Obama's 'Independent' Review Of Mass Spying Is Destined For Failure
On Friday, Obama announced that he would form a "high-level group of outside experts" to review intelligence and communications technologies. This group, Obama said, would be "independent" - able to step back freely - to review surveillance technologies and "consider how we can maintain trust of the people."It only took the weekend for much of any trust in that group to fade.
This is the same James Clapper who gave false information to Congress when asked whether the NSA was collecting data on Americans. He later apologized.Perhaps most interesting in Clapper's statement on Monday is the absence of wording used on Friday: independent, and outside. In an expanded statement, the White House said the group would present their interim findings to his office, and the final report would go "through the Director of National Intelligence."
"In practice - not theory - Clapper gets to chop the draft of the interim and final reports, and the Office of the Director of National Intelligence would - again, in practice - assist in selecting the members of the review group," Robert Caruso, a former assistant command security manager in the Navy and consultant, said in an email.This arrangement is sure to arouse suspicions, with many Americans showing distrust after leaks of previously unknown spying programs. Even Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.), a veteran politician and national security hawk, admitted as much to Fox News Sunday: "Right now there's kind of a generational change. Young Americans do not trust this government," McCain said. "Without trusting government you can't do a lot of things."
Still, Caruso believes there can be good to come from such a review. "I trust [Clapper] has the best intentions at heart." But on whether that final report would be transparent or heavily redacted, he told me, "we'll have to wait and see."
- After Bihar, now BJP promises free Corona vaccine in MP
- Sanofi, GSK to support COVAX with 200mn doses of Covid-19 vaccine
- Union Minister Smriti Irani tests positive for COVID-19
- Samsung overtakes Xiaomi to retake the smartphone crown in India
- Axis Bank is back in the black as fee collections ramp up and ₹10,000 crore in fund raising cushions the balance sheet