11 rustic Airbnb cabins in the Catskills you can book for under $200 a night

Advertisement
11 rustic Airbnb cabins in the Catskills you can book for under $200 a night

log cabin catskills new york

Airbnb

A cozy Catskills cabin for under $200 a night? Yes please.

Advertisement
  • Fall is a great time to visit the Catskills for fall foliage, ample hiking, and outdoor activities.
  • Popular areas around Hunter, Windham, and Belleayre Mountains in New York are typically more affordable in fall, before peak ski and snowboard season starts.
  • We found highly-rated, rustic cabins on Airbnb you can rent on a weekend in October or November for under $200 a night.

Ski season is still a few months away, but that shouldn't keep you from curling up in a woodsy cabin, especially considering how many cozy Airbnb Catskills rentals are available for under $200 a night. More on that in a minute.

Autumn is also just a great time to visit the Catskills. The popular areas around Hunter, Windham, and Belleayre Mountains in New York are typically more affordable, and inventory is higher compared to peak winter ski season. And while you won't be able to hit the slopes just yet, you will enjoy colorful leaf peeping, hiking, and other outdoor activities most skiers and snowboarders miss.

The trip to the Catskills is roughly two-and-a-half hours from New York City by car, and many bus lines provide access as well. You may also take a train and then either rent a car, or call a rideshare to complete the trip. It feels a bit more remote than the Hudson Valley, but with just as much charm.

No matter how you arrive, you'll adore any of these cute cabins in the woods, selected based on the following search parameters:

Advertisement
  1. Airbnb listing is for the entire home (no awkward hallway conversations with your host).
  2. The home is available on a weekend. I looked a month out at October 27-29, and November 1-3. All were available to book as of publishing time.
  3. All are highly rated Airbnb listings in New York's Catskills with a review score of 4.5 or higher.
  4. Properties are all rustic cabins. Bring on the log, pine, and oak.
  5. Homes are affordable, and priced under $200 per night.

Keep reading to book any of these 11 Airbnbs for under $200 per night, starting with the least expensive

Subscribe to our newsletter.

Find all the best offers at our Coupons page.

Disclosure: This post is brought to you by the Insider Picks team. We highlight products and services you might find interesting. If you buy them, we get a small share of the revenue from the sale from our commerce partners. We frequently receive products free of charge from manufacturers to test. This does not drive our decision as to whether or not a product is featured or recommended. We operate independently from our advertising sales team. We welcome your feedback. Email us at insiderpicks@businessinsider.com.

{{}}

Log cabin in Margaretville, $97

Log cabin in Margaretville, $97
Book this log cabin for $97 per weekend night

I'm not sure what I find more exciting: the rustic chic look of this Airbnb cabin, or the fact that it's only $97 per weekend night. There's wide open availability in November, and well beyond. The massive deck and woodsy living spaces effortlessly blends nature with modern amenities. Writes one review, "We had such a wonderful time at this cute cabin in the woods. It felt like a real getaway to a secluded cabin in the wilderness, while being quite close to great restaurants and hikes. The front porch was the ideal place to lounge after a day in the woods. Would recommend to anyone!"

Rating: 4.91

Log cabin in Arkville, $126

Log cabin in Arkville, $126
Book this log cabin for $126 per weekend night

This cabin is everything I hoped for when searching out a log home: classic mahogany exterior, rich wood walls, and knotted pine fixtures. There's so much wood in fact, that a few white walls almost look misplaced. If you really want to hole up in winter, book now. The extremely reasonable rate is currently available in winter too, and the schedule is wide open in January and February. A Catskills rarity!

Rating: 4.96

Advertisement

Woodsy cabin in Willow, $141

Woodsy cabin in Willow, $141
Book this cabin in the woods for $141 per weekend night

This studio is no-frills lodging, perfect for the outdoor enthusiast who wants to disconnect in order to reconnect. The cabin has an environmentally conscience bathroom with a walk in shower, sink, composting toilet, and on-demand hot water. However, it's not totally roughing it — there's also a private wood-fired steam sauna, perfect for a chilly evening.

Rating: 4.93

Mountainside cabin in Mount Tremper, $154

Mountainside cabin in Mount Tremper, $154
Book this mountainside cabin for $154 per weekend night

Furnishings are simple but bright in this modern studio cabin. It's located stream-side, on the grounds of Mount Tremper Arts, an internationally recognized contemporary arts center. The home also borders 150 acres of Catskill Park land, with access to hiking right on property. The large deck, hammocks, and charcoal grill make it an ideal base for active mountain adventures.

