We asked 5 women of different shapes and sizes to try bathing suits from Swimsuits for All - here's how they reacted to the fits and styles

Pros: I like that this was a twist on the classic black swimming suit — it looked anything but basic. The fit was perfect but I did read the other reviews from the website and knew that I should size down.

What I liked about the Swimsuits for All website is that there were a lot of reviews and feedback from other plus-size people. The greatest concern from shopping for a swimsuit online is fit and it's even worse for plus-size people. It's nice to have advice and reviews from other real women who have bought and tried the swimming suit.

Cons: The three other swimming suits that I originally liked were sold out in my size, which was a bummer. —Shirley Cheng, INSIDER producer

I always want to buy one-piece suits like this, but I've been worried that they wouldn't have enough support in the chest since I have DDs. I knew if anyone was going to get it right, it'd be Swimsuits for All, and I'm happy to report that they did! The suit has built-in cup support, and though it's definitely not going to hold the girls up the same way a top with an underwire would, it at least provides enough to keep the girls in place. —Sally Kaplan, Insider Picks editor

As a plus-size woman, shopping for swimsuits always gives me a little bit of anxiety, so it was really nice to be able to look online. I was really surprised by how many different suits I actually wanted to buy — Swimsuits for All offered a lot of different styles that were all super cute and on-trend. When my selection came in the mail, I was really excited to try it on and I found that it fit perfectly. I couldn't wait to get out to the beach and show it off! —Hattie Weber, Insider Studios associate editor

Style, texture, and fit — this suit fires on all engines. I love the combination of the tie-front tank style with the ribbed fabric, which was on the thicker side and far from the cliche of a flimsy bikini. Accordingly, I felt totally comfortable splashing into the ocean or jumping around in the sand. Though I don't have a large chest, the underwire bra also helped me feel more supported and secure.

The color is a gorgeous blue that'll match clear summer skies well, while the double-strapped back makes the suit look even more interesting. It's fun having a range of swimsuit styles and colors to wear throughout the summer, but this one's definitely a favorite. —Connie Chen, Insider Picks reporter

Being a different size on top and bottom has always made it difficult for me to buy swimsuits. The top (size 20) fit great and it even surpassed the beach test and there was no swimsuit malfunctions! The bottom (size 14) is high waisted and fit right. It has a cute fold on top that made it look special and not as plain as a completely solid swimsuit bottom. —Jennifer Hernandez, Business Insider Intelligence customer success associate