These two charts show what's wrong with Trump's tax proposal

Advertisement
These two charts show what's wrong with Trump's tax proposal

President Donald Trump has promised "massive tax cuts" to help middle-income families.

Advertisement

But a report out Friday from the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center shows his tax framework actually raises taxes on individuals to give tax cuts to businesses:

tax reform chart

Tax Policy Center

Over a decade, Trump's plan would cut business taxes by $2.6 trillion (the red bars), and lose another $240 billion by repealing estate and gift taxes (the yellow bars). Then, it partly makes up for that by raising individual income taxes by $470 billion (blue bars).

Of course, businesses are ultimately owned by individuals, so those business tax cuts flow through to benefit people. Most economists will even tell you that a portion of the corporate income tax is borne by workers, whose wages go down when corporate taxes go up.

Advertisement

And you don't have to be rich to own a business. But unfortunately, the business tax preferences in Trump's plan are designed to provide almost no benefit to lower- and middle-income people who own small businesses.

The plan caps the tax rate on business profits at 25%. If you own your own business, you'd only benefit from the cap if you would otherwise be subject to a tax rate higher than 25%. And under this plan, you'd generally have to have a family income over $200,000 for that to be the case.

It's therefore no surprise that Trump's tax plan directs nearly all its overall benefits to the wealthy. That's in Figure 2:

tax distribution chart

Tax Policy Center

This is not a case of "well, of course rich people get the biggest slice of the tax cut - they have the biggest incomes." Overall, Trump's tax cut is big enough to raise Americans' after tax incomes in 2018 by 2%. But for the bottom 80% of the income distribution, the increase in after-tax income is only about 1% - an average savings of $530 per tax filer.

Advertisement

After-tax incomes of the richest 1% would rise by more than 8% on average - a saving of $129,030 per tax filer. That is, they get far more than their share of the tax cut.

And many people wouldn't get a tax cut at all. The Tax Policy Center says 12% of tax filers would see their taxes go up in 2018 because of the plan. I walked through one example of an upper-middle income family that would pay more. By 2027, 25% would face a tax hike, as inflation would eat away some of the benefits given to taxpayers in the first year.

It's pretty astounding to go around talking about the need for a middle-class tax cut and then produce a plan that reserves nearly all its benefits for the wealthy while raising taxes on tens of millions of middle-income Americans. But that's what Republicans have come up with.

Sad!