us over. Next time we want to shop on a budget, we know where to go.

TJ Maxx was the clear winner here. The plethora of options and unbeatable prices won us over. Next time we want to shop on a budget, we know where to go.
Advertisement