Here's the one big problem with China's supposedly amazing schools
Getty / Guang NiuChina has a reputation for having a rigorous education system, scoring number one out of 65 nations in the latest Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) test.
Fifteen-year-olds around the world take the PISA every three years, and it's become the gold standard of ranking nations in terms of educational strength.
In comparison to China, the US scored 36th in math, 28th in science, and 24th in reading on the last PISA ranking.
China's dominance on international standardized tests, coupled with its relatively cheap government spending on education, might make the country seem like one whose schools the US should emulate.
But Yong Zhao's book "Who's Afraid of the Big Bad Dragon?" takes a critical look major flaws in China's education system, arguing that its focus on test-taking can rob students of creativity.
"Chinese education produces excellent test scores, a short-term outcome that can be achieved by rote memorization and hard work," writes Zhao, who grew up in China and taught there, "but like the Chinese government itself, it does not produce a citizenry of diverse, creative, and innovative talent."
Chinese educational system excels at transmitting a narrow amount of content and prescribed skills that its students must master, Zhao argues.
Getty / Cancan Chu Chinese students put an outsize amount of time into mastering these skills. They have an average of 14 hours of homework a week, the most of any country measured by a study by the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD).
The US, for comparison, had an average of 6 hours per week.
This hard work isn't paying off in terms of innovation, according to Zhao.
A recent article in the Harvard Business Review expressed doubts that China could be a world leader in entrepreneurship due to the "bounded" education and political systems there.
And many think the Gaokao, China's most important university entrance exam, kills creativity and drive. Xu Xiaoping, a Chinese angel investor, believes this to be the case and also claims it will take at least 20 years for China to stop sending students overseas to learn how to be innovative, according to Venture Beat.
Zhao looks to another Chinese scholars' words on the matter to highlight this point.
"No one, after 12 years if Chinese education, has any chance to receive a Nobel prize, even if he or she goes to Harvard, Yale, Oxford, or Cambridge for college," Zheng Yefu, a professor at China's Peking University, said, according to Zhao's blog.
While that might be an overstatement, other scholars have noted the dearth of Chinese-educated Nobel Prize winners. In order for China to produce more Nobel Prize winners, "Chinese academia will need to modify their teaching styles to emphasize more creative problem solving, rather than the traditional approach that values ... memorization," the prominent statistician Howard Steven Friedman wrote in the Huffington Post.
The US shouldn't rush to adopt China's rote education methods, Zhao argues. For him, that's already happening with America's increased fixation on standardized testing. This focus on testing, he argues, reflects America's embrace authoritarianism.
A rush to look like China, he argues, would lead to "the loss of values traditionally celebrated by American education - values that helped make America the most prosperous and advanced nation in the world."
- I just got laid off from my dream job at Tesla without warning. I feel like my life got uprooted so a billionaire could save some money.
- Four-days work week, full and final settlement within 2 days of exit — new changes at workplaces to reflect from July 1
- Akash Ambani to head Reliance Jio - that’s just phase I of Mukesh Ambani’s succession plan
- OnePlus Nord 2T Review — A balanced all rounder at an affordable price
- Reliance Industries, ONGC, Vedanta and others slapped with windfall, export tax on petroleum
- Sena moves SC to suspend Eknath Shinde and 15 other MLAs
- Sensex sinks by 400 points in early trade on weak global cues
- YouTube rolls out new tools to combat spam and account hijacking