Rating: 4.93

Advertisement

Microbrew cabin in Livingston Manor, $170

Microbrew cabin in Livingston Manor, $170
Book this microbrew cabin for $170 per weekend night

Here's one for the craft beer drinkers: a cottage nestled in a field behind the lauded Catskill Brewery. Formerly the brewmaster's residence, the small cabin is totally private, and available for rental. Ideal for a solo traveler or couple, there's a small, quaint farmhouse kitchen and queen bed. An abundance of sleek wood creates a Scandinavian feel, coupled with minimal decor and a neutral palette. Grab a brew and hunker down on the deck.

Rating: 4.67

Hiker's cabin in East Jewett, $176

Hiker's cabin in East Jewett, $176
Book this hiker's cabin for $176 per weekend night

Originally a barn from 1840, this historic cabin still sits on the original stone foundation. Three bedrooms comfortably fit groups into the beamed, loft-like space with wood-burning stove. Explore five acres of protected land filled with apple, ash, pine, oak, and maple trees, and loads of hiking. Fun fact: the stone steps are from the 1900s, and were built for dismounting from a horse carriage.

Rating: 4.97

Advertisement

Tiny home in Mount Tremper, $185

Tiny home in Mount Tremper, $185
Book this tiny home for $185 per weekend night

A tiny house seems tailor made for a Catskills getaway, and this sweet home feels especially idyllic. It's situated mere steps from a pond, wild mountain stream, and waterfall. Bring your pup to this pet-friendly Airbnb, and curl up by the antique wood stove, or under a blanket on one of the the lounge chairs. There's a kitchenette and eco-friendly bathroom, but no running water. Writes one review, "Loved this tiny cabin so much! The bedroom was my favorite part, with the skylight and beautiful wall of windows looking into the woods."

Rating: 4.96

Woodland cabin in Palenville, $190

Woodland cabin in Palenville, $190
Book this three bedroom cabin for $190 per weekend night

Unplug from the city in this three bedroom home nestled within lush Catskills foliage. If you do manage to venture out, you'll find hiking trails right outside your doorstep. Guests considered stays highly memorable, writing, "The raving reviews are justified, this place is awesome. The location is breathtaking, very well situated for adventure day trips and relaxation. The house is spotlessly clean and generously equipped with everything you need. The local guide by the hosts was excellent. One of the best Airbnb experiences we've had."

Rating: 4.98

Advertisement

Artist cabin in Windham, $195

Artist cabin in Windham, $195
Book this Windham cabin for $195 per weekend night

Your artist host designed this whimsical, custom-built abode with nature in mind. Walls, beams, and arches are all crafted with natural pine and hemlock wood for a soft look that's peaceful and light. Antique furniture, plush down pillows, barn wood stairs, and a propane stove set a soothing tone inside, while outside, the private stone courtyard with cast iron Norwegian wood stove, and bistro seating makes for a dreamy retreat.

Rating: 5.0

Cabin in Phoenicia, $198

Cabin in Phoenicia, $198
Book this log cabin for $198 per weekend night

Many Airbnbs are eye-catching, but verified Airbnb Plus listings take it to another level with expert design and details. Take this hideaway for example, with local flea market finds and statement decor. Every nook was tastefully curated, from framed art to patterned blankets. Raves one recent guest, "One of the coolest Airbnbs we've ever stayed in! This cabin is a retro mountain escape dream … The house is so charming and funky and really well equipped for any kind of getaway."

Review score: 4.94

Advertisement

Log cabin in Shandaken, $199

Log cabin in Shandaken, $199
Book this log cabin for $199 per weekend night

When you think of a log cabin, it probably looks exactly like this. Woodsy, homey, and transportive to another era, this Airbnb cabin delivers on a true mountain retreat. It's got much to boast about on the inside too, with a massive stone fireplace, three plush bedrooms, and chandelier light fixtures. Writes one review, "One of the best homes I have stayed in the Catskills ... The log cabin is very spacious, wel-maintained, and spotlessly clean. The host was very responsive and the location is central to many spots."

Rating: 4.89

Next StoryWeWork could cause a disaster for New York City's real estate